6. apparent contradiction between one verse about "do no differentiate between any prophets" and then later it says "these are the prophets who are exalted in status over others"
Question-and-answer session, 17 January 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: apparent contradiction between one verse about "do not differentiate between any prophets" and then later it says "these are the prophets who are exalted in status over others"
Assalamu alaikum. I think that lā tufaddilū 'alā Mūsā, lā tufaddilūnī 'alā Yūnus ibn Mattā is similar like lā nufarriqu baina ahadim mir-rusulih. All people, all messengers, all messengers of God, but on the other hand, Qur’an says tilkar-rusulu faddalnā ba'dahum 'alā ba'd. So this clarifies the question:
all are equal, and one is over the other.
They are both right. I follow what you mean, but I wonder if everybody has understood you correctly. No, you won't, of course.
My question is, sir, do they...
You know, he says, what he wants to point out is in a very right way of making you understand. You know, he draws your attention to two statements of the Holy Qur’an, which are apparently contradictory to each other, but are not contradictory to each other.
One statement says lā nufarriqu baina ahadim mir-rusulih, that the admission of all the prophets and those who believed with them was that we do not differentiate between any of these prophets. Yet the Holy Qur’an goes on to declare, tilkar-rusulu faddalnā ba'dahum 'alā ba'd. These are the prophets, messengers, of whom We... elevation of status. Exalted, yes, exalted. Exalted in status over others.
So, apparently, the two statements are contradictory to each other. Yet, they are not. The meaning of the one belongs to a different region, and the meaning of the other belongs to a different region, so they do not contradict each other; only the angle of the vision is different.
When Allah says lā nufarriqu baina ahadim mir-rusulih, which is the admission of the people who believe, it means this verse means that whatever comes from God, as far as belief in that person is concerned, we will not differentiate. We will not differentiate between messengers of God as far as their truth is concerned. Whether they belong to Arabia or to other countries of the world, whether they came in the past or they came now or they appear in the future, whoever comes from God, as far as our belief is concerned, we will make no differentiation of color or creed or geographic regions or time. That does not mean that they are equal in status.
Yet in the other place when the Holy Qur’an says tilkar-rusulu faddalnā ba'dahum 'alā ba'd, it means that of all the prophets who were all true, some of them exalted over others, above others. So the statements are not contradictory.
Similarly, he thinks the tradition of the Holy Prophet can be reconciled where he says he is not superior to other prophets. He may mean in a way different to the way in which he declared that he was the most superior, ana Khātam-un-Nabiyyīn, the very best of things, he declares it very categorically.
So what doctor sahib has in mind that maybe the reconciliation lies in the same direction as we reconcile the two verses of the Holy Qur’an. Is that what you had in mind? Correct?
Yes, sir.
Now, this is what he wanted to say. But there, the Hadith which you have quoted, I don't think it is possible to reconcile the tradition—this tradition—in the same manner as we choose, as these two verses can be reconciled. There the issue involved was the issue of preference of one over the other. So the declaration of AnHazrat (saw) was in response to that particular question. So there you can't say that here he might have meant completely different thing. You follow the point or not?
The Hadith to which Mr. Rashid pointed out, if the wording is correct, then it is very difficult to handle the wording of that Hadith. The wording is: do not declare me to be superior or exalted above all other prophets, or—no, no, sorry—do not declare me to be superior over any prophet in the world. This is the wording of the Hadith. This is why I rejected this wording, because it's very difficult to reconcile this with the declaration of the Holy Qur’an and other traditions of AnHazrat (saw).
But if, as I believe, the true wording is lā tukhayyirūnī or lā tufaddilūnī 'alā Mūsā, then you can easily reconcile this statement with other statements of the Holy Prophet and with the Holy Qur’an. Because there, Hazrat Musa's followers' feelings were hurt. So, in that particular situation, AnHazrat (saw) prohibited his followers to declare him to be superior, where the followers of other prophets might take offence, because that was a particular situation. So I think, I personally believe that this wording which he has quoted is not correct because the same incident is related differently and more logically in other versions of the same tradition.