5. Our neighbour says: Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad says he is the Imam Mahdi, the Promised Messiah and also a prophet. How can these be three things? [Also: that he raised his claims gradually.]

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Our neighbour says: Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad says he is the Imam Mahdi, the Promised Messiah and also a prophet. How can these be three things? [Also: that he raised his claims gradually.]

They are three names of one and the same thing. [After a brief query about the neighbour, named Ghulam Hussain:] Ask him his profession, ask his tribe – he will tell you three attributes by which he describes himself. Show him a hadith: the Holy Prophet (saw) says: ‘La Mahdi illa Isa’ – there is no Mahdi except Jesus. We will follow the Holy Prophet (saw), not him. Remember this hadith: ‘La Mahdi illa Isa’ – there is no Mahdi except Jesus. It means that one person has two names, two titles. A man can be a [teacher] in one capacity, a poet in another, an architect in another – one person with three capacities. As to the objection that he claimed it gradually: Jews and Christians say exactly the same about the Holy Prophet (saw). The Western orientalists, Jewish and Christian opponents, raise exactly this objection: first he said he was not greater than the Prophet Jonah, then regarding Moses, then over all. First he said, warn your nearest kinsmen, then the people of Mecca and its surroundings, then he became prophet for Arabia and finally for the whole world. This is their objection. If it is valid, it must be valid everywhere. So your position clearly matches that of the enemies of Islam; you have adopted their stance toward the Holy Prophet (saw).

10 of 10 left today