1. The speaker before you said that this movement was announced in 1849. What role did your organisation and your elders play in the War of Independence of 1857? Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and many other landlords, who even today own hundreds and thousands of acres of land, criticised the War of Independence until the very end. But an ordinary Muslim … (Follow-ups:) By 1849 the British had reached the Punjab. Did your elders condemn it, as Sir Syed Ahmad and many others did? You yourself call it 'Ghadar' (mutiny). Hindus and Sikhs generally say that. I have never heard any Muslim speak this way of the 1857 independence movement. (When asked whether there was ever a jihad in which idolaters and Muslims fought together:) For freedom one has to do so. The Holy Prophet (saw) allied with the Jews of Medina against the Meccans. There was an agreement with the Jews, after all. (Finally:) So he forbade jihad?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 March 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The speaker before you said that this movement was announced in 1849. What role did your organisation and your elders play in the War of Independence of 1857? Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and many other landlords, who even today own hundreds and thousands of acres of land, criticised the War of Independence until the very end. But an ordinary Muslim … (Follow-ups:) By 1849 the British had reached the Punjab. Did your elders condemn it, as Sir Syed Ahmad and many others did? You yourself call it 'Ghadar' (mutiny). Hindus and Sikhs generally say that. I have never heard any Muslim speak this way of the 1857 independence movement. (When asked whether there was ever a jihad in which idolaters and Muslims fought together:) For freedom one has to do so. The Holy Prophet (saw) allied with the Jews of Medina against the Meccans. There was an agreement with the Jews, after all. (Finally:) So he forbade jihad?
He says 1857 was the War of Independence, but the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat was founded in 1889. What role can people who come later play? What role can a son play in the birth of his mother? Look, you are not aware of the facts of the War of Independence and you are needlessly confusing it with religion. The so-called War of Independence, which is also called Ghadar, was in fact a movement of the Hindus. Many elements in India which were also hostile to Muslims ran that movement. That is why the leading Muslim scholars of that time refused to issue a fatwa in its favour, and those people were besieged. The result was that the movement proved extremely harmful for the whole of India and the rule of the Muslims was overthrown. That was the outcome of that movement. Before it there was Muslim rule; Bahadur Shah Zafar was ruling. It was this very movement that destroyed it. Had it not taken place, the map of India would have been different. You want a fatwa from the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in favour of such a movement, which overthrew the last Muslim rule, the Mughal Empire? They came in because of that. You do not know this, and carried away by emotional talk you want to confuse it with religion.
1849 – the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat was founded in 1889 and you are talking about 1849? I do not understand your argument. (On cooperation with idolaters:) Have you ever heard of a jihad in which idolaters and Muslims fought jihad together? Inna lillah! Fear God, why are you distorting the history of Islam? At the Battle of Badr, when he was in dire need of helpers, the Holy Prophet (saw) refused the help of an idolater on the grounds that no idolater would take part in jihad. And he was the foremost wrestler of his time. The Muslims who brought the message were very pleased that a helper had been found. The Holy Prophet (saw) said: God's religion has no need of any idolater; I reject his help. The alliance was not that henceforth they would fight alongside us. Name a single jihad in which even one Jew took part alongside the Prophet (saw). If Medina is attacked, that is not called jihad. The agreement was that the Jews would not fight against the Prophet (saw); there is no agreement that the Jews would fight with him. Show it to me somewhere. Did the Jews fight alongside in the Battle of the Trench (Ahzab), at Badr, at Uhud? So why do you not refrain from attacking Islam merely for the sake of attacking Ahmadiyyat? I am saying nothing against the agreement; I am only saying: in your eagerness to say something against Ahmadiyyat at all costs, why do you begin speaking against Islam? The clear principles given by the Holy Prophet (saw) in the light of the Holy Qur’an are as bright as the sun and the moon. Speak keeping them in view. I am a religious leader, not a political leader. Speak to me about religion. And I assure you categorically that in what you call jihad, the question of the participation of non-Muslims does not arise; therefore this movement, whose leaders were Hindus and through which the Muslim government was overthrown, cannot be called jihad. Later this very thing was lamented. Read the book of Sir Syed Ahmad; you will learn a great deal from it. These are historical events; by distorting them you can gain nothing. Historical facts should be read in the light of history. It is not that after the creation of Pakistan history is written one way for a while, and when another regime comes it begins to be written another way. That is just like what happens in communist countries, where in one era Stalin is one kind of man and in another era he becomes a different kind. One should look at historical facts consciously. There can be disagreement about conclusions, but not about facts. Therefore, regarding what you call the War of Independence, first correct the facts, look at the actual events, then decide for yourself what its nature was, what its form was, whether it benefited or harmed the Muslims.
(On whether he forbade jihad:) Not at all. He absolutely did not forbid jihad. He forbade killing in the name of jihad. These are two completely different things. Fighting can also take place in jihad, that is correct, but not every fight is called jihad. Fighting for freedom is not called jihad. If you forget the definition of jihad given by the Holy Qur’an you may make any definition you like, but it cannot become an Islamic definition. What is the authority for defining jihad? Tell me: is it the Holy Qur’an and Hadith, or something else? Take out the verse of jihad from the Holy Qur’an where permission was first given, and the matter will become entirely clear. In Surah Al-Hajj the verse was revealed for the first time in which Muslims were given permission for jihad. Jihad existed before too, but it was jihad with the Holy Qur’an, not with the sword. The first permission for jihad with the sword came in Surah Al-Hajj, and the verse is: (recites) 'Permission is given to those against whom war is made, because they have been wronged – and Allah indeed has power to help them – those who have been driven out of their homes unjustly only because they said: Our Lord is Allah. And if Allah did not repel some people by means of others, cloisters, churches, synagogues and mosques, wherein the name of Allah is oft commemorated, would surely have been destroyed.'
Permission is given to those who are already being attacked with the sword, that they too may fight. There is no disagreement about the translation of this verse among Shia, Sunni or any sect; it is so clear and open that you may open any Qur’an and it is the same. 'Alladhina yuqataluna' means: permission is given to those against whom fighting is already being waged, i.e. the enemy has started fighting them and We had not given them permission before. So the enemy taking the initiative is necessary for the permission of jihad. That is the first condition. 'Bi-annahum zulimu': those who are fighting them have no legitimate reason to raise the sword against them; they fight out of injustice. That is the second condition: those against whom the sword is raised must be the oppressed. The third point God stated before going further: 'Wa inna Allaha ala nasrihim la-qadir' – Allah declares that He has power to help and aid these oppressed ones. Those whom He grants permission, He can also make victorious. Before going further, reflect on this verse and its context, on what matters of jihad come to light. First, Muslims are nowhere permitted to be the first to raise the sword in the name of Islam or religion. That a Muslim, because of difference of religion, draws the sword and says: now I will set religion right with the sword, otherwise become Muslims – this is permitted nowhere in the entire Holy Qur’an. Permission is for those against whom the enemy first raised the sword. Number two: they are oppressed, they have committed no fault. Now tell me: a person, a people who are so oppressed that attackers boldly attack them without any fault of theirs, will necessarily also be weak, will they not? What wisdom is there in giving a weak people permission to fight unless its victory is guaranteed? Herein the wise nature of the word of the Holy Qur’an becomes evident: when the thought arises that this is such an oppressed and weak people that anyone may trample on it and anyone may raise the sword against it, and it has been given permission to fight – as if a man were to tell a sparrow, bravo, go ahead and fight, you have our permission – it is not a mere permission, it is a promise. God is mightier than all. When God gives permission, He also guarantees that He will grant victory to those who have been given permission. This is the third condition of jihad: in a jihad fought in the way of Allah, Allah necessarily grants victory. You will not see a single jihad in the life of the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw) in which this promise of God was not fulfilled. Is there any in which defeat was suffered?
After this God says: 'Alladhina ukhriju min diyarihim' – these are the same people who were so weak that they were driven out of their homes, and even after expelling them they were not left alone; they were pursued with swords to the place where they had been cast out. 'Bi-ghairi haqq' – without any right, there is no right, no reason to drive anyone out of his home on account of difference of religion. 'Illa an yaqulu Rabbuna Allah' – their only fault was that they said: Allah is our Lord. Having concluded this subject, God Almighty now begins another – the same verse is still continuing. He says: if God did not grant some people permission to defend themselves against others – i.e. here there is permission for defence, and defence means defence, not attack. The notion of jihad in Islam that one should raise the sword and go around subjugating enemies is completely demolished in this verse. 'Wa lau la daf'u Allahi an-nasa ba'dahum bi-ba'd' – if God did not permit self-defence, what would happen? 'La-huddimat sawami'u' – sawami' are not churches but places where worshippers of God withdraw, cut off from the world, build a hut or go into a cave; these too would be destroyed. 'Wa biya'un' – and churches would also be destroyed. 'Wa salawatun' – and the places of worship of the Jews would also be destroyed. 'Wa masajidu' – and mosques, in which God is remembered abundantly, would also be laid waste. Now reflect: Islamic jihad is being discussed – what mention is there of churches, cloisters and Jewish places of worship? Their protection too is proclaimed in this defence. This is Islam. Where the Holy Qur’an permits defence, where it permits jihad, it also declares that all houses built in the name of God, whether they belong to Muslims or to non-Muslims, we guarantee the defence of each. And if this permission were not given, not only would mosques be laid waste, but all these houses of worship in which Christians, monks and Jews worship would be destroyed. This is the teaching of Islamic jihad. According to this teaching, if a church is being attacked and a Muslim is killed defending it, this too is jihad. This is what is called a universal teaching, this is called a beauty that captivates like magic. Present this teaching to the world, then see what power the enemy of Islam has left. Abandoning this teaching and teaching instead that if someone differs in religion, loot his home, drive him out of his home, make him homeless, kill him, destroy him, who is he anyway, he differs from Islam – this is jihad? The Promised Messiah (as), against this jihad whose distorted concept today's scholars are presenting, [declared] that no one in the world can abrogate the conditions of jihad laid down by the Holy Qur’an. Whenever they apply, defence will be permitted. But in circumstances where the enemy does not attack you on account of religious difference, does not interfere in your religion, does not drive you out of your homes in the name of God, does not use force to separate you from Islam, whatever fight you wage cannot be called religious jihad.
There are a hundred kinds of political wars. Look now: isn't Iraq fighting against Iran? Both are political wars. If Iran says this is our jihad and Iraq says this is our jihad, whose dead will go to Paradise and whose to Hell? Has it ever happened that the defender is waging jihad, the one who dies in defence goes to Paradise and the one who killed him also goes to Paradise? Therefore, like a conscious person, one should first study the teaching, understand the basic teaching of the Holy Qur’an, then distinguish between religious and political wars. If you do not make this distinction, you cannot defend Islam at all. Look, the history of Islam began with religious wars in which religious principles were followed one hundred percent, and in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) there is not a single incident on which the enemy can put his finger and which we cannot defend. Later, when political governments were established, there were many wars waged by Muslims for which no justification can be found. When the enemy attacks this and says this is your jihad, how will you defend it? This is the principle: tell them that the Holy Qur’an permits religious wars with religious conditions. Apart from this there are also political wars in the world; it is the work of historians to judge them, but religion is not at fault in them. Have Christian nations not fought political wars in the world, and are they not still doing so? Will you blame Christianity as a result? This is the position of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat: Islamic jihad is alive and enduring, but with those conditions which are the conditions of Islamic jihad.
A Palestinian friend came to me and asked: tell me, what is this war, is it jihad or not? I said: look, you want an answer from which you can create a stir. I tell you that the Jews have no right to be there; it is a political conspiracy against the Islamic world, that is my opinion. And the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat has always been in the front rank in defeating the Jews through arguments, including at the United Nations. The defence that Zafrullah Khan made, no one has ever been able to make to this day; all Muslim countries know this and were indebted to him. But if you call it religious jihad in the sense of which the Holy Prophet (saw) spoke, then tell me: has God, God forbid, … [gap] … said I am not giving you permission for jihad at all? [God says:] I have power over your victory – and in the war you are waging, where has that promise gone? Why does a small minority beat you again and again? In the midst of a huge majority it is only a small sore, yet it has become a cancer. A healthy body, however large, is overcome by a cancer even if small; this shows that the immunity of a healthy body no longer exists within you. It cannot be that you are fulfilling the conditions of the jihad God has prescribed and Allah abandons you. On one side you affirm that God has power to help, and when there is war He gives victory to the enemy and abandons the Muslims – that cannot be. Therefore from the religious point of view there are certainly some shortcomings; reform them, and then there is God's promise: 'Inna al-arda yarithuha ibadiya as-salihun' – it is about this very land that it is promised that My righteous servants will certainly be made its heirs. Therefore try to remove your moral shortcomings, try to remove the shortcomings in your faith, become righteous servants, and then God's promise will be fulfilled in your favour. One should not needlessly oppose a matter of reason and understanding. One should speak with arguments, on the basis of the Holy Qur’an and the Sunnah.