5. Hudhur, my question concerns Hazrat Adam (as). Hazrat Adam (as) is described as the father of the present human race, or, as written in the Holy Qur’an: I appointed Adam as Khalifa. If he was the father of this race, over whom was he appointed Khalifa? Were there humans before him? – Secondly: when we read the Holy Qur’an, it says God forbade Adam to approach that tree and eat its fruit; he ate it and was led astray by Satan. This gives the impression that only after eating the fruit did circumstances arise by which human procreation began. What fruit was it, what was it that was forbidden?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 August 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Hudhur, my question concerns Hazrat Adam (as). Hazrat Adam (as) is described as the father of the present human race, or, as written in the Holy Qur’an: I appointed Adam as Khalifa. If he was the father of this race, over whom was he appointed Khalifa? Were there humans before him? – Secondly: when we read the Holy Qur’an, it says God forbade Adam to approach that tree and eat its fruit; he ate it and was led astray by Satan. This gives the impression that only after eating the fruit did circumstances arise by which human procreation began. What fruit was it, what was it that was forbidden?

Yes, that is right: before Hazrat Adam was appointed Khalifa, humans existed in great numbers. For Khalifa does not mean the first human. The Holy Qur’an also calls Hazrat David (as) Khalifa; then one would have to accept that at the time of David the humans before had been wiped out and came into being again. So the term Khalifa has no connection with being the first; rather, being Khalifa requires that people exist beforehand. As long as there are no people, over whom will he exercise Khilafat? When God made Adam Khalifa, it was proven that people existed before over whom God appointed him Khalifa. [On the second question:] The first matter is settled; I have answered it often before, it is asked very frequently. It is clearly proven from the Holy Qur’an – I am being brief now because I have answered in detail before – that Adam was not the first human. To infer from 'Khalifa' that he was the first human is wrong, because every prophet is a Khalifa of God, and about Hazrat David it clearly says: 'O David, We have made you a Khalifa in the earth.' So there were people before him, and Khalifa requires that people exist, otherwise over whom would he rule? That is done. The next matter is a different question: what was the tree whose fruit they ate? What do you think the tree was? [Questioner: My master, how can I decide on that?] No, you decide – I return the decision to you. [Questioner:] You had indicated in a previous answer that it was probably sexuality, because procreation began with it; this is the common interpretation. [Hudhur:] That interpretation is what I wanted to clarify: it is a wrong impression. Procreation was going on before; everyone knew it; even animals knew that procreation happens this way … [long section unintelligible, including on the meaning of Khalifa and Khilafat] … [English:] … generally speaking, that they committed a certain offence against the law of Allah, for which they were removed; even if you want to interpret it as a sexual offence – even then we don't know … [unintelligible] … And the philosophy of crime is this: when Allah makes His will clear to you, you do not violate that will, you do not break the law of Allah – that is crime, and that suffices for us. The nature of the particular crime is something Allah did not reveal to us, and we are not interested in knowing what happened. We only know that he worked against the will of Allah, and that's enough.

10 of 10 left today