4. What is the correct interpretation of "ribaa" (usury/interest) in the light of transactions involving food items?

Question-and-answer session, 31 January 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What is the correct interpretation of "ribaa" (usury/interest) in the light of transactions involving food items?

"As-salamu alaykum. When Anhazrat (saw) defined the term riba, he mentioned five commodities like barley, wheat, dates, gold, and silver..."

"Didn't you ask this question two years ago?"

"I don't think so, Huzoor."

"Huh? I think you did."

"No, I didn't."

"Achha, all right. If I'm right, I'll remember further. Please proceed further."

"And he mentioned these commodities, and he said as far as barter trade is concerned in these commodities, we should seek to fulfill two conditions, and he said in Arabic: mithlan bi-mithlin, yadan bi-yadin."

"Right."

"Otherwise…"

"I understand this, yes, I know it."

"Now, I would like to ask Huzoor, the question is that according to the face value of this hadith, there are certain practices in Pakistan or anywhere which according to the normal economic moral standard, they're perfectly conceivable, but according..."

"Yes, I know. Well, yes, you're right. I think this question was not asked. I understand. Another question pertaining this on about this, about the definition of riba, was asked. But this will end up in the same, in fact.

Anhazrat (saw) has prohibited this as riba, declaring it to be riba, which means usury.

The type of usury which is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, which is forbidden for Muslims to indulge in, is a word of very wide application. And every act which contains the spirit of usury is also forbidden. And the spirit of usury which has been described in the Holy Qur’an is exploitation of the poor.

So, it is not just a fixed way of exploitation when you deposit some money with somebody, with some bank, and take interest on a certain rate, on a certain percentage, or you give money to a poor person and charge him. It is not just that. Exploitation in any way of a person who is, of necessity, bound to accept your unequal terms.

So some usury was also practiced in Arabia in those days in this form. And the same is practiced in slightly different form in our countries even today. In Sindh, for instance, at the time of the cotton crop or the wheat crop, this usury is practiced. It's given a different name. So when the farmer is in need of money, then the rich people exploit the farmer.

Or when a farmer has a poor crop, a poor quality crop and some rich people have very high quality crop, then they are also exploited. And this is the form which has been mentioned in the tradition that you have just referred to.

For instance, date, for instance, is a very is a staple diet of Arabia—it used to be, I mean—and at that time, some farmers had poor quality dates and some rich people had every type of date, reaching a very excellent quality. And those poor farmers who wanted to eat the excellent quality dates for occasions, when they approached such farmers, they said, "All right, we will give you high quality dates, but for one kilo of high quality dates, we will get five kilos of your dates," and so on and so forth. Or when they were in need, they would say, "We will give you today this much dates, this much quantity of dates, and we will take later on that much quantity of dates."

So both these were forms of exploitation. So by reminding us that this is the usury which is forbidden in the Holy Qur’an, not just a form, but wherever the spirit of exploitation will be found, that will be forbidden under Islam.

So, Anhazrat (saw), to make it clear to us, demonstrated it by this. That is to say, if somebody is richer and has a better quality, he should also show kindness. He should exchange it at the same with the same weight and immediately, so that if a high quality is flown as a favor to some poor person, it's a good act. So that is promoted. I mean, not only exploitation is forbidden, but a better quality is sown into Muslims' culture and habits.

10 of 10 left today