4. Is it a virtuous act for Muslims to attack Hindu temples since Abraham is believed to have also attacked temples of idol worship?

Question-and-answer session, 16 August 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it a virtuous act for Muslims to attack Hindu temples since Abraham is believed to have also attacked temples of idol worship?

I have a question in connection with the former question about Hazrat Ibrahim (as). Some Muslims say that it's a virtuous act to attack Hindu temples and destroy the idols, and they give the example of Hazrat Ibrahim (as).

Right. Did you ask this question before? Who did? I don't know. Exactly the same question was asked here in one of the sessions earlier, and I answered that.

The fact is that, to number one, Islam is a more developed religion in every respect than the earlier religions revealed. And there are certain things, certain attitudes of largesse and large-heartedness adopted by Islam, which were not adopted earlier, because the society in those days was much cruder, and the message suited the time, but it did not suit all times. So the incident which is mentioned here is relating to a much earlier period than Islam. That is one thing.

There is another point now which has to be solved, and I will discuss both together. Anhazrat (saw), when he was given access to Ka'bah and he entered Mecca as a conqueror, he himself broke the idols. And all the idols were broken and removed from Ka'bah. That is the second incident. So if you read both together, what should be the explanation?

Number one, as I mentioned, Hazrat Ibrahim (as) is known to have destroyed those idols, yet we know positively that at that time he was of young age. His Sharia had not been revealed to him. He was made a prophet earlier than the Sharia which he followed, because according to the Holy Qur’an, previously, he followed the Sharia of Hazrat Nuh, the law of Hazrat Nuh, and at about 50 years of his age, when the Sharia of Noah ended—according to the Holy Qur’an, it ended in 950 years—at that time, according to historical facts, Hazrat Ibrahim must have been 50 years old. When the previous Sharia ended, a new Sharia must have been revealed to him. And that was at the age of 50. And this incident, which is reported, is of a much earlier time, when he was young, and we have no traces of Noah's Sharia. So we don't know the circumstances, whether at that time he was acting within the four walls of the Sharia or acting like a youth who was just filled with the love of Unity, and he did it by way of argumentation, whatever you may call it.

So we are not responsible for that act which occurred long, long ago, before the, even before the Sharia of Hazrat Ibrahim (as) was revealed to him. And we know from the Holy Qur’an that sometimes, before the revelation of Sharia, a prophet can do something which Allah would not approve. But when it is told to him, made clear to him, then he repents.

The Holy Qur’an tells us that Allah does not permit His dear ones, those who follow Him, to pray for their idolater parents, deceased idolater parents. Yet Ibrahim did pray because he had promised his uncle or parents that he would pray for them. But when Allah revealed to him that Allah did not like this, he immediately ceased praying for them and repented his act. So this is the same Ibrahim; before Sharia, he thinks in his own terms and indulges in certain acts as he thinks good, pious acts, because praying for deceased parents appeared to be pious to him. Otherwise, he should never have vowed for this. And similarly, this act appeared to be pious to him before the Sharia was revealed to him.

That also shows—and they are very similar incidents in nature—that also proves the fact that in Noah's Sharia there was no mention, or at least he didn't know, that prophets are not permitted to pray for their deceased elders who indulge in idol worship. So both are incidents of similar nature.

So that much for Hazrat Ibrahim's (as) act of breaking the idols.

As far as Anhazrat (saw) is concerned, the reason is very obvious; there is no confusion about it. The fact is that Khana Kaaba was the first house of worship for Allah, not for idols, and this was misappropriated for a usage for which it was never built. It was reinstated. Anhazrat (saw) did not indulge in the large-scale massacre of idols because we hear no mention of Anhazrat (saw) breaking other idols in Arabia or telling people to break idols, because what he did was, he established the sanctity of places of worship, whether they were right or wrong, as such. And the Holy Qur’an very clearly enjoins upon Muslims to do that.

So his own act of breaking the idols was a limited act pertaining to that situation of Khana Kaaba having been filled with idols where they do not belong. And it was a wrong committed against the first house of Allah's worship, so it had to be rectified.

10 of 10 left today