16. Question from Lajna Imaillah: May we eat meat obtained here other than from Muslim shops? We have heard that in a situation of necessity, when halal meat is not available, one may eat it after reciting Bismillah. How far is this correct?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Question from Lajna Imaillah: May we eat meat obtained here other than from Muslim shops? We have heard that in a situation of necessity, when halal meat is not available, one may eat it after reciting Bismillah. How far is this correct?
The question is: if halal meat – slaughtered by a Muslim or a Jew with the name of Allah – is not available, may we eat other meat by reciting Bismillah? The answer: not every other meat may be eaten. A chicken, for instance, that someone did not slaughter but killed by wringing its neck and suffocating it, is forbidden. For where the commandments are mentioned, it is clearly stated: that killed by a blow – i.e. what a person did not kill by slaughtering but which died from a blow, an accident – or that strangled; this is declared forbidden. Over a forbidden thing you may recite Bismillah a thousand times, it will not become halal. But an animal that a person slaughtered for the purpose of eating, even in a non-Muslim manner – i.e. its blood flowed out and it died through the bleeding –: if a name other than Allah’s was pronounced, it also becomes forbidden, and again a thousand Bismillahs cannot make it halal; that is, if at the time of slaughter the intention was to offer it to some imaginary god instead of God, such an animal remains forbidden forever. A third form: the slaughterer took neither the name of God nor of anyone else, and killed the animal for human use in such a way that its blood flowed. Such meat becomes permissible if Bismillah is recited over it. With this clarification: if you are certain about a shop that the meat was not slaughtered in an idolatrous manner – as among some Hindus and other religions where it is offered (to deities) – and it was not strangled, then it can be permissible. If the blood has flowed and it was killed for human use, it is permissible. (Questioner:) On a factory line (the chickens are put) in water at 250 to 300 degrees and killed that way first. (Huzur:) That is forbidden – that whose blood did not flow when it was killed is forbidden; it should not be eaten. (Questioner:) But the Arabs have written 'halal' on it; so if the Arab who slaughters writes 'halal' …? (Huzur:) No. What does that mean? You are contradicting yourself. On the one hand you describe a procedure that is entirely forbidden, and when I said it is forbidden, you answer me: 'halal' is written on it. The procedure you described is a forbidden procedure; your answer to it is meaningless. I said: if your description is correct, the thing is forbidden – and against that you argue that 'halal' is written on it. You will have to accept what I say if you accept that I am speaking according to the Holy Qur’an. (Another participant:) I worked where they slaughtered chickens – they were kept for that purpose because they exported to Saudi Arabia etc. We asked them: do you recite Bismillah or do you just slaughter? They said: if we recite it so many times our minds will be muddled; we recite it once in the morning and after that it runs all day. (Huzur:) One should not investigate so much; asking so many questions makes the mind sick. A believer should not overthink. The Hadiths on this in Bukhari are astonishing: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that if a believer kills an animal for the purpose of eating and forgets to say Bismillah, it still remains halal; one should recite it before eating. He made religion very easy, yet the basic principles remain: what is forbidden remains forbidden; Bismillah cannot make it lawful. In intermediate matters God does not like going to extremes and being harsh; rather He permits that if you recite Bismillah over such meat before eating (it becomes permissible). And (the slaughter of) a Muslim is lawful even before eating anyway, whether he recites Bismillah once or a hundred times. Once he has begun with the intention and decided, 'I slaughter with (Allah’s) permission', it remains lawful even if he does not recite it every time.