5. Question number two: You surely know that Hindu women fill sindoor in the parting of their hair for the welfare and closeness of their husbands. A man employed at a sindoor factory hesitantly asked the factory owner: 'Sir, is what is written on the sindoor box true?' The owner sensed the delicacy of the matter and said laughingly: 'God gave the knowledge of sindoor to my father in a dream; I am just carrying on the work he started.' Would you kindly tell us whether Mirza Sahib was truly a prophet, or did he too merely dream of being a prophet? Is your conscience satisfied in this matter that you are carrying on the work Mirza Ghulam Ahmad started? – Ejaz Sahib Janjua.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 March 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Question number two: You surely know that Hindu women fill sindoor in the parting of their hair for the welfare and closeness of their husbands. A man employed at a sindoor factory hesitantly asked the factory owner: 'Sir, is what is written on the sindoor box true?' The owner sensed the delicacy of the matter and said laughingly: 'God gave the knowledge of sindoor to my father in a dream; I am just carrying on the work he started.' Would you kindly tell us whether Mirza Sahib was truly a prophet, or did he too merely dream of being a prophet? Is your conscience satisfied in this matter that you are carrying on the work Mirza Ghulam Ahmad started? – Ejaz Sahib Janjua.

Through the long route of sindoor he has finally disclosed his real point. The Holy Qur’an says: 'Ya ayyuhalladhina amanuttaqullaha wa qulu qaulan sadida, yuslih lakum a'malakum' – O you who believe, adopt righteousness and speak the straightforward word. Straightforward speech reforms deeds. The straightforward question was: if I consider the Promised Messiah (as) a prophet, do I truly consider him so, and if so in what sense; and do I believe the work I do is truly right? The answer is: I consider the Promised Messiah (as) a prophet exactly in the sense in which the word Nabiullah was used for the coming Messiah. Listen carefully to my answer: I consider him a prophet exactly in the sense in which the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw), upon whom the verse Khatam-an-Nabiyyin was revealed, used the word Nabiullah for the coming Messiah – not the one who had passed, but the coming Messiah; and in one hadith of Muslim he used this word four times. I consider him a prophet in the sense in which the concept of Imam Mahdi is found in the Holy Qur’an and in which the Holy Prophet (saw) gave the prophecy of the Imam Mahdi. If the status of the Imam Mahdi was not that of a prophet subordinate to the Holy Prophet, then Hazrat Mirza Sahib by no means had that status either. But if the status of the Imam Mahdi is that of an ummati prophet, and if the status of the Muhammadan Messiah is that of an ummati prophet, then the status of Hazrat Mirza Sahib too is that of an ummati prophet. It is impossible that someone claims to be the Messiah, is truthful in his claim, and says: I am the Messiah but not a prophet. For the hadith of Muslim will testify against him: O claimant, how did you become the Messiah? Muhammad, the noble Messenger (saw), upon whom the verse Khatam-an-Nabiyyin is revealed, states as the sign of the Messiah's truthfulness that he will be Nabiullah. If you are a Messiah who is not Nabiullah, then go, you liar, we have nothing to do with you – that will be the answer. If someone claims to be Imam Mahdi and at the same time claims: God did not make me Imam through revelation, I became one myself – would you care a penny for his claim or not? Think about it in your heart. Instead of objecting to Ahmadiyyat for the sake of making a witty point, first clarify your own belief: what is the status of the Imam Mahdi in your view? I know, and if you search your hearts and ask your scholars, you cannot reach any conclusion other than that the Imam Mahdi can be nothing but an ummati prophet. In him are found those two conditions which are necessary for every prophet, which cannot be found outside a prophet, and you believe that these two conditions are found in the Imam Mahdi. What is the condition of a prophet? Allah raises him and through His revelation makes him the Imam of the age – that is the first condition of prophethood. The second condition is that He does not permit his denial and declares belief in him necessary. Are these two conditions common to prophethood or not? Tell me, or if you do not want to say, think about it in your heart. Now tell me, without which of these two conditions will the Imam Mahdi be? Will the Imam Mahdi rise of his own accord? Will the people elect the Imam Mahdi? Will God appoint him or not? If the revelation of Imamat came to him and God appointed him, then the next question resolves itself: whomever God raises – whether one likes it or not – He does not permit any person to deny him. And the scholars of the entire Ummah are agreed on this even today. Go and ask a scholar of any sect; he will tell you that these two conditions are necessary in the Imam Mahdi: God will appoint him – otherwise no one would even spit in the face of an imam made by men. God will appoint him, and pledging allegiance to him and accepting him will be obligatory for the Ummah. If any scholar does not accept this, show him the hadith in which the Holy Prophet (saw) commands: When the Imam Mahdi appears, you must reach him even if you have to cross mountains of snow. One instruction is: pledge allegiance to him; the other: convey my salaam to him. Both these hadiths are well known. Now tell me: the one about whom Muhammad, the noble Messenger (saw), says that when the Imam Mahdi appears you must go, even crawling on your knees over mountains of snow, and pledge allegiance to him – is belief in him necessary or not? If it is necessary – and your heart testifies that it is – then tell me, has the Holy Qur’an declared belief in anyone necessary other than prophets? Allah, messengers, angels, books, the Last Day and prophets – besides these it has not declared belief in any institution necessary. And all scholars agree on the necessity of believing in the Imam Mahdi. Whether you hold the ear from behind or from the right side – whether one has the courage to say it or not are separate issues. Righteousness demands that you ascertain your own belief: what do you believe about the Imam Mahdi? In terms of belief, do you accept prophethood in him or not? Not in terms of Shariah – in that our belief is the same: that he is one hundred percent subordinate to and a servant of the Shariah of Muhammad Mustafa, one hundred percent subordinate to and a servant of the commands of the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw). These conditions are common to your belief and ours; there can be no objection there. But the components you have established for the Imam Mahdi are components of prophethood. If you want further proof: I had submitted that the word Imam Mahdi exists in the Holy Qur’an. And for the Ahl-e-Qur’an who say this is a fabrication and that they do not accept that the Holy Prophet (saw) said it, this is an effective answer. The Holy Qur’an, after mentioning the prophets – in one place, indeed in more than one – naming the prophets, says: 'Wa ja'alnahum a'immatan yahduna bi-amrina'. These are all those people: Noah, Moses, Jesus and Abraham – after naming them all, He says: regarding them We did two things. Number one: 'ja'alnahum a'imma' – a'imma is the plural of Imam, as one says a'imma-e-kiram. So God clarified that We make the prophets Imams. The second clarification: 'yahduna bi-amrina' – they do not guide on their own; they first receive guidance from Us and then guide. What do you call one who guides of himself? Hadi. One familiar with Arabic grammar understands immediately: as one says Qatil – that is the form of Fa'il (agent). And one who first receives guidance from someone and then passes it on – the form of Maf'ul applies to him, and he is called Mahdi. So the Holy Qur’an in one place defined the prophets thus: in all the prophets two conditions were found. First, they were Imams whom We had made, not whom the people had chosen. Second, they were not Hadi but Mahdi: they received guidance from Us and then spoke among the people, not without Our guidance. So this is a term in the Holy Qur’an, and not in one place but in three places in the Holy Qur’an this verse was revealed in different contexts, and always concerning prophets. Therefore the issue should be resolved and the strife should not be needlessly prolonged. We are ready to swear by every holy name of God and declare that we do not consider the status of Mirza Sahib even a needle's breadth higher than the status of the Imam Mahdi, nor a needle's breadth lower. Debate with us what the status of the Imam Mahdi will be – not our Imam Mahdi; your Imam who is to come – determine his status. If you do so with righteousness, no conclusion emerges except that he will be an ummati prophet: he will be an Imam, God will appoint him, and the Ummah will not be permitted to deny him. If not today, then tomorrow such an Imam is bound to come – what answer will you give him? [Questioner interjects: So you too think that if not today, another Imam is to come?] Quite right – but there is nothing (ambiguous) in it; this is a manner of speech. Through familiarity with the Urdu language – Lucknowi friends are sitting here, ask them – one cannot speak at all without this manner of speech. When we say: if not this one, then tomorrow another will come, it is a form of argument, a manner of speech. The Holy Qur’an has used this manner of speech; therefore one should not mock something the Holy Qur’an has also used. [Questioner: You are a scholar and an elder; asking you was my sincerity, and clarifying it is my sincerity.] Jazakallah, but – all right, I apologise; your manner gave me that impression. [Questioner: No, I am not mocking; you are a scholar, I am nothing.] No, no, you are my honoured guest. Good, the misunderstanding is removed, Jazakallah. The Holy Qur’an also uses this manner: if not this, then it will be thus. Say to them: if there were gods besides God, the heavens and the earth would have been rent asunder. That is in the Holy Qur’an, isn't it? Now if someone says: so God accepts the possibility of other gods besides Him – certainly not! It is a manner of argument: if you do not accept this, then that would follow. All right, Jazakumullah.

10 of 10 left today