8. God has [a decree] over every person; every person’s death is also God’s decree – so why not in the case of one who commits suicide?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: God has [a decree] over every person; every person’s death is also God’s decree – so why not in the case of one who commits suicide?

[On the remark that this was a question put to him:] Divine decree does not at all mean that God compels someone who commits a crime to commit it. God has given permission: ‘Fa man sha’a fal-yu’min wa man sha’a fal-yakfur’ – whoever wishes, let him believe, and whoever wishes, let him disbelieve. Open permission has been given for both. This means: the reward for good goes to the one who does it, because he did it; decree does not mean he must necessarily do it. He receives the punishment for evil because he did it. Further He says: ‘Laha ma kasabat’ – the good one does intentionally benefits him, ‘wa ‘alaiha ma-ktasabat’ – whoever does evil with effort, intention and deliberation [bears the consequences]. That is not decree; one does it knowingly. What a person does in full consciousness – a good deed is decree [in the sense of being permitted], a bad deed likewise, but the decree does not compel him to do good or evil.

10 of 10 left today