16. Question from Lajna Imaillah: May we eat meat obtained here other than from Muslim shops? We have heard that in a situation of necessity, when halal meat is not available, one may eat it after reciting Bismillah. How far is this correct?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Question from Lajna Imaillah: May we eat meat obtained here other than from Muslim shops? We have heard that in a situation of necessity, when halal meat is not available, one may eat it after reciting Bismillah. How far is this correct?

The question is: if halal meat – slaughtered by a Muslim or a Jew with the name of Allah – is not available, may we eat other meat by reciting Bismillah? The answer: not every other meat may be eaten. A chicken, for instance, that someone did not slaughter but killed by wringing its neck and suffocating it, is forbidden. For where the commandments are mentioned, it is clearly stated: that killed by a blow – i.e. what a person did not kill by slaughtering but which died from a blow, an accident – or that strangled; this is declared forbidden. Over a forbidden thing you may recite Bismillah a thousand times, it will not become halal. But an animal that a person slaughtered for the purpose of eating, even in a non-Muslim manner – i.e. its blood flowed out and it died through the bleeding –: if a name other than Allah’s was pronounced, it also becomes forbidden, and again a thousand Bismillahs cannot make it halal; that is, if at the time of slaughter the intention was to offer it to some imaginary god instead of God, such an animal remains forbidden forever. A third form: the slaughterer took neither the name of God nor of anyone else, and killed the animal for human use in such a way that its blood flowed. Such meat becomes permissible if Bismillah is recited over it. With this clarification: if you are certain about a shop that the meat was not slaughtered in an idolatrous manner – as among some Hindus and other religions where it is offered (to deities) – and it was not strangled, then it can be permissible. If the blood has flowed and it was killed for human use, it is permissible. (Questioner:) On a factory line (the chickens are put) in water at 250 to 300 degrees and killed that way first. (Huzur:) That is forbidden – that whose blood did not flow when it was killed is forbidden; it should not be eaten. (Questioner:) But the Arabs have written 'halal' on it; so if the Arab who slaughters writes 'halal' …? (Huzur:) No. What does that mean? You are contradicting yourself. On the one hand you describe a procedure that is entirely forbidden, and when I said it is forbidden, you answer me: 'halal' is written on it. The procedure you described is a forbidden procedure; your answer to it is meaningless. I said: if your description is correct, the thing is forbidden – and against that you argue that 'halal' is written on it. You will have to accept what I say if you accept that I am speaking according to the Holy Qur’an. (Another participant:) I worked where they slaughtered chickens – they were kept for that purpose because they exported to Saudi Arabia etc. We asked them: do you recite Bismillah or do you just slaughter? They said: if we recite it so many times our minds will be muddled; we recite it once in the morning and after that it runs all day. (Huzur:) One should not investigate so much; asking so many questions makes the mind sick. A believer should not overthink. The Hadiths on this in Bukhari are astonishing: the Holy Prophet (saw) said that if a believer kills an animal for the purpose of eating and forgets to say Bismillah, it still remains halal; one should recite it before eating. He made religion very easy, yet the basic principles remain: what is forbidden remains forbidden; Bismillah cannot make it lawful. In intermediate matters God does not like going to extremes and being harsh; rather He permits that if you recite Bismillah over such meat before eating (it becomes permissible). And (the slaughter of) a Muslim is lawful even before eating anyway, whether he recites Bismillah once or a hundred times. Once he has begun with the intention and decided, 'I slaughter with (Allah’s) permission', it remains lawful even if he does not recite it every time.

10 of 10 left today