4. Why does God place "a covering of the hearts" of some people, as mentioned in the Holy Qur’an (17:47), if all humans are supposed to be have free will to choose whatever religion they like?
Question-and-answer session, 25 April 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why does God place "a covering of the hearts" of some people, as mentioned in the Holy Qur’an (17:47), if all humans are supposed to have free will to choose whatever religion they like?
I'll read verse 47 of Surah Bani Isra'il in the translation: "And we put coverings over their hearts, lest they should understand it, and in their ears a deafness. And when thou makest mention in the Holy Qur’an of thy Lord alone, they turn their backs in aversion." So my question is, the human being is left on his own free will in this earth, and here Allah says He puts coverings over their hearts Himself, I mean, that is something Allah...
You know, these verses, or I should say such verses, should be understood in the light of those fundamental verses which are the governing clauses in this regard. The fundamental verse in this regard is: Fa-man sha'a fal-yu'min wa man sha'a fal-yakfur, La ikraha fid-deen. These are categorical statements of the Holy Qur’an, that there is no compulsion in religion whatsoever. Man sha'a fal-yu'min wa man sha'a fal-yakfur—whoever pleases, he can become a believer; whoever so pleases, he can become an infidel. It's up to him.
So there are so many of these fundamental statements of the Holy Qur’an that such statements as you have just made must be read in the light of those statements. And these statements, such statements as you have made, as you referred to, I mean, they have been mentioned elsewhere in the Holy Qur’an with different twists, with the result that when you bring them together, then you can begin to see the meaning involved.
The fact is that people will be declared diseased or incapable of receiving message because of their inner diseases by Allah. And this act of Allah's declaration that now they have passed cure, this is mentioned in this verse. When Allah says that their hearts are closed to this, and Allah made their hearts closed, according to the idiom of the Holy Qur’an, it should be read: Allah declared their hearts to be closed. Allah declared, declared their case to be irretrievably lost.
So this is the declaration of Allah which is mentioned in this way:
فِي قُلُوبِهِمْ مَرَضٌ فَزَادَهُمُ اللَّهُ مَرَضًا
Which means, the disease was within their heart, but it was not obvious. They were destined to die of that disease anyway. So Allah aggravated the disease, that is, caused it to be aggravated so that it could capture the whole being and then people would know that they are diseased people.
And then their fate is sealed. So because Allah is the ultimate of everything, so sometimes He refers the causative to Himself. But in other verses where as such as I have just mentioned, and and many other verses, Allah explains the fact that initially and originally, the people themselves are responsible, but they reach a stage where the matter is past cure, so Allah gives the declaration. After that declaration, nothing can be done.
Man yahdihillahu fala mudilla lahu, wa man yudlilhu fala hadiya lahu—this is again one of the the the same type of statements, that whomsoever Allah declares the rightly guided one, no one can misguide him from then on. Whomsoever Allah declares—I I'm translating it as 'declares'—declares to be misguided, from then on nobody can ever guide such a people. So ordinarily the misguided are are guided, can be guided, otherwise there is no sense in sending prophets. So here you have to translate it like this: whomsoever Allah declares to be misguided, that is, Allah considers that they have reached a stage of erroneous and mischievous behavior where they will not be guided from then on.
So these all these verses belong to this category.
— So even if it says, "I have increased their—" as you just mentioned, increased their maraz...
— Yes.
— ...then that is still a declaration.
— That is still declaration in the sense that Allah permitted that that disease to take its normal course. You know, when you leave the attempt to cure and some disease is persistent, and then you leave: "All right, let it happen what let happen what what may happen to it"—that is, Allah increases their disease, that is the sense. Allah would not forcefully stop that disease from then on.
— So on the other hand, when Allah says He has exalted some above others, is this the same sort of thing on the other side?
— Allah exalts some others, some above the others, on meritorious grounds, on merit.
— He doesn't help Himself...
— What do you mean by it?
— When He says, "We exalt some above others"...
— Yes.
— He again uses "We exalt".
— Of course Allah exalts, because automatically you can't reach anything. You can't even get the fruit of your labor automatically. You know, this is we are in a state of sleepiness, we are living as if we are dormant. We don't realize that what we believe is as automatic consequence of our labor is not not at automatic at all. If Allah provides the fruit of the labor, then we get the fruit, otherwise we won't get anything. There are so many factors involved between the labor and the ultimate ripening and gathering of the fruit, and later on benefiting from that fruit, that if a single stage is lost, your fruit is lost.
So Allah sees to it that those who put in labor, their labor is rewarded. And for that, maybe hundreds of thousands of factor are factors are working, which are unobserved and unseen by our eyes. So this is why the ultimate responsibility is taken by Allah. He is He does this and He does that.
In one of the Surahs, I think it is Waqi'ah or in one of the end Surahs, the Holy Qur’an particularly harps on this subject: that you burn the fire and you think the flame that you burn, that does this, but no, it is Allah who does it; you sow the seeds and you think that the crop that has followed, it is your labor. It is it is not so, it is Allah who brings the crop and sees to it that ultimately it bears fruit.
Now, when you read that full Surah, then you begin to understand the meaning. That it is not as simple as that: you throw a seed somewhere and it would suddenly... that you consider labor, and as if the natural consequence should be that immediately that shoot that that seed should increase in number. It should be not be the natural consequence. The natural consequence should be that whatever you throw away is thrown away and lost. Its multiplication is a special phenomenon, is a special favor. You throw the same seed even in a wrong ti— at a wrong time, you lose it; in the wrong atmosphere, you still lose it; in the wrong climate; in the wrong soil. And yes, you throw in everything in every perfect condition, every suitable condition, and there is no rain from Allah. Some disease occurs for which other factors which are responsible to ward off that disease are not operative by Allah's command, and suddenly the crop is overwhelmed.
Even if you go into the ecology and consider this aspect of a farmer's labor, and the stages involved between that labor and the ultimate fruition of that labor, then you will begin to understand that everything is beyond our control. Because automatically so many factors from Allah are involved and they are helping us, we believe in our blindness that, "Oh, you see, we did it and we got it."
Once I remember—it's a very interesting incident—I remember that when Hazrat Khalifatul Masih
Salis (rh), the third caliph, ordered his first—um, that what's that machine in English that's... you know, that cuts the crop and threshes it, threshes it? What? Combine? No, combine. Combine harvester. That's called combine harvester.
So when he first ordered his combine, I also ordered along with him, and our combines reached about the same time. And the crop was just ready, and both he and I had very good crops, just first-class crops. And while his combine reached first, while we were examining, he also sent a message to me that, "Come and see this combine." It actually was, I think, a Danish or Swedish-made combine. We got it from Shahnawaz Limited. So, it was a beautiful affair and we were enjoying it.
Suddenly, a cloud rose, which was an abnormal cloud, you know, a column of cloud came very rapidly and it developed into a storm. And it started, you know, a hailstorm started. Hails came in such size that never in my life did I see a hail that big. One of them I took home later on from my farm and weighed, and it still weighed half a pound. Many a cattle was killed. Some roofs were pierced through by the hailstorm, by the hails, and some children under the roof were killed or injured. That was the extent of damage that was done to the crops by that hailstorm. The result was that there was nothing to reap.
So, Hazrat Khalifatul Masih Salis (rh) gave a khutbah, sermon, on that, and he was very happy. And we were all very happy with the grace of Allah because we knew that it was a reminder from Allah to us that even for a fraction of a second, if Allah's grace is taken away, you can be deprived of your labor's fruit, which you consider it is your labor's fruit.
Things are held in order, in balance. So many factors are working underneath and so many angels are at work all the time to run the machinery of universe in perfect balance, and we think we have done it and we can do it. This is wrong. So Allah is justified when He says, "I did it, and I did it," yes? In that sense I mean.