3. Why do Ahmadis not perform Fatiha Khwani when they go to a Muslim's home upon a death? (Follow-ups:) Our elders, whom we follow – did they know less about Islam? Were our elders wrong, were they not Muslims? Is this a custom? Fatiha Khwani is indeed a prayer.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 March 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Why do Ahmadis not perform Fatiha Khwani when they go to a Muslim's home upon a death? (Follow-ups:) Our elders, whom we follow – did they know less about Islam? Were our elders wrong, were they not Muslims? Is this a custom? Fatiha Khwani is indeed a prayer.
This is completely wrong. Ahmadi Muslims express sympathy upon the death of every Muslim, go to their homes, pray for them; and for other Muslims too – the ones I am speaking of – we also pray at their graves. There is not the slightest fatwa of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat against this; it is an entirely false allegation. With what you call Fatiha Khwani, our only disagreement is with the term Fatiha Khwani. The term Fatiha Khwani is not found anywhere in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) or the Rightly Guided Caliphs. Can you present a single Hadith or a verse of the Holy Qur’an which proves that the Muslims of the early centuries went to the homes of those in which a death had occurred and raised their hands and read the Fatiha? Show one Hadith from which it is learnt that on the occasion of the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw) any Companion performed Fatiha Khwani. We are only explaining to you: do not start new customs in Islam. The religion of the Holy Prophet (saw) is sufficient for us. That beautiful Islam is the one established by the Sunnah. When you step outside it, you will fall into customs and traditions.
(On the objection about the elders:) Look, this is exactly what I am asking you: will you follow the elders …? I am telling you exactly this: the Holy Prophet (saw) did not perform Fatiha Khwani. This is exactly what I am saying: whatever goes beyond the Sunnah is not Islam. Were Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), and his Companions wrong? No. I am saying that customs enter religions later on. Yes, it is a custom. A custom is everything that is not Sunnah, which is not established from the Messenger of Allah (saw) and his Companions. Therefore customs can be good and can be bad, but they cannot become Sunnah. The real point is that when those saints came to India, there was immense ignorance here, owing to the Hindu religion many bad customs were prevalent, and because of language differences and other problems they wanted to give them at least a minimum of religious instruction by some means. Because of this, many things were initially introduced with good intention which later became customs – for example teaching Surah Al-Fatiha and having the Fatiha recited as a prayer. I am sure they started it this way. They must have said: when you pray for a saint or a deceased person, then since Surah Al-Fatiha is a complete prayer, learn this short prayer; you do not know much Arabic, recite this everywhere; it will be of use in Salat too, it will be of use everywhere. Thus, owing to lack of knowledge, in the beginning, for the instruction and training of Hindus, our Sufis and saints adopted this method. When Islam spread further, when Islamic teaching became widespread and clear, it was necessary to take them back to the Sunnah. And this is the effort we are making; we are doing nothing other than this. Now there is the fortieth day, the eleventh, sweets are distributed after a death, [food] is distributed, meals are given – so many disputes, of which there is no trace in the Islam of the early centuries. To say 'so our elders are wrong' is emotional talk. It is the same talk which the Holy Qur’an repeatedly mentions, that the opponents of the Holy Prophet (saw) used to say to him: so are our forefathers wrong? The Holy Qur’an says: why can your forefathers not be wrong? Only he is not in error upon whom revelation descends; only he is right to whom God grants light. So I do not understand the cause of disagreement in this. I give you this message, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat gives this message: the Sunnah should be sufficient for us, because in the Sunnah religion was perfected. To perfect beauty nothing can be added, nor can anything be taken away. Therefore the later customs have harmed us. We have gradually moved away from Islam because we have clung like empty vessels to the customs introduced later, even if they arose with good intention. Therefore come out of customs and traditions, establish the Sunnah, return to the Islam of the early centuries, practise simplicity in marriage and weddings, practise simplicity in death and burial, and all these burdens lying upon us will be lifted from you. The Sunnah of the Holy Prophet (saw) was that they offered the funeral prayer, prayed and showed sympathy to one another. We do the same. There should be no objection to this.
(On the objection that Fatiha Khwani is a prayer:) No, for the sake of prayer we too recite the Fatiha, but I am speaking only against the custom. When one goes somewhere – I have been many times – one man raises his hands and everyone follows: this is Fatiha Khwani. (Interjection: the Fatiha prayer.) No, this is a different practice. The Fatiha prayer as a prayer is a distinct thing. In prayer the heart moves, then it is genuine; prayer is not a custom. One should know the meaning of the Fatiha; a person should, reflecting and immersed in the attributes of Allah, beseech Him with 'iyyaka na'budu wa iyyaka nasta'in'. That is prayer. In this respect reciting the Fatiha as a prayer is by no means forbidden. But the custom that has been formed – that one must recite it and recite it in imitation, and when someone comes, one man raises his hands and everyone follows – is completely baseless. There is no authority for it in Islam; it is a mockery of Islam. Therefore we request you that instead of being annoyed with us you reform yourselves. What is wrong with the religion which Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), demonstrated through his practice? Tell me, why should it not suffice? It ought to suffice.