17. Question (from a guest, General Singh?): All prophets come from God. Can there be more than one prophet at one time? Please explain in detail.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 October 1985
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Question (from a guest, General Singh?): All prophets come from God. Can there be more than one prophet at one time? Please explain in detail.
At one and the same time there has been more than one prophet in several ways – not only can there be, there have been. First: until a world religion – one religion for the whole world – had come, Allah sent (prophets) to every region; (the Holy Qur’an says) that We sent prophets to every people, every region. So simultaneously there will have been a prophet in China, one came to Japan, one to Africa, one to India. It is not necessary that they came to all countries at once, but the possibility exists. When nations were not very large, (there were) at one time more than one prophet in the world among different peoples. To research this, we have appointed various scholars to determine, from the dates of the well-known prophets mentioned in the Bible, which other prophet was known in which part of the world in that era and what he was saying at the time. So in principle this is established. From the Holy Qur’an it also emerges that in one and the same religion more than one prophet came at one time: e.g. at the time of Hazrat Moses (as), in Moses’ lifetime, God made Hazrat Aaron a prophet. Likewise, among his descendants there was a time when father and son were both living prophets: Hazrat Joseph was a prophet and Hazrat Jacob was a prophet, and both were together – not only in the same era but in the same place, Egypt – and lived together; there was no contradiction. Between those who come from God there can be no contradiction at the same time. But it is not possible that from one God at the same time one prophet calls in one direction and another calls in another. That is wrong, against reason, simply not acceptable. (Questioner:) Huzur, Surah Ya-Sin mentions that in one village there were (three messengers) … (Huzur:) That is a matter for research. … The word qarya (village) is still to be researched – whether the Ashab al-Qarya refers to prophets at one time or whether prophets of three different eras are being mentioned. In the commentary on this … I answered in Pakistan that the interpretation of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is that here Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) is meant, and by the two before him two prophets – according to some Hazrat Noah and Hazrat Moses, according to others Hazrat Moses (as) and (Jesus) – and that both were honoured through the Holy Prophet (saw). For it does not say: We sent a third prophet, but “fa-‘azzaznā bi-thālith” – We strengthened the two with a third. This means one superior to them came. And there is another very important proof: in my view this is the prophecy of the Gospel in the parable of the vineyard, where it is described that an owner planted a vineyard, first sent a servant whom they beat and sent away empty-handed; then he sent his son, and him too the people beat and killed; then the lord himself came and took possession. Are three mentioned or not? One after another, and the last is the greatest of all – God’s representative, as if God Himself had come to earth. By this the Holy Prophet (saw) is meant, by the son obviously Hazrat Jesus. So the meaning is: in three eras God sent religion, but when it was rejected each time, God sent a prophet of such majesty that his coming was as it were the coming of God. And in “fa-‘azzaznā bi-thālith” the same theme is seen, the theme of the vineyard. To assume that it means one village and three prophets is not necessarily correct. There may have been such an event, I do not deny it, but the essential meaning of this verse is the prophecy about the Holy Prophet (saw). (Questioner:) The verse has 'hum' (them) – are the people of the town meant? (Huzur:) I think the pronoun refers to the two prophets … (Questioner:) It refers to the people of the town … (Huzur:) By qarya the inhabitants are meant, a nation too is meant by qarya … The word qarya is a very broad word; its meaning is not necessarily 'village'. … They are very broad, deep meanings; it is not that it means a village in a restricted sense. It can mean a civilisation, an established nation. In the Holy Qur’an e.g. Umm al-Qura (Mecca) …