1. Was the practice of retribution of "…the free man for the free man, and the slave for the slave, and the female for the female…" as mentioned in the Holy Qur’an (2:179), instated before or after Islam?
Question-and-answer session, 16 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Was the practice of retribution of "…the free man for the free man, and the slave for the slave, and the female for the female…" as mentioned in the Holy Qur’an (2:179), instated before or after Islam?
Al-Hurru bil-Hurri wa al-Abdu bil-Abdi wa al-Unsa bil-Unsa. Yes, yes, yes. One scholar said it's the instruction to the Muslims and the other one said this was the practice of the Arabs before Islam. So I was a bit puzzled. Ah, that which which one has said that it was a practice before Islam? Now it was in Ramadan, so more than a month. Was, was it an Ahmadi scholar? One of the scholars was Imam sahib and the other one was Which Imam sahib? of the London mosque. He present, he uh interpreted in the in the second way, the other I don't remember now who did it in which way. And the other Imam, who was he, who Well, he's not an Imam, he is sitting here. He said Naseer Ahmad? What was the explanation you gave? Go there to the mike, huh. Huzoor, I told him the translation which Hazrat Musleh Maud has mentioned in Tafseer-e-Sagheer. Yeah, right. And I explain, explained that translation as Huzoor has commented detail detail Yes, that that means that al-Unsa means the unsa. Yes, and the slave and the, exactly, that is the one you gave, you, yes, killed someone. Correct, the person who himself is is the culprit, yes, either that is hurr or 'abd or unsa, he will be killed. Yes, and what was the other explanation? That must have been forwarded by the Imam because there's only one person and one explanation are left now. The other explanation was that it was a practice before Islam that if the killed person was a slave, then in retribution a slave would be killed, and that was the un-Islamic practice which should be left. So what did he mean by saying that? That has it been adopted by the Holy Qur’an, or has it been mentioned just as a historical as a historical fact? Yeah, well, he said that this is what is condemned in in this this line. No, it isn't. That is wrong. This matter is to be further investigated, in my opinion. But the one explanation which has been given by Hazrat Musleh Maud, in my opinion, that is the best explanation so far. It holds water, it's logical, and it doesn't jar on human nature. But the other explanations, whichever they are, they are not fully satisfactory. Still, I feel that there is room for further exploration. And I was once thinking of concentrating on this issue myself. So that, Inshallah, I will do now, you have reminded me.