9. Does the verse in the Holy Qur’an, "O ye who believe! take not the Jews and the Christians for friends…" (5:52) forbid Muslims from making friends with any Jews?

Question-and-answer session, 14 August 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Does the verse in the Holy Qur’an, "O ye who believe! take not the Jews and the Christians for friends…" (5:52) forbid Muslims from making friends with any Jews?

In the Holy Qur’an, it says that one day, even the stones will turn over or something with the Jews, and if they're prepared, my grandfather...

Oh, must you always mention your grandfather?

Yes, please.

Says it's bad to make friends with them.

Make make friends with whom?

The Jews.

The Jews? The Jews?

Yeah.

No, no, I think he's wrong. He's misunderstood the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an says that those who are inimical or hostile to your religion—don't make... don't be... it's not said that don't be friendly to them. It says, don't make them bosom friends, so that they influence you wrongly, and you begin to take sides with anti-Islamic forces. This is what is prohibited. But to treat anyone kindly, with sympathy, with regard, is not only not prohibited in Islam, but it is imperative on you to treat all human beings with Rahmah, because Aan-Hazrat (saw) is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an as Rahmatul-lil-Alameen, and Jews are a part of Alameen.

Aan-Hazrat (saw) was so kind and so beneficent that in his time he was kind to the Jews of his time who were the most antagonistic to him. The Jews of today are not to be compared in hostility to the Jews of the time of Aan-Hazrat (saw), and they can't be compared in crime as well, because the present-day Jews hate us, ordinary small people. It is a crime, of course, but the Jews of Huzur-e-Akram (saw)'s time hated him, the very best, the very cream of things, the one for whose sake the whole universe was created. Yet he treated them kindly and he spoke nice words to them. He let them, in fact, sometimes insult him, and yet he was kind to them. He was kind to their alive, live, and he was kind to their dead as well.

Once a Jew, for instance, approached him and said, "Look here, O Muhammad, peace be upon him, you are not good in financial dealings. You are like your, the Quraish, other Quraish, and you are worse in financial dealings." Hazrat Umar, who was standing by, he got extremely annoyed, and he was about to strike him, and Rasulullah (saw) said, "Just stop it. Let him finish." He said, "You promised that you would return the money you borrowed from me on that date, and the day have come and you have not returned.

“So you are bad in your financial dealings.” So Aan-Hazrat (saw) said, “He is right. I had promised him, and this is the time, the time has not passed. So Umar, go and pay him the due, and pay him some extra, because he had to take the trouble to wait till the end.” And this is how Aan-Hazrat (saw) treated him.

Hazrat Umar was flabbergasted. He said, “Look here and look at him, he is insulting the very best of of of creation. And his servants are ready to offer their blood for the sake of his honor, and yet he is kindly to this insulting Jew, and very softly spoken to him.” So when he reached there and paid him the due, which was dues of the Jew, and paid him some extra money as well—and in dates, in fact, it was paid—then that Jew accepted Islam. And he said, “I have never seen a man more beautifully behaved and better in conduct than Aan-Hazrat (saw). So he must be right.” That was his treatment of the living Jew.

Of the dead, it is reported that once a corpse was being carried for burial, and when it passed by Aan-Hazrat (saw) where he was sitting with his companions, he stood up in respect. So some of his companions pointed out, “Ya Rasulullah, he is a Jew.” He said, “Yes, I know, he is a Jew, but he was a human being. You should show respect to human humanity.”

This is Islam, as we have learned from Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). We follow him, not the Mullah of today. If they preach hatred in the name of Islam, let them do it. You are not concerned; the Ahmadis will not follow him. The Ahmadis will follow their master, the master who was created as master for all times, that is, Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). We'll follow his conduct, and he, if he was kind to his enemies, we will be kind to our enemies.

Yeah, but, um—

Yeah, but what?

What about the bit where it’s in the Holy Qur’an Sharif where it says that the stones will turn over or something...

Huh?

...for the... when the... with the Jews?

Huh? Huh?

Qur’an Sharif mein to koi nahin hai.

What did... where... What does it say? I can't understand.

She says there is in the Holy Qur’an Sharif that the stone will turn over to the Jews.

No, not in the Holy Qur’an. It is in... in a in a book, in a tradition of Aan-Hazrat (saw), it is said that those Jews in the at the end at at the latter days, who would be fighting the Muslims, a time would come when those who hide them and give them cover would turn against them. This is the meaning of that tradition.

But it is neither here nor there. I mean, this is not related to the subject I am speaking of. Islam doesn't say that when you are fighting your enemy, you should spare the life of the enemy who has come to to kill you. That is not kindness. Kindness means in ordinary circumstances, in human relationship, you should be kind even to your enemies. But you have extended this to a situation of war. And that Hadith which you have quoted is speaks of a situation of war which which which are of which I am not speaking.

10 of 10 left today