10. Hudhur, it is said that Allah created man as the noblest of creation and on the one hand gave him the power of decision; on the other hand He says that not a leaf moves without My command. If a person does something bad, is God’s pleasure involved?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Hudhur, it is said that Allah created man as the noblest of creation and on the one hand gave him the power of decision; on the other hand He says that not a leaf moves without My command. If a person does something bad, is God’s pleasure involved?

For a person who does wrong, God cannot in any respect be held responsible, except in so far as God gave him freedom of choice; beyond that, no. This too is a training. If you allow a child to do this or that, to eat this or that, and he eats something bitter, and you told him beforehand that it is bitter, and he knows what bitter tastes like, then you are not at fault; he decided himself. You could have stopped him by force; if you do not stop him by force, that is only your permission. Such is Allah’s relationship with His servants: when He has permitted both good and evil, He is responsible only for the permission, not for the offence. [On the follow-up:] If He says not a leaf moves without My command, and He did not command evil, then is man not acting against His command? In those [matters] God gave no command to do evil at all. But where He has given free choice, He has in a sense suspended the command and given man the choice; that is His command. Here Allah’s command is: you are free. In that sense His command applies – we have been made free.

10 of 10 left today