7. Why is the funeral prayer (janaza) not permitted for someone who committed suicide? When someone dies, people say it was destined. If it was destined, then for the one who committed suicide it was destined too – so why no funeral prayer?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Why is the funeral prayer (janaza) not permitted for someone who committed suicide? When someone dies, people say it was destined. If it was destined, then for the one who committed suicide it was destined too – so why no funeral prayer?
[After queries:] Your question would be valid if you said: this is my belief, and I see a contradiction in it with something else; Islam says this, and I see a contradiction in it. You are relying on what people say. Islam does not say that death by illness or accident is predestined in that sense. [On the point that his mind may not have been sound:] That is exactly what I am saying: one cannot know whether someone committed suicide out of insanity or out of defiance of God, because the borderline cannot be discerned. Therefore God has reserved it for Himself: I will judge. But as far as the outward observer is concerned, he has interfered with God’s decree and shown despair; that is why it is forbidden. Firstly, taking life is forbidden, and even our own life we did not give ourselves. A father may not take his son’s life, although it is his son; likewise one may not take one’s own life – it is murder. And despair is combined with the murder, i.e. he despairs of God’s mercy and then commits suicide. This is a double offence, which is why, as a precaution, the funeral prayer for him has been forbidden. This does not mean that everyone who commits suicide goes to Hell; if you infer that, it is wrong. For Allah knows best; He will decide. If someone commits suicide out of insanity or in circumstances in which, in God’s knowledge, he was not accountable, such a person does not belong in Hell; He decides as He wills. At the funeral prayer we do not know what God has decided or will decide. Outwardly a person only sees that someone has committed an act in which two major sins are combined. First, he took a life, and in two ways: either he regarded himself as the owner of his life – which is like idolatry – or he murdered himself. The owner of life is God alone. That is why one is commanded to say ‘Bismillah, Allahu Akbar’ before slaughtering; it means we are not the owners of any life, we do this with Allah’s permission. Even to kill a small animal, man needs Allah’s permission. Likewise it is impermissible to kill harmless animals without reason – an animal you neither intend to eat nor have any other purpose for, nor is it causing harm: killing it amounts to wasting life without reason. With suicide the matter is far graver; there are two offences: he took a life he neither created nor owns; Allah gives life and decides when it is taken back. Secondly, he showed despair of Allah. When someone kills another, despair is not involved; when he kills himself, he does it for that reason – it is a double sin. To create abhorrence of it, Islam adopted this method: do not offer his funeral prayer. What his inner state was, whether he was insane, whether he was in control of himself – Allah knows best; reward and punishment are His to give, and He will decide accordingly. However, if it is established, for instance by doctors, that he was insane, his funeral prayer may be offered. That is another point: for a person declared insane by doctors who has no control over himself, there is no objection to the funeral prayer; it is not forbidden. For the cases whose inner circumstances are unknown – whether insanity or crime – what was said before applies.