1. How has the standard of the English police and the state of crime in England changed over the past 40 years and have you ever felt you were a victim of racial profiling?
Question-and-answer session, 3 March 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: How has the standard of the English police and the state of crime in England changed over the past 40 years and have you ever felt you were a victim of racial profiling?
At one time, many years ago, my impression was that the British police could be presented as a model police for the rest of the world. And I am talking of the days when I was a student here, in 1956 and 57. Although some people complained that the standard had a bit deteriorated, but to my observation, this was the ideal police one could boast of. It had a very high standard of responsibility as well as firmness in discipline, plus politeness. All these things were so beautifully well-mended into each other that they made one single personality, and that was the most beautiful thing about it. They were kind, yet very firm in principle. They would not bother about anybody unnecessarily. But once somebody came to their notice, then they would be very thorough.
I had one experience myself, you know, of being caught unawares, breaking a law which I was not intentionally breaking at all. You know, I went to Wandsworth High Street. Normally, the parking days were different than that particular day, because the timings had—the days had just changed on that first day. So previously, I used to notice that no parking, for instance, Saturday, Sunday and so on, and on that day the schedule had changed. So despite the fact that I parked the car just ahead of the notice board, I didn't care to read it and just parked it and went ahead doing something.
When I returned, a mounted constable standing waiting for me. So he first saluted me, and was courteous, asked about me, and then, "Can you read English?"
I said, "Yes, I can."
"What's that?"
I said, "Well, I didn't notice it, I'm sorry."
He said, "No, you should have read it, so come along with me."
So he took me back to—asked my address, took me to the mosque here, and then he was very thorough investigating everything: where I got my license from, who was the inspector who examined me and so on, he telephoned him. He telephoned my insurance. He telephoned, you know, so many places where he thought some clue could be found to my record, whether I was a criminal or this and that. After having done everything, then he apologized and saluted and parted.
So that was a little experience of how they went about once they began to suspect. Otherwise, normally they wouldn't bother much.
Did you find his thoroughness disturbing and upsetting?
At that time, I was enjoying it in reality. Really. Because I was at peace within, you know, so I was just sitting comfortably, enjoying what he was doing and observing, because I had nothing to hide. There was no suspicion within me, I mean no criminal consciousness or of any sort, so it was alright with me. But I think the criminal would feel very uncomfortable in such a situation, because somebody is going, you know, trying to investigate every possible nook and corner for any possible crime or omission, but I was alright.
On the other hand, my experience of French police in the same days when I visited there as a student on holidays was exactly the opposite. I was really surprised how one could find so much difference in European countries in the police standards and behaviour, attitude and so on, very different. I think the German police is still the same, almost. No variations, not many in them, not noticeable anyway.
Do you think that some people's attitudes have changed and they think that perhaps we're not the ideal police force anymore due to the fact that we've had quite a bit of trouble over the last few years, and it's brought to light that there is some trouble in this country which there wasn't around 1956, hardly at all. But now things are changing.
I think there are various factors influence this standard of police as such. Number one, if the entire country is going downhill in moral standards and everything, in outlook, program, it's impossible to keep one particular platform as high as it used to be. It has to sink along. And this is a motion for which the particular people who occupy that platform are not responsible. The whole country is sinking, so you have to sink along with it.
So, I have noticed a general downhill trend in the standard of morality here. From individual to individual, the behavior is very different now. Generally speaking, the crime was so low in those days, the rate of crime, and the type of crime was so different as well, that, for instance, if I left something in my car, and even I forgot to roll the windows up, I would still feel safe.
In fact, once I left my things—camera and things—in my car and forgot to carry them above to my apartment. And because it was winter, so I didn't use the car for the next two months or so, and I had not locked it either. And I didn't need the camera, you know, it so happened that I didn't require those things, so I never thought of searching for them. And when I went back to my car in the beginning of the summer, everything was there, just lying there. Everybody could see, passing by, that these were things lying there, and nobody took notice of this.
Secondly, in those days, people took active interest in preventing crime. They were very conscious. If somebody behaved unusually, they would take note of it, and they would try to help those who were suffering at the hands of someone else, you know. Everybody thought it was his responsibility to help. Now, I think there is this, you know, an attitude of carelessness or, "Well, we're not concerned, let it happen," you see. Not entirely, I mean, there are exceptions, but overall, I think this is the difference.
And the third factor, which I noticed at that time as well, which has, in fact, influenced now to a large degree the morality in the police, is that in those days, generally people would never think of bribing the police. This was, you know, this was against the British character. And some Pakistanis, whom I knew, had started trying to do that, you know, and some other groups from other countries who were used to having their things done, work done, through bribery, were attempting to do that. And a friend of mine told me that he knew cases where some Pakistanis really got success, and they were starting to give them a taste of this money—in the name of wine, you know, ten shillings for a drink or something. So it started, you know, just the opening was made in those days. Now, I don't know myself, I have no direct knowledge except from some television programmes on these issues, I understand that it has really become a problem in some places at least.
Then the officer was more respected at that time, that I also noticed. Because of her traditional values, people did have a very special respect for the police, and the police knew it and enjoyed it, and that was a reward for them.
You know, a sense of—inner sense of being noble and being respected, that's a very great reward. If, because of these racial problems and other things, the police is being looked down upon or considered as an enemy, then the same attitude is created by way of polarization. If I feel inimical towards you, naturally a pole would be created within you to counter this, and your attitude will not remain neutral any longer. So I don't think it started from the police, but this sense of enmity and hostility, which appeared from certain groups to begin with, and then also became an individual trait in many, that is also responsible for the police attitude. If you walk along the streets knowing that you are being looked at as enemy number one or something, you know, lowly placed and this and that, naturally you can't help reciprocating the same.
When you say that there's a lot of racial problems in this country, I find when I'm out on the streets, if I speak to somebody for an offence, if they're black or Pakistani or something, they always say to me, "You're only doing it because I'm black," or something. If somebody stopped you, and perhaps there wasn't an actual offence, but it was checking over motor vehicles, and they stopped you, a police officer, would you personally think he's done this, the reason why he stopped me is because I'm Pakistani?
Never. Never. The thought would never cross my mind. I don't look at things like this, in this attitude at all. I, on the other hand, have experienced that Allah, God has given us a subtle capability of judging others and measuring them. The moment we come across each other, we begin to measure each other, and it is that moment which decides how you are going to treat your opponent or adversary or a friend or a passer-by you come across, whatever it be. The police officers also judge the person whom they are addressing. And the moment they see, if they so observe, that the person is a gentleman, noble man, and he is rightly minded and rightly behaved, their attitude would immediately adjust to this situation. They will not be insulting, except for an odd person out. There are people in every society who are odd men out.
There are people in every society who are odd men out. But this is a general behaviour which I have noticed everywhere: in customs, in immigration, everywhere. Within a matter of a few sentences, they get the measure of you, and even if they have been insulting—or maybe not consciously insulting, but have been just showing disregard—they would readjust and change their attitude.
So, it is a lot that depends on the public teaching as well. Not only the police should be taught these things; there should be a public education. But what education do you give to the public in television, in radio and things? You are particularly, as if you are consciously teaching them to be, you know, go mad about things and have disregard for all norm and culture and form and tradition and everything. This is the message now being conveyed to the people here in England and elsewhere in Europe, particularly in America: that you should have no regard for anything. This is a short life; live as and enjoy as you possibly you can.
And this is being appreciated more and more by the people, and their demand is being created more for this type of television and entertainment, with the result that they are going a step ahead and they just don't represent the society as it exists. If that was so, even that could be somehow justified. But they go one step ahead to teach you evil things and evil manners.
And I think this is the greatest curse of the time: the employment of television in our country, in these countries particularly, how they are employed. And they are not a help to you at all.