7. Eating carrion is forbidden, and eating that over which the name of Allah was not pronounced when slaughtering is forbidden … and elsewhere it says that eating carrion is forbidden … (question partly unintelligible, apparently about a seeming contradiction between verses.)

Urdu question-and-answer session, 19 September 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Eating carrion is forbidden, and eating that over which the name of Allah was not pronounced when slaughtering is forbidden … and elsewhere it says that eating carrion is forbidden … (question partly unintelligible, apparently about a seeming contradiction between verses.)

Where is that? … You should look at the Holy Qur’an; one cannot treat the Holy Qur’an like this. Before asking such questions you should find the exact verses. The Holy Qur’an has a majesty; one cannot be permitted to play with it like this. You should find the exact reference, then present the one verse, present the other verse, and then ask: apparently there seems to be a contradiction between them, please explain the solution. That is the correct method. Until you find the reference, I will not answer it. I have explained this again and again to the young people in London; earlier they too used to do it this way. Now it is like this: whoever wants to ask a question about the Holy Qur’an first finds the verse, then shows it and says: please explain. Then no wrong question can arise.

10 of 10 left today