2. Is it true that, according to the Holy Qur’an, a true prophet cannot be murdered?

Question-and-answer session, 4 April 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it true that, according to the Holy Qur’an, a true prophet cannot be murdered?

Why Hazrat Yahya was killed? Why he didn't why he had he he was beheaded, whereas we go and present to the people, we say, according to the Ayat, Wa lau taqawwala 'alaina ba'dal-aqawil, a Prophet must live a natural life. I mean, he shouldn't be…

Yes, I understand the point.

The fact is that the translation of Wa lau taqawwala 'alaina ba'dal-aqawil, la-akhadhna minhu bil-yamin, thumma la-qata'na minhul-watin. The translation of this this verse, particularly the part thumma la-qata'na minhul-watin, is made too literally, while in in reality it cannot be translated literally, because then in in every case the jugular vein will have to be cut by God and somebody would have to be taken by hand literally, by the right hand. So obviously these are Arabic idioms and they should be translated accordingly.

Moreover, it is an accepted principle that if one verse of the Holy Qur’an is to be correctly translated, it should agree with the rest of the Holy Qur’an and should not, that translation, and should not contradict any part, verse or verse of the Holy Qur’an; otherwise the translation is wrong.

So if by this you translate, by this verse you translate as Allah has promised that whoever makes a false claim to prophethood, attributes something to God which Allah has not said, then Allah would certainly murder him—if that is the translation, then how would you translate the verse which pertains to AanHazrat (saw)? And it says:

وَمَا مُحَمَّدٌ إِلَّا رَسُولٌ قَدْ خَلَتْ مِنْ قَبْلِهِ الرُّسُلُ أَفَإِنْ مَاتَ أَوْ قُتِلَ انْقَلَبْتُمْ عَلَىٰ أَعْقَابِكُمْ

Khala, the word khala has been translated as ordinary death or murder. Even if the, Na'uzu Billahi min zalik, the murder of AanHazrat (saw) could not mean that he was a false prophet, because the following part is inqalabtum 'ala a'qabikum—did you have a right to renegade and to turn your backs against Islam? That verse shows that even if, Na'uzu Billahi min zalik, AanHazrat (saw) had been murdered, the enemies of Islam had the the Muslims had no right to turn their backs to Islam and say he is a false prophet.

So murder of a prophet is not at all against the truth of that prophet, is not an argument against the truth of that prophet. Similarly, the Holy Qur’an repeatedly tells us of many a prophet who was murdered at the hand of the Jews. So, that being so, that this verse should be translated, the verse in question, in accordance with these statements of the Holy Qur’an.

So, la-qatana minhul-watin should not be translated as "We would have killed him", but it should have been translated as "We would have destroyed him", and this is exactly what the meaning of the verse is. When you cut the jugular vein, you totally destroy the signs of life. I mean, there is no possibility left. It is a complete and total destruction of the man.

So, here it means that if anyone makes a false claim, Allah would see to it that he is destroyed, he is uprooted, he is annihilated. This is the translation which is should be acceptable in the light of other verses of the Holy Qur’an.

So, Hazrat Yahya, if murdered, it is no it's nothing strange about it. In reality, prophets before Hazrat Yahya had been murdered, and murdering of a prophet is not a sign of his falsehood. That is one way of looking at this problem.

There is another way from the religious point of view. Here Allah says, "la-akhadhna minhu bil-yamin", "We will destroy him", "We will kill him", and on the other hand, it is nowhere denied that the enemies of the prophets cannot kill them. The subjects are different in both these cases. On the one hand, prophets are opposed by the ordinary people and they sometimes succeed in killing prophets. But it is not Allah who destroys them. Here Allah says, "I will do it." That means that Allah will also make a distinction in this regard. Allah will see to it that such a person is really destroyed and is exposed as well.

So in case of Dowie, for instance, although he was not murdered, but when he was destroyed by Allah, his own people abandoned him. He was deserted by all, friends and foes alike. His name was tarnished. He had to accept in so many words that he was not the son of the so-called father of his, but his mother was a wanton woman, and this statement he gave in the he submitted in before a court of law.

So all these things are the signs that it is Allah who is doing it. If just a chance murder occurs, nobody can say that this is Allah's doing. But if the whole surrounding turns against somebody and signs appear in in in frequently, and they encompass the person from all sides until he has no way out, this is the punishment of Allah which has been described here.

Otherwise, catching by the right hand doesn't mean anything. Catching by the right hand in reality means that his power will be destroyed; he will not be permitted to run away.

So this phenomenon occurs when really the punishment comes from Allah, and it should not be confused with an ordinary chance murder of a prophet at the hand of the enemy. It's actually it's the failure of the mission of the of a prophet—failure, not just the failure, but failure in a strong way where one can seem when can see and witness the wrath of Allah falling upon such a person. That is, if he is a conscious liar, if he is in his full contr in his if he is in control of his senses and so on, then it should happen. This shouldn't happen to every madman who claims to be a prophet.

10 of 10 left today