2. (The question is read out:) What would you say about non-Ahmadi people? Are they Muslims according to Ahmadiyyat or not? (Supplementary question from someone present:) Since the Messiah of Qadian, has merely reciting the Kalima Tayyiba become insufficient? For someone to call himself Muslim, is it not sufficient that he professes the Kalima Tayyiba? You just said that whoever does not acknowledge the Messiah, does not believe in him, how can he be a Muslim? (Further interjection:) The Holy Prophet (saw) did not say this to anyone who did not accept him.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 March 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (The question is read out:) What would you say about non-Ahmadi people? Are they Muslims according to Ahmadiyyat or not? (Supplementary question from someone present:) Since the Messiah of Qadian, has merely reciting the Kalima Tayyiba become insufficient? For someone to call himself Muslim, is it not sufficient that he professes the Kalima Tayyiba? You just said that whoever does not acknowledge the Messiah, does not believe in him, how can he be a Muslim? (Further interjection:) The Holy Prophet (saw) did not say this to anyone who did not accept him.
Look, the poor mullahs have often taught you such questions against Ahmadis which are emotional in nature, not factual, whose only purpose is to make you averse. This question is of exactly that nature. The fact is that the mullahs took the lead in issuing the fatwa of kufr (disbelief) against the Promised Messiah (as). The Muslim scholars of all India went on issuing fatwas of kufr, until they even reached Mecca and Medina and obtained fatwas from there. For twelve years the Promised Messiah (as) remained patient and admonished them. He said: there is a ruling of the Holy Prophet (saw) that if you do not desist from declaring a Muslim a disbeliever, this charge will turn back on you; therefore I am warning you. When they did not desist, he announced: Now I declare that whoever considers me a disbeliever, according to the verdict of the Holy Prophet (saw) – I am now compelled to say that your takfir has turned back upon you. That was the first time a declaration of takfir was made by the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, and it was on this basis. After that the Promised Messiah (as) said: whoever declares that Mirza Sahib is not a disbeliever is a Muslim, he is not a disbeliever. The same declaration stands today. So try to understand this one position of ours in this way.
Secondly, there is a fundamental difference. When you call us disbelievers, and all Muslims are calling us so, you are calling us deniers of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), which is contrary to the facts. We say: we believe in the Holy Prophet (saw) with heart and soul, we are lovers of his religion, his humblest servants; the Holy Qur’an is our book, the Sunnah is ours – this is our claim. You say: no, you are lying, you are deniers of the Holy Prophet (saw). So you are speaking against our own claim; that is not justice. In the sense in which we call you kafir, we say it according to your own claim; so what is your complaint? We say: you are deniers of the Imam Mahdi. Now tell me, what other path do we have? The one whom we accepted as Imam Mahdi – either we are lying or we are telling the truth; there is no third option. That we accepted him believing him to be true is beyond doubt, otherwise why would we bear so many hardships on this path? What is being done to us in Pakistan, no false people could endure. We have certainly accepted him as true. So one who believes that the Imam Mahdi has come and is true – if he does not call his denier a denier of the Imam Mahdi, what will he call him? Is there any third option for us besides this?
Once our [Muhyiddin?] Sahib Qasuri, Maulana, who has since passed away, asked me this very question: tell me plainly, Mirza Sahib – he was, by the way, a very noble person and also maintained love and connection – tell me plainly, what do you consider us? I said: first answer one question of mine, I promise I will then tell you plainly. He said: what? I said: tell me, according to you the Imam Mahdi has not come. When the Imam Mahdi comes, what will you call the person who calls the Imam Mahdi a liar? He said: I will call him a kafir, not a believer. So I said: then do not expect that of me. You are such a steadfast believer that you call the denier of the Imam Mahdi a kafir, and you expect of me that I should call the denier of the one whom I believe to be the Imam Mahdi a believer? What kind of justice is that? So the point is that we do not say anything contrary to your own claim. If we are wrong, you should be proud that you have been called the denier of a liar; then there is no issue at all.
(On the interjection that the Prophet did not say this:) What? The Holy Qur’an is full of it; the deniers of the Holy Prophet (saw) have been called kafir, kafir, kafir so often as in no other book in the world. (Interjection: the Holy Qur’an is not the speech of the Prophet but the speech of Allah.) The Holy Qur’an says to the Holy Prophet (saw): 'Qul ya ayyuha al-kafirun' – it commands: O Muhammad, say: O ye disbelievers! Did the Prophet (saw) obey the Holy Qur’an? What did he say – 'O believers'? I am giving an example; what better example can there be than that the Holy Qur’an addresses the Holy Prophet (saw) and says: 'Qul ya ayyuha al-kafirun' – O Muhammad (saw), proclaim, address them: O ye disbelievers! Did the Prophet (saw) then say: no, not kafir – and reject the Holy Qur’an? God forbid! You say strange things. Listen to me, I am giving the answer; if you speak in between, I will answer that too.
(On the Kalima question:) Thank you, you have voiced what was in our hearts. (On the objection that he had said one who does not acknowledge the Messiah cannot be Muslim:) I did not say that. Do not put words in my mouth. A very clear point: by reciting the Kalima Tayyiba a person becomes a Muslim; you and I agree on this. But if he denies the angels, will he still remain a Muslim? If he denies even one prophet, will he still remain a Muslim? Tell me! Look, problems are not solved by sloganeering. Religious matters should be resolved with understanding and reflection. After the Kalima Tayyiba a person becomes a Muslim, but it is necessary to fulfil all the conditions of faith. If, despite reciting the Kalima Tayyiba, a person – 'Amantu billahi wa mala'ikatihi wa kutubihi wa rusulihi wal-yaumil-akhir' – denies any one of these five things, or even any single component of them, then it is the unanimous view of all Muslim scholars, and it has come down so from the Sunnah, that he cannot be called a true, proper Muslim. Therefore the issues of 'Islam below Islam' and 'kufr below Islam' have existed in the Ummah from the very beginning. As for the position of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, it is very clear: whoever recites the Kalima Tayyiba, we cannot call him a non-Muslim; the question does not even arise. But if beyond that he denies any of these things, some form of kufr will be established in him; even so we will not call him a non-Muslim. Whoever professes the Kalima Tayyiba and says I am a Muslim, no Ahmadi has ever to this day called him a non-Muslim. Pick up the books of the Promised Messiah (as) and see. There is a difference: one is the term kafir, the other is non-Muslim; between these two terms there is a difference of heaven and earth. That is why, although Muslim scholars have all called one another kafir and still do, they did not call one another non-Muslim. What is the reason, why did they not? Because they knew. The earlier scholars were not people of superficial knowledge; they were saints, friends of Allah. They made mistakes, but they understood the foundations of Islam.
The Holy Qur’an has made a fundamental distinction between calling someone kafir and calling him non-Muslim. The Holy Qur’an, addressing the Holy Prophet (saw), says that these Bedouins who say we have believed – 'qul lam tu'minu' – tell them: you have not believed. Far from having believed – 'lamma yadkhulil-imanu fi qulubikum' – faith has not even peeped into their hearts; according to the Shariah they have no faith at all. Even so, tell them you have the right to call yourselves Muslims; you say 'aslamna' – fine, keep saying it. So this is the magnificent religion of Islam, which encompasses every aspect. Whoever claims I am a Muslim, it is established from the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah that no one has the right to call him a non-Muslim. If while remaining within Islam he says something of disbelief, there is a right to call him a kafir below Islam. The precedent for this is found in the Holy Qur’an and also in the Hadith. Let me explain it to you: the Holy Prophet (saw) says that when a Muslim steals he becomes a kafir, and yet he also called him a Muslim; when a Muslim commits adultery he becomes a kafir. In view of this principle Muslim scholars always issued fatwas of kufr against one another, but did not call one another non-Muslim. The reason is that the Holy Prophet (saw) did not permit it from the very beginning. The Holy Qur’an was revealed to him, not to just anyone; he understood the meaning of the Holy Qur’an best. That he said so-and-so has become a kafir has its place; but despite that, on one occasion in a battle a Companion overpowered an enemy. When he was about to kill him, the enemy pleaded: look, I am becoming a Muslim, I recite the Kalima, let me go – and he recited the Kalima. Despite this he killed him. He presented himself before the Holy Prophet (saw) and related with great pride: the fight went like this, I overpowered him, and in the end out of fear he said I recite the Kalima. I said: I will not let you go, you have merely become afraid – and I killed him. He narrates that in his whole life he never saw the Holy Prophet (saw) as angry as he was with him that day. And in one narration it is stated that he kept saying again and again: on the Day of Judgement, when that Kalima bears witness against you, what answer will you give? Then he said: did you tear open his heart and see whether he was saying it with his mouth or with his heart? Therefore no one has any right to call a person who calls himself a Muslim or recites the Kalima a non-Muslim – neither the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat nor any other group. That is why we never issue any fatwa contrary to your own profession, and have not done so to this day. We say: you are Muslims, but while remaining Muslims you have denied the Imam Mahdi – the one we believe to be the Imam Mahdi. Therefore for the denier of the Imam Mahdi the ruling is the same as the fatwa of your own scholars, a unanimous fatwa.
What is the need of the Imam Mahdi? That is the question. If the Imam Mahdi is to come, you should reflect for what purpose he will come. On one side God appoints him – fourteen hundred years have passed in waiting, in your view he has not yet come; suppose he comes tomorrow – and on the other side He permits him to be denied? That is against reason. It cannot be that for the sake of a magnificent religious movement God makes someone an Imam and tells people: you may well deny him, it makes no difference. Therefore our position is a position of compulsion: either we are liars, or we truly consider him the true Imam Mahdi. When we consider him true, then whoever denies the one we call Imam Mahdi, we will call him a denier of the Imam Mahdi, but we will not call him a non-Muslim. You call us non-Muslims; that is an injustice. The Holy Qur’an gives no permission whatsoever for that.