8. Are Hindus and Buddhists considered to be a part of the "People of the Book" (Ahle-Kitab)?
Question-and-answer session, 30 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Are Hindus and Buddhists considered to be a part of the "People of the Book" (Ahl-e-Kitab)?
Sir, I want to ask about Ahl-e-Kitab. I mean, which nations are called Ahl-e-Kitab? Beg your pardon? Which nations or Ummahs are called Ahl-e-Kitab? And are Hindus and Buddhas are also Ahl-e-Kitab?
According to the definition of the Holy Qur’an, they are not called Ahl-e-Kitab. No, I am sorry. According to to the understanding of or interpretations of the verses of the earlier scholars, let us say, they are not called Ahl-e-Kitab. Because by Ahl-e-Kitab at the time of An-Hazrat (saw) were understood only two people: the people who were followers of Old Testament, that is the Jews, prior to Hazrat Isa (as), and people who are the follower of New Testament, that is the same Jews who believed in Jesus Christ (as), or others who believed in him and became Christians. They are called Ahl-e-Kitab.
But also, the Holy Qur’an has bracketed Sabi'een with Ahl-e-Kitab, when it mentions that such people's good act will not be wasted and sin, and they have Allah Ta'ala has mentioned Sabi'een as apart from the rest of idolaters. So they are bracketed with Ahl-e-Kitab.
This is a very interesting exception made in the Holy Qur’an. In fact, a new window is opened there, and people don't take note of this very important fact. Had this not happened, then the objection would arise that the Holy Qur’an limits itself to only a certain line of religious revelations, and although it claims that other religions were revealed elsewhere, the Holy Qur’an does not recognize them, and the concept of Ahl-e-Kitab is so limited that it applies only to a certain lineage and not to others.
But strangely in it is really surprising that Holy Qur’an does not leave any possibility unattempted, unattended. And this verse reminded me of this suddenly; when I read this, then I woke up to this reality: what a great book this is! Sabi' is defined in Arabic as a person belonging to a religion, to some prophets who are not the prophets of Israel, or non-Arab prophets. So that shows that the Sabi'een were also in fact included in the same writ, at least as far as treatment is concerned, as that of Ahl-e-Kitab. So this is why An-Hazrat (saw) was called Sabi', or and his followers, by his opponents—that they belong to some non-Arab religion.
So that shows that those religions who are proved to be belonging to certain prophets, and those religions whose teachings of unity of God is still preserved—because Sabi'een were also those who were not idolaters, who believed in Allah; that is also a definition of Sabi'.
So that means that any people who are proved to be belonging, to prove to be belonging to prophets of Allah, who believe in the message of prophethood, and this teaching is preserved in their book, although they have deviated in practice, yet they would be treated as Ahl-e-Kitab. This is my inference.
Now this is why, though Christians have become idolaters, yet their category of Ahl-e-Kitab has not changed. The verdict about those Christians, despite the fact that we know they have become idolaters—many among them—is not changed. That is to say, their original book does preserve the concept of unity of God, their official faith is unity of God, so even if within that they become sort of idolaters or similar to idolaters, they would be treated as Ahl-e-Kitab.
Now, if you accept this principle, then within Islam also such sects will be treated likewise who, to all our according to the best of our knowledge, have started behaving like Mushrikeen: those who bow to to to graves, call from I mean beg from the dead saints, and so on and so forth. According to certain sects of Islam, they are non-Muslims, they are idolaters, and should be treated as Mushrikeen. But from the inference which I have drawn, based not only on the present situation of Christians, but based on the situation which prevailed at the time of An-Hazrat (saw), it is not a new factor that has evolved that Christians, who were Ahl-e-Kitab, had suddenly become idolaters. At the time of An-Hazrat (saw), they had already started calling partners with God. This is why the Holy Qur’an says kaburat kalimatan takhruju min afwahihim. Everything was in the knowledge of Allah, and Allah had revealed this knowledge to An-Hazrat (saw), in the Holy Qur’an, in unambiguous terms.
So knowing that these people had started calling partners with Allah—let me rectify my term, instead of idolaters, at least we can say this much, that they had become Mushrikeen of some sort—yet they were treated differently from those Mushrikeen who did not emanated from a phenomenon of prophethood, who did not have a message declaring Allah's unity, whether it was deteriorated later on or not.
That is not concen- I mean, relevant here. So, this applies also to the Muslims of today. We are more magnanimous in our approach to these Muslims than Wahhabis, for instance. Wahhabis declare them to be Mushrikeen and want everybody else to treat them as Mushrikeen, so that they no longer enjoy the rights of Muslims within Islam. In fact, they debar them from human rights. They say they have become Mushrikeen, so they have no rights left whatsoever on on on the face of earth.
This is not our treatment. We say, because they belong to the Book, the Holy Qur’an, which declares and affirms the unity of God, and because they believe in the phenomenon of prophethood, as such, even if they have deviated in practice or in certain views, they would still be bracketed with the Muslims, believers of the Holy Qur’an, and not otherwise.
So, if such things are proved of other people, like Hindus—at least some sects among them who believe in, or claim to believe in, the unity of God, and trace it back to the original teachings, and if those teachings are preserved—there is a possibility that this term could be extended to them, but after investigation.