1. What is the background behind the execution of a number of Jews living in Medina during the time of Muhammad (saw)?

Question-and-answer session, 17 January 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What is the background behind the execution of a number of Jews living in Medina during the time of Muhammad?

In your Khutbah today, you spoke about the early history of Islam and the early spread of Islam. And you mentioned that there wasn't very much bloodshed in the early history of Islam, as far as I understood from the translation, you mentioned that there was not very much bloodshed at the early spread of Islam. And it made me wonder about the massacre on one Jewish tribe in Medina, why did this take place?

Number one, that was, whatever you call it—call it massacre or give it any big name—the number of people killed is still within hundreds. And the story itself is so much exaggerated that some scholars are already working on this, that things which have been related are impossible to happen. Mathematically it can be proved that in that area, in that small space, so many prisoners of war, for instance, could not be kept in a small house, and so many other objections are also being raised, and the matter is now under investigation.

Secondly, when I talked of war, Islamic war, I did not have that in mind in particular. That was a punishment meted out to them of their own demand. That was outside the category of my discussion. Whatever happened, whatever the number of the Jews concerned, that is not for the time being relative to the point. The point is why they were, as the Western historians call murdered, or executed by a court of justice, as we call it. The fact is that they committed a crime of breaking the covenant which they had gone into with Muslims regarding war and peace and their behavior and so on.

Now, in case of war, if anybody turns traitor, even by the most modern and lenient standards of so-called civilizations, the person is executed. Or even if it's a group of persons, I mean, the number doesn't matter. Even if they are a million, they would be still put to death for the crime of treason to the nation at the time of the greatest crisis. So the Western scholars generally forget the numbers of such killings in their own countries in recent times, which they call the civilized times, and they pronounce out of all proportion that number of Jews which were killed at the time of Ānhazrat (saw).

You know, the Jews which were killed by the Nazis, according to the Jewish claim, were six million. And that six million is not a far remote incident of history; this just happened within your lifetime, and at least in my lifetime. Again, the claim is very much exaggerated there, too. I'm quoting this particularly to point out a similarity between the habit of Jews with regards to their victims.

Already many Western scholars have taken strong exception to this propaganda that six million Jews were killed in concentration camps, in Nazi camps in Germany. And only recently I read a very interesting investigation in this regard—and he quoted document after document to prove the point that it was exaggerated, you know, by a factor of, say, 10 or 20. And this is an incident of recent history. If this is what they do about things which happened before everybody's eyes, what would they do to an incident which occurred 1,400 years ago?

So this is an established fact that a lot of false statements have been added into Islamic history, introduced into Islamic history by the Jewish scholars, intentionally. And this was a point which was a point of great interest to them, to create hatred against the Muslims.

So as far as the number goes, we don't know what number it was. But as far as the facts are concerned, the fact is that they were traitors. Even if they were in large numbers and they had been persecuted—prosecuted and killed, it wouldn't have made any point of objection; it shouldn't have raised any point of objection. But the things, how it happened, are a very interesting story to be remembered by Muslims and to be told to Christians and the Jews, of course.

The fact is that when their fate was being decided, it was offered that Hazrat Rasūl-e Karīm (saw) himself should decide what should happen to them. Now, this offer was turned down by the Jews, because they did not have trust in him; rather, they would have trust in a so-called friend of theirs, who otherwise was a friend, of course, but who happened to be a Muslim.

Hazrat Sa'd... kya naam tha unka? Sa'd bin Mu'adh the ya faisla karne wale ya doosre the? Hazrat Sa'd to mujhe yaad hai... Anyway. Nahin, Mu'adh woh to hain ek, lekin I'm not very sure. Anyway, there was a companion of Ānhazrat (saw) who belonged to a tribe of Medina, who was a leader of a tribe of Medina, was held in very high respect by the Jews in particular. He was quite friendly to them, so they decided to make him the arbitrator, rather than Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Had he decided—and as we know his previous conduct—we are quite certain he would forgive them. He would have forgiven them. But it was their own choice of arbitrator. And that arbitrator chosen by the Jews, he decided according to the Bible, in the book in which they believe.

So, I think this was also offered to them, whether they would go according to the Islamic tenets or according to the Biblical verdict, and they chose their case to be decided according to the Bible. And they thought he would prove dishonest—I mean, he was friendly to them—but having become a Muslim, he had to act honestly and righteously. He was left no choice by the Jews themselves.

So that sort of killing cannot be included in the category which I was discussing during the Khutbah. That was just, you know, battles or an extended war between the Muslims and the non-Muslims on the other hand. And this does not fall into that category at all. That's a question of treachery in times of war.

10 of 10 left today