5. Did the prophets Adam, Joseph and Jonah commit sin according to the Holy Qur’an?

Question-and-answer session, 21 March 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Did the prophets Adam, Joseph and Jonah commit sin according to the Holy Qur’an?

Now Hazoor, another question is about Ismat-e-Ambiya or the innocence of the prophets. And this is defended and supported by this verse: Lā yasbiq... Lā yasbiqūna bil-qawli wa... Pardon? Lā yasbiqūna bil-qawli wa hum bi-amrihī ya‘malūn in Surah Ambiya about the prophets, that they do not transgress what they are told and they do accordingly. Now the Promised Messiah has said about Prophet Adam that: Mera to yaqīn hai ke Hazrat Adam ki isti‘dād mein kisi qadar koi tasāhul tha jabhi shaitān ko waswasa ka qābū mil gaya. Wallāh agar is jagah Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) ka wujūd-e-kāmil khaṛā kiya jaata to shaitān ka kuchh bhi bas na chalta. Right. This is one. And about Prophet Joseph the Promised Messiah says he suffered wa labitha fis-sijni bid‘a sinīn because he said: Uzkurnī ‘inda rabbika, that is he used intercession or what we call in our language sifārish to the fellow prisoner who was going to be released, that make... Let's first decide the issue of Adam. Pardon? Let's first decide the issue of the sin of Adam. No, because I want to mention about three prophets which have been... No, let's first decide one after the other, you know. First, please let's decide the issue of, and finish with the issue of the sin of Adam as mentioned here. Why to refer to Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) when there is a categorical statement of the Holy Qur’an itself: ‘Aṣā Ādamu rabbahū faghavā. The literal meaning of this is that Adam committed sin against God and went astray. That is a very, a very clear statement. So the question which you should have asked according to me would be, that is a valid question, that on the one hand the Holy Qur’an says that positive, in positive terms, that Adam did commit a sin against God and went astray. And on the other hand the Holy Qur’an makes us believe that the prophets are innocent. Why this contradiction? Is that the question which you wanted to ask? Yes, because... That is in conflict with the concept of Ismat-e-Ambiya. That's why I understand, I mean this is what I have put forward in clear terms, that it seems to be, there seems to be an internal contradiction in the claim of the Holy Qur’an and the statement, other statements of the Holy Qur’an. On the one hand, the prophets do not commit sins. On the other hand, the Holy Qur’an itself relates certain incidents in their life which appear to be sins. And here, in case of Adam, it says in so many words, he committed a sin against God and went astray. But at the same time the Holy Qur’an also draws our attention to this fact that lam najid lahū ‘azmā, we forgave him and did not consider it as a sin on his part because lam najid lahū ‘azmā, we did not find any willful act, willful intention on his part to commit sin. That is to say, in itself although that act was a sin, but it was done inadvertently. It was not done in the spirit of a sinner, in violation of of something very clearly. So when the Holy Qur’an itself has explained the situation, then we find there is no contradiction. Only our definition of sin is to be now redefined and reshaped.

In view of this, the definition of sin would not be just to violate any law of God, but it will be to violate a law of God willfully in rebellion against the law, understanding the full implication, is the sin which can never be committed by prophets. But the sin of negligence, the sin of inadvertent acts, that may be committed by prophets, but very rarely and so occasionally, so rarely, that hardly there are two or three such incidents which are recorded. Even that, even if it is described as sin, happens very rarely in the lifetime of of prophets. And such incidents, because they are conspicuous—so conspicuous because prophets generally don't do such things—so they are recorded and the explanation is given by the Holy Qur’an to defend their cause, to defend their case. Now, next please. Now, about Prophet Joseph, the Promised Messiah says he suffered wa labitha fis-sijni bid‘a sinīn. He suffered incarceration in the prison. Pardon? He suffered imprisonment. Yes. Because he told to the fellow prisoner before he was released, Uzkurnī ‘inda rabbika, make a mention of me to your lord. Yes. And that was the reason that he went into prison, because he, I mean... No, no, he couldn't have written that that was the reason why he went to the prison, because this thing happened in the prison. No, he actually his prison, actually his imprisonment was prolonged because he... This is the statement of the Holy Qur’an again. This is exactly the statement of the Holy Qur’an that when Hazrat Joseph said this to the servant... Pardon? Yes, no, who was a servant of, in the court of of a king. Hazrat Yusuf (as), Hazrat Joseph said it to one of the servants of the king who was imprisoned at that time, who was in the, is a fellow prisoner with him, that when you are released, as I see according to your dream, you would be released, then remember me to your lord, that is to the king, because you have access to him. And when you remember him in good way, he would help me and help, and he would release me from the prison. That was the spirit. God didn't like it. The Holy Qur’an says that he forgot it because Satan made him forget. And this is why Joseph remained for a few more years to tarry in the prison.

Now what is the question based on this statement? Now actually, the Promised Messiah has said that Prophet Joseph suffered because he tried to seek intercession of a fellow prisoner to recommend to the king that he's a very nice man... Well, as far as that statement is concerned, you first refer to the book, I will read it myself, and then I'll be able to explain, because I don't have that portion in my mind. When you refer to the Holy Qur’an, obviously it immediately comes to my mind, but I can't say that of every part of Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as)'s books, that whichever para you refer to, it would immediately appear to me. So unless I have seen that para, I will not be able to to explain the true import of what he is saying. Where it is clearly stated, and whatever Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) has said, would be within the four walls of this statement, because it will be based on this statement. And likewise, the Promised Messiah said about Prophet Jonah, that he suffered to stay in in the belly of the fish... stomach, the fish stomach, because he became grouchy and disgruntled and frustrated and left his people... This is exactly what the Holy Qur’an has said again. So he... Yes, but he... So why don't you start from the from the foundation? Instead of going to the explanations made by the Holy, by Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as), why don't you start at the beginning? The Holy Qur’an says that it was such an act on his part that had he not sought forgiveness from Allah and had Allah not forgiven him, he would remain as such till the day of resurrection. Allah shows some displeasure. But the fact is that when Allah shows displeasures at certain acts of His chosen ones, it is not essential that that act is by ordinary standard a great sin. It is directly related to the expectations. You know, on the white cloth, the slightest spot would be a blemish. But on an ordinary dirty cloth, such a spot would not even be noticed by anybody. There are certain acts on the part of ordinary people which can be defined as acts of goodness, but those, if they are part of the character of higher people, they are blemishes.

So all this should be understood in that atmosphere of relativity, otherwise you will never be able to reach the truth. Those acts on the part of such prophets which have been spoken with such displeasure by Allah in the Holy Qur’an, if such an act was committed by you, nobody would ever take notice of this as having, you know, been anything wrong, there has there there have been anything wrong with it at all. Even if you accept such a decree of God with, in the spirit as Jonah did, but you do not renegade, you do not speak against God, it is said that somebody has stood the test, you know, he has passed the test, he kept his faith alive. You you commend such a person. But in Jonah, it was something which, you know, displeased Allah very much, because He expected much more from Jonah, much, much more. So in comparative terms, those are declared as sins. Don't judge them as sins according to the ordinary explanations of sin by ordinary human beings. Hazoor, I got one question about Prophet Joseph again, but it's a different question. Now in Surah Yusuf, the Holy Qur’an says: Wa laqad hammat bihī wa hamma bihā... Wa hamma bihā... Lawlā an ra'ā burhāna rabbih. Yes. Now what is the kamāl of, or excellence of Hazrat Yusuf? I mean he did something after seeing the burhān of his God. As if... No, no! This is what is wrongly translated. Here, now listen to my translation. It depends on which part of the verse you associate with which part of the verse. There are three pieces to this verse and they can be studied in a way that first two pieces are interconnect- interconnected, and the third piece is separate. Or the second two pieces are interconnected and the first piece is separate. I look at this verse in the light, in the in the former light. That is to say, now let me translate it first: Wa laqad hammat bihī—that is one statement. Wa hamma bihā is the second part of the statement. Lawlā an ra'ā burhāna rabbih is the third—Lawlā ar-ra'ā burhāna rabbih, that is the third part of the statement. People generally commit the mistake of associating the first two parts of this this statement as against the third, which is they keep separate, and the entire meaning is distorted then. If you read it as I read it, then it will be a completely different picture which will be painted. The meaning in in the first instance is, as you have said, she decided to sin, commit sin with him.

He also decided to commit sin with her. But, in the meantime, after having taken this decision, Allah—that is the third part of the statement—Allah showed him some signs from Him, and in view of those signs, he was rendered, you know, incapable of committing sin. This is not what the Holy Qur’an says. It is against the expression of the words lawlā an ra'ā burhāna rabbihī. As I read it, it means: wa laqad hammat bihī, she had decided to commit sin; wa hamma bihā lawlā an ra'ā burhāna rabbihī, had he not seen earlier Allah's signs in his favor, he also might have decided in committing sin. This creates a completely different picture. Hamma bihā is attached not to the first statement, but to the second, the third one. This would be read now: hammat bihī—finished; hamma bihā lawlā an ra'ā burhāna rabbihi—he might or he also might have committed, decided to commit sin, had he not seen signs of his Lord earlier. So the lawlā, the the expression lawlā makes us inclined to this much more than the than the first attitude towards this verse. If you knew Arabic, then you will understand what I mean. Lawlā means had it not happened. Not that that there and then Allah showed him the signs. It is referring to some earlier signs, the favors of Allah to him. This is why he is held as honorable in the sight of Allah. This is why Allah says, tells that this is Aḥsan al-Qaṣaṣ. This is the best narration that can be made, most beautiful narration. If you read it as you have read, as on ordinarily these these verses are translated, then how can you call it the best of narrations? Even a prophet, which is supposed to be such a chaste prophet as he stands as an example for others, this is the extent of his piety, that he has made a firm decision of committing sin, but only forcibly from Allah he is led away? And this is the best of narrations, you think? It can only be termed a termed as best of narrations if these verses are read in the light as I have shown you.

10 of 10 left today