5. What is the best approach to training Ahmadi Muslim children who are born in the West?
Question-and-answer session, 31 January 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What is the best approach to training Ahmadi Muslim children who are born in the West?
Huzoor, those people who have been brought up in Pakistan, and particularly the children, and then they have arrived in these Western countries, at least they have some exposure to the true teachings of Ahmadiyyat because of the environment behind, surrounding them. But unfortunately, those who have either born here or been brought up go to the schools where there is more of the Christianity and other sources. And the evidence of this comes about during the training class which we are holding in Glasgow for Atfal particularly, in the shape of some horrifying questions, some alarming questions which they raise. For example, why the Ghair Ahmadis are rich.
Why?
The Ghair Ahmadis, the non-Ahmadis, are rich and building beautiful mosques; why Ahmadis are not rich, and so on.
Why do, why do you call such questions horrible questions?
Huzoor, in the sense that maybe...
Any inquiry which springs from an innocent mind is not horrible at all.
Jee, Huzoor, it's only horrifying to us, maybe, not to them. They are innocent questions to them.
You are horrified.
Jee Huzoor, to an extent because I didn't know the answer.
Why?
Maybe I didn't know the full answer to that. Many more questions, Huzoor, like that.
Answers are not difficult to give, but the question is, why did you have such reaction? This is what is worrying me. Questions should always be entertained normally, neutrally. No question, unless it is asked with malintention, bad intention, should be treated as a horrible question. Questions may arise in any direction, you know. An investigating mind must not be suppressed. And the children's minds particularly should be encouraged to spell out whatever they feel.
Huzoor, may I humbly submit that the word "horrifying" I used is only my own, maybe wrong word, which I...
Perhaps what you wanted to say was that you were shocked at their lack of understanding such things as are commonly, normally understood in people who are brought up in Pakistan and things. Is that right?
Huzoor has understood my mind more than I could understand my own.
I hope so, yes. Jazakallah, yes.
And when we try to explain to them, of course it seems that maybe it's a background, it's attitudinal change, Huzoor. My request is: how do we bring about this attitudinal change rather than giving a direct answer? What is that would...
Well, every family is responsible for the training.
Jee, Huzoor.
Look here, you look at this young Sanoori, come here. He has been asking many questions here.
Did you find any of his questions horrifying or not?
No, sir, most amusing and very interesting.
Were you brought up here in this country or born here?
Yes.
Yes, you tell him.
Yeah, right.
It depends on the family. If you discharge your responsibilities well towards your own children, no such problems would occur. But most unfortunately, it is the parents who should be worried about, not the children in the in the first instance. If they are not very serious about their religion or their culture, their values, these things would happen.
And these classes are held to complement their efforts. Sometimes they can put in some efforts, but not all. So to complement those efforts such classes are held. So it's a continuous struggle, and I hope, Insha'Allah, after participating in this class which you are referring to, they would come out to be- they would emerge as better children than before, Insha'Allah.