2. What is the different between a ghayr-shari prophet in contrast to ghayr-tashri prophet?

Question-and-answer session, 25 January 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What is the difference between a ghayr-shari prophet in contrast to ghayr-tashri prophet?

Huzoor, my question is about a word which is used generally for Hazrat Masih Maud (as), but I am not agree to that word. That word is ghayr-shari nabi. This word is now in our literature also found. But it means that a prophet who is against Shariah.

No, it doesn't mean that.

Huzoor, I want to explain in this way that I have studied a book of Kazi Muhammad Nazir Lyallpuri Sahib. He has said in his book that there should be a word, ghayr-tashri'i nabi. It means that a prophet who has not the orders of Shariah in his wahy or revelation. But ghayr-shari nabi, he said that a momin cannot be ghayr-shari...

No, no, this is just pedantic, being too grammatical, far too accurate. This is some scholar are like this, some scholars are like this, but these words which have found a meaning in a long usage and people can understand them as a term, they should not be attacked like this on the finer points of grammar and things.

Tashri'i or shari'i in reality here means one and the same thing. Why Kazi Sahib says tashri' means that tashri' means to introduce a Shariah or to pass a Shariah on to somebody. Shara'a yusharri'u means somebody who passed a law on to some other person, passed a book on to some other person. So in reality that is not also correct. If you become more pedantic, then the whole use of tashri' is totally inapplicable to prophets at all, because the early scholars in Islam, a great majority among them believe that Anhazoor (saw) was not Shari'. Shari' was God, and it's wrong to say that he issued a law. He received a law; he never issued a law. So pedanticism doesn't end there where you suggest, it will go further.

And here it is not pedanticism, it is exactly the situation, as we find in the previous century and earlier. Now people have started using the phrase Shari' (as). It is a very misleading phrase, because this is exactly what the Christian Orientalists claim, that the Shariat of Islam was made by Anhazoor (saw) and he is the Shari'. This is incorrect. In all the books of jurisprudence and other books where the word Shari' is used in the older classical literature, we will not come across this word referring to Anhazoor (saw).

They will never use the word Shari' (as). They would say Shari' is God and Anhazoor (saw) is the recipient of Sharia. So, tashri' is a step further. No man can be a tashri'i nabi in that sense.

When you say shari' nabi, then this can be on the receiving end as well as on the giving end. Shari' means who has a Sharia of his own. This word "of his own" is not mentioned in the word shari', but it is understood as such. So, there is nothing wrong with the word shari'.

By shari' nabi, we understand the one who has a Sharia. Everybody has a Sharia. You have a Sharia too; Sharia of Islam is your Sharia. But when we say a nabi is a shari' nabi, we mean the one to whom a Sharia was revealed.

10 of 10 left today