6. If one arrives for prayer after it has started and joins in the middle, then what is the status of the rakaas that must be made up?

Question-and-answer session, 14 March 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: If one arrives for prayer after it has started and joins in the middle, then what is the status of the rakaas that must be made up?

If a person comes for the prayer after the Imam, and he or she joins in, for example, in the Asr prayer, joins in the third rakat, and he or she completes third and fourth, and after the Imam has said, As-salamu ‘alaykum, As-salamu ‘alaykum wa rahmatullah, he or she has to complete, what will be the treatment of those two rakaats? Will the two rakaats he or she has said be the same as the Imam and his two earlier he has his or her...

Partly, the fact is that the Imam's intention prevails over the intentions of those who follow. This is the general law. So if the Imam is saying the last two rakaat, the one who follows him, his rakaats would also be the last two rakaats, not the first two. The first two have already been said by the Imam. So after that, he will start from the beginning, the rakaat which have been missed. He has missed the first two rakaat, not the last two. So he will say them in the same order, first and second.

I think everyone else did.

What I understand is that his two rakaats which he or she has said with the Imam will be his or her first—two first—and then he will follow...

No. I say the Imam's intention prevails over the intention of the follower. This is the general rule. Even if the Imam is saying Asr prayer and somebody thinks it is the Zuhr prayer and he has to say Zuhr prayer, if he joins such an Imam who is performing the Asr prayer instead, his prayer would be Asr prayer, the one he would say after that Imam, despite his own intention to the contrary. So such is the strength of the Imam's intention. And this is also a lesson to the community traditions of Islam that you, you follow Imam, and you don't, you never go any step ahead of Imam. You have to remain behind him. So when this is applicable to Zuhr and Asr, also it is applicable internally to every prayer, whatever name the name be.

Still it's not clear to you. I can see that on your face.

No, Huzoor, it's clear. What I understand is, Imam has said, he joins last two rakaats, and then he will have to repeat those left, the first two rakaats.

Exactly, that's right. Is it clear now? Clear, Huzoor. Alhamdulillah. Yes.

10 of 10 left today