11. It is narrated that the Companions complained to the Holy Prophet (saw) that [Hazrat Bilal (ra)] did not pronounce Arabic correctly; thereupon someone else called the adhan, and when Bilal did not call it, the sun did not rise. To what extent do you believe such things?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: It is narrated that the Companions complained to the Holy Prophet (saw) that [Hazrat Bilal (ra)] did not pronounce Arabic correctly; thereupon someone else called the adhan, and when Bilal did not call it, the sun did not rise. To what extent do you believe such things?

No, we do not believe this. Truth must certainly be accepted, but this is a fabricated story. The Holy Qur’an says that We have fixed the courses of the sun and the earth, and as long as God has fixed it, until the Day of Judgement, not a particle of difference can occur in them. What contradicts the Holy Qur’an also contradicts [the laws of nature]. Those who narrate such stories attribute [it to the Prophet], but since it contradicts the Holy Qur’an you are necessarily lying; for it is impossible that the Holy Prophet (saw) would say anything against the Holy Qur’an. Therefore you are the liars, [not] the Holy Prophet (saw).

10 of 10 left today