1. (The actual question is not clearly audible. From the answer it is evident that it was asked how, in view of the many contradictory prophecies about the Imam Mahdi, one can recognise the true Imam Mahdi.)
Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 December 1985
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (The actual question is not clearly audible. From the answer it is evident that it was asked how, in view of the many contradictory prophecies about the Imam Mahdi, one can recognise the true Imam Mahdi.)
Prophecies about the Imam Mahdi are found in abundance, in various books and from various sects, more than about any other founder of a religion. There are also very many contradictions among them, to a great extent. The reason is that many have claimed to be the Imam Mahdi in the Ummah before. Whoever made the claim presented some Ahadith in his own interpretation. The last such claimant appeared only recently, at the end of the 14th century (AH), rising in Mecca with his companions. You must have heard that he appeared with armed companions, kissed the Hajr-e-Aswad (Black Stone), and then announced in the Ka‘bah that he was the Mahdi. Afterwards people sent troops against him and finished him off. He too presented a Hadith that the Imam Mahdi would come with so many companions, kiss the Black Stone, then go to the Ka‘bah and announce from there. He did exactly that, but nobody accepted him.
There is only one solution to this problem: to study the various prophecies and see whether they could be fulfilled in someone even by chance, or whether there is a special sign attached to them whose fulfilment is beyond human power. All prophecies whose fulfilment depends on chance cannot serve for recognition, because they may be fulfilled in someone through accidental events, or a person, having heard them, can simply act them out. But if there are prophecies over which man has no control, which are beyond his power, so that even if the whole world exerted itself it could not fulfil them in its own favour despite knowing them, then that is certainly reliable. Therefore the most important prophecy is the one whose making is not in human power.
(People ask: if the name is such and such, how will the prophecy be fulfilled?) Our answer is: this prophecy relates to chance events; you cannot recognise the man by it at all. If you are sincere in your demand, why did you not accept the one in whom it was fulfilled? The claimant to Mahdi-hood who arose in Yemen was himself named Muhammad, his mother was named Amina, his father Abdullah, he was of Fatimid descent, and he has become a thing of dreams; not one of his followers remains, the movement was wiped out. Every claimant has presented some Ahadith which he thought were fulfilled in him, and outwardly they were, yet he was not accepted. The reason is fundamental and psychological: a chance prophecy cannot create certainty in the heart. If I tell someone that a representative of mine will come wearing a black coat, with black hair and of such a height, many such men could come; it is no distinguishing sign. If they come, doubters will say: there are countless people like you in black coats. A black coat and such signs are ordinary things and will not be accepted. The matter of the Imam Mahdi is even more important, since he is the representative of Allah and of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Necessarily, prophecies had to be sought – and they surely exist – that are distinctive, extraordinary signs beyond human power.
The most important of these, in my view, is the one related to the moon and the sun. For even in today’s world, despite acquiring extraordinary powers, no one can change the mutual motions of the moon, sun and earth, and manifesting a sign in them is not in the power of one man, nor even of the whole world. So I place this prophecy before you; then judge whether making or fulfilling it was within any human’s power.
The Holy Prophet (saw) said: “Inna li-mahdiyyina ayatain lam takuna mundhu khalqis-samawati wal-ard; yankasiful-qamaru li-awwali lailatin min Ramadan wa tankasifush-shamsu fin-nisfi minhu, wa lam takuna mundhu khalqis-samawati wal-ard.” That is: For our Mahdi there are two signs which, since the world was created, have never appeared as signs in anyone’s favour. The first: the moon will be eclipsed on the first night in the month of Ramadan, and the sun will be eclipsed in the same month on the middle date. And since the world was created, these signs have not appeared in anyone’s favour.
This is the prophecy about which, when Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as) claimed to be the Imam Mahdi, all the scholars demanded: fulfil it and show us; if you are the Imam Mahdi, where are these two testimonies? It was not in his power, nor is it in anyone’s power today. In 1894, in the month of Ramadan, the moon was eclipsed on the 13th, and in the same month and the same year – not in some other Ramadan – the sun was eclipsed on the 28th. When this happened there was a great uproar, because this is exactly what the scholars had been demanding. Some rose up in confirmation, joined the movement and accepted Hazrat (Mirza Sahib) (as). Others invented excuses and said the prophecy was not fulfilled. Let me tell you what argument they put forward; then the whole matter will become clear to you.
The prophecy mentions “nisf”, the middle. The scholars objected: the beginning of the month, the first date, is the first of Ramadan; the middle of the month, if it has 29 days, would be the 14th or 15th, and if 30, there is no middle day at all. The prophecy said that on the first date of Ramadan the moon would be eclipsed and on the middle date the sun. You yourselves say the moon was eclipsed on the 13th and the sun on the 28th; so the prophecy was not fulfilled. How can you say it was?
The answer given by Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as), which the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat always presents, is this: God has fixed the dates of lunar and solar eclipses, and it is impossible for these dates to change, because if they changed even by an hour the earth would be turned upside down. They cannot change unless the mutual motions of the sun, moon and earth change. And the Holy Qur’an declares that it is impossible for the sun and moon to interfere with each other’s course; that is God’s decree. How could God act against His own decree? Besides, if the sun’s motion changed even slightly, doomsday would come and the earth would be turned upside down. So we must see what the eclipse dates of the moon and sun are. Among the lunar eclipse dates, the first is the 13th, the second the 14th and the third the 15th; apart from these the moon cannot be eclipsed – the whole world knows this. The sun also has three eclipse dates: the 27th, 28th and 29th. So what was meant was the first night among the eclipse dates, not the first night of the month, and the middle day among the eclipse days, not the middle day of the month. Accordingly the prophecy was fulfilled. This is the claim of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat.
His (saw) words are that the “qamar” will be eclipsed on the first night. And the whole world knows that every Arab calls the moon of the first three nights “hilal”, not “qamar”. You will have heard of Ruyat-e-Hilal committees (new-moon sighting committees), but never of a Ruyat-e-Qamar committee. Even today, if you say before an Arab that the qamar has risen, he will say: have you gone mad, what are you talking about? No eloquent Arab could even think of calling the first night’s moon qamar; everyone calls it hilal, and that for the first three nights, not only the first night. Had the Holy Prophet (saw) meant the moon of the first three nights, he would have said the hilal will be eclipsed on the first night. But he says qamar. Ask the members of a Ruyat-e-Hilal committee whether they are members of the Ruyat-e-Qamar committee; they will object: ignorant man, you don’t even know the basics. And to the Holy Prophet (saw), the most eloquent of Arabs, they attribute – God forbid – that he did not know the difference between which phase is called qamar and which hilal. Therefore, after the Holy Prophet’s (saw) own decision, no room remains at all.
The second point is common sense. Anyone with the slightest common sense can judge that the first night’s moon has itself barely appeared, it is so thin; it disappears almost as soon as it appears. Often children keep pointing it out and the other can hardly see it: where has it gone? If that moon was to appear as a prophesied, manifest sign, then a quarrel would have started: the Imam Mahdi says the eclipse has occurred, and the Mullahs say it has not even risen. And if the poor thing is eclipsed as well, what would remain of it? A thin moon, barely visible, and on top of that an eclipse – nothing at all could remain. Then the same quarrel: it hasn’t risen, so where will the prophecy go? Therefore these are useless tales. If you reflect sincerely on the words of the Hadith, the Holy Prophet’s clear intention becomes apparent. If you speak with reason, it still cannot be the first night’s moon. And if you speak scientifically and keep in view the declaration of the Holy Qur’an that the mutual motions of the earth, sun and moon cannot change – it is impossible – then after reflecting on these matters only one view emerges: the first of the lunar eclipse nights and the middle of the solar eclipse days were meant. And that is what happened; the eclipse was fulfilled exactly in this way.
(Objection:) The moon and sun have been eclipsed several times in Ramadan on these first and middle dates, not just once, so this is not reliable. The answer is that all four of its conditions were never fulfilled before: in the month of Ramadan; the moon eclipsed on the first night; the sun eclipsed on the middle day; and that there be a claimant to Mahdi-hood – because he (saw) said that this had never happened as a sign for the Mahdi, as a sign for anyone. These conditions were never met. How many Mahdis have appeared in the Ummah! Make a historical survey. I had it done in India: for all the claimants to Mahdi-hood their dates were established – when they made the claim and when they died – and then an independent opinion was obtained from the most famous observatory in India and its experts. I sent it for publication in the Review; I don’t know whether it has been printed yet. Look at it; that research is very thorough, they examined it with great effort. It turned out that for none of the claimants to the office of Imam Mahdi so far did this sign occur in their time, except for Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as). He made the claim, and after the claim – indeed three or four years after it – this sign appeared. And that is not within human power. To make a claim after a sign has appeared is one thing; but for the claim to come first and then the sign to appear – that is the real sign. And this has happened only once.
(On the question of the source:) The tradition is in Daraqutni; we can show it to you. But the interesting point is that until this prophecy was fulfilled, all the scholars kept presenting this Hadith prominently. It was so well known that among us even poems by scholars contain references to this prophecy, and they too understood these dates in the sense that the first night’s moon was not meant. Thus before the Promised Messiah (as) there was a very pious scholar, Maulvi Muhammad Lakhoke Wala, whose work was known in Punjabi under the name “Ahwal-e-Akhirat”. In his Punjabi verse he said: “On the 13th the moon, on the 27th (?) the sun will be eclipsed, in the same year in the month of Ramadan – so it is written in a tradition.” Who had told him that the first night did not mean the 1st but the 13th? Evidently these scholars understood it from the words of the Hadith itself; they were no astronomers who could calculate it. It is a common Hadith, nothing obscure; it is one of the most well-known Ahadith.
(In the Holy Qur’an it says:) Such a bright sign will appear that the eyes will be dazzled by it – “bariqal-basar, wa khasafal-qamar”: and the moon will be eclipsed – “wa jumi‘ash-shamsu wal-qamar”: not only the moon, but the sun and moon will be brought together in this matter, i.e. in one month, in one place. This detail lies in the words “jumi‘ash-shamsu wal-qamar”; the Hadith is its explanation. And not only that: going back further, this prophecy is also mentioned in the Bible, in the New Testament. Hazrat Masih (Jesus) (as) gave as a sign of his second coming that the moon will become dark and the sun will cease to give light; then he will appear, and people of noble nature will come from far away on seeing this sign, while the unwise, unfortunate ones will beat their breasts: alas, what has happened! – and they will not affirm. So this sign is not something accidental that only the Ahl-e-Hadith accept and the rest deny; it is rooted in the Holy Qur’an, and even before that it is mentioned in the prophecy of Hazrat Masih (as).