6. Can non-Muslims go to Heaven?
Question-and-answer session, 7 March 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Can non-Muslims go to Heaven?
There was this argument, back home, between this Muslim and a Christian. They were arguing about which one of them would go to paradise or something like that. The Muslim believes that the Christian will not go to paradise because he never accepted Muhammad, Prophet Muhammad. Then the Christians who believe that the Muslim will not go to paradise because he never accepted Jesus Christ. As son of God, literal son of God. Yes, that's right.
Now the question is, who goes to paradise? That's interesting, yes. I mean that's the question, who goes to paradise?
In fact, this is an objection which the Holy Qur’an raises against the parochial attitude of Christians towards Jews and Jews towards Christians: *Qālatil-Yahūdu laysatin-Nasārā ‘alā shay’in wa qālatin-Nasārā laysatil-Yahūdu ‘alā shay’*. The Holy Qur’an tells us that the Jews said that the Christians have no foundation whatsoever, so they would never, not never be forgiven by God. And the Christians, on the other hand, say the Jews have absolutely no foundation, so they will never be liberated by God and they will never go to heaven. And the Holy Qur’an took exception to this attitude.
How could the Holy Qur’an, having done that, take exactly the same attitude towards others? Quite on the contrary. It is the only religion—and when I say the only, I mean the only religion in the world—which declares categorically that Allah's light, Allah's guidance is not the monopoly of a particular people or a particular area of the Mediterranean belt alone. The Holy Qur’an declares that Allah has shown His light and sent His messengers and reformers to all parts of the world, in all ages, among all the people—black and white and yellow, no distinction.
So having made such magnanimous, magnanimous declaration covering the entire world, bringing it under the spell of Allah's mercy, how could the Holy Qur’an take that parochial attitude that none but a Muslim would ever be forgiven?
On the contrary, it goes further to explain that—now I quote the Holy Qur’an:
*Innal-ladhīna āmanū wal-ladhīna hādū wan-Nasārā was-Sābi’īna man āmana billāhi wal-yawmil-ākhiri wa ‘amila sālihan falahum ajruhum ‘inda rabbihim wa lā khawfun ‘alayhim wa lā hum yahzanūn.*
This is a verse taken from Surah al-Baqarah. It says, those who have believed, verily those who have believed, that is those who have believed in the Holy Prophet of Islam; *wal-ladhīna hādū*, and also the Jews; *wan-Nasārā*, and also the Christians; *was-Sābi’īna*, and also people belonging to other religions outside the Mediterranean belt, because *Sābi’ī* was the word used for non-Arabian religions.
Non-Mediterranean religions—whoever belonged to that religion, he was named Sabi by the Arabs. So this word covers all the religions outside Arabia or outside the Mediterranean.
Now, the Holy Qur’an, having reached this, the Holy Qur’an says: *Innal-ladhīna āmanū... āmanū billāhi wal-yawmil-ākhiri wa ‘amilus-sālihāt*—of those who truly believe—here again the word *āmanū* is repeated, meaning of these which we have counted, those who truly believe in God and the Day of Judgment and act righteously, their reward would be upon God, upon their Lord; no fear shall come upon them, nor shall they have cause to grieve. This is the declaration of the Holy Qur’an. If, according to the Holy Qur’an, all of them are bound for hell except Muslims, how could the Holy Qur’an declare that their reward is with Allah and no grief shall come upon them, no fear shall come upon them?
In view of this categorical statement, it is impossible to attribute such a narrow teaching to Islam. Yet, as you have rightly said, the majority of the Muslims of today take this attitude. Why? They are not also without foundation altogether. They have another verse in mind which they have misunderstood and which they have not been able to compromise with this verse which I have just quoted.
So, unfortunately, among the Muslims we find two opposing groups. Some follow this verse and say even the non-Muslims would be forgiven if they are righteous, and some follow the other verse:
*Innad-dīna ‘indallāhil-Islām*, *wa man yabtaghi ghayral-Islāmi dīnan falan yuqbala minhu*—Verily, the religion in the sight of God is Islam, and whoever is inclined to accept any religion other than Islam, it will not be accepted from him by God.
What a categorical declaration that all other religions would be rejected! So how can you bring these two verses to a compromise situation? And what do you draw from all these apparently paradoxical statements? Once we understand this, then the whole issue is solved on the basis of the authority of the Holy Qur’an.
In fact, the Holy Qur’an, having declared that God has revealed light to all the world, also gives them guarantee that if within the four walls of their teachings they truly believe and they are sincere and they act righteously, then their reward would be with Allah.
So it is the individuals discussed belonging to various paths or religions of the world. But when religions are compared with religions, then Islam is the latest manifestation and the most complete manifestation.
Somebody who has to compare and choose his religion, *wa man yabtaghi ghayral-Islāmi dīnan*, that shows that he has already been acquainted with Islam, yet he prefers another religion to Islam and rejects Islam. He would not be able to benefit from that general declaration which applies to the people who have not rejected Islam, who are born in a different religion, have followed the tenets of that religion sincerely, and who are honest to themselves and to God. They will be forgiven; they will go to heaven.
But those, given the opportunity of comparing Islam with other religions, reject the most perfect revelation and the latest revelation and accept a less perfect or interpolated religion, giving preference over Islam, of course, such people would not be held as righteous in the sight of Allah. And this very act of rejection of Islam shows that they are not rightly minded, they are not righteous, because if the claim of Islam is correct—and that is an if, of course, involved, but we have to consider this question with some logic, so I am saying if the claim of Islam is right, that this is the latest manifestation and this is the universal revelation—so as compared to this revelation, if a Christian, without any bias, begins to compare Islam with Christianity, he should begin to see that both stand in the same line of development, only one is an older religion, less perfect and more related to its time, and one is more perfect and more universal.
And also in one case, the original book, that is the Testament, has been interpolated, and we find many paradoxes and many differences related by various scholars; the Apostles do not agree with each other on many things. And in one case, that is the case of the Holy Qur’an, it is a perfectly preserved book; not a word, not a jot has changed. And that we believe not only on the claim of Muslims, but on the authority of hostile critics of Islam.
So this comparison is very clear. Also, he should begin to see that the fundamental claims of Islam stand much more to reason than the present-day version of Christianity, which would have him believe that except for one Middle Eastern region, Allah never showed any light anywhere.
So on just common sense basis, anyone who begins to compare Christianity of the present day—not the Christianity of Jesus Christ (as), because I believe that was different, and the Holy Qur’an also tells us that it was much closer to the Holy Qur’an than to any other religion, but I'm talking of the present-day version of Christianity—so he should be able to see, if he's righteous in the sight of Allah.
And then, having made this comparison, if he rejects Islam and chooses another path, then Allah would say rightly that your faith is then rejected by God. If you reject His freshest message, His complete message, Allah has a right to reject your faith. That is what it means: *Innad-dīna ‘indallāhil-Islām*, *wa man yabtaghi ghayral-Islāmi dīnan falan yuqbala minhu*.
But for those, for people in Nigeria and other parts of the world, who have not occasion, who have not capability, who have not the potential to make religious comparisons—but who are honest people, who are true people, who have no paradoxes within, no inconsistencies, they sincerely follow Christianity, whatever God has given them by way of wisdom they have understood something and they follow that sincerely and act righteously, positively the Holy Qur’an guarantees them reward by Allah and no fear shall come upon them.