9. Is the injunction in the Holy Qur’an to put loans into writing (2:283) applicable during social occasions between family and friends?
Question-and-answer session, 25 April 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Is the injunction in the Holy Qur’an to put loans into writing (2:283) applicable during social occasions between family and friends?
Surah Baqarah, verse 283 tells us that when we take a loan, one from another, for a term, we must write it down, except when it is a transaction on the spot, when goods and money...
Why don't you read the verse?
Yes, Huzoor. Verse, the verse which was, I got...
Yes, read the verse, because this sort of loose translation is not the right way to go about it.
Daynin faktubuhu, you know, these are the words, but I don't remember the full verse. Can I read the English translation?
Okay, yes, go ahead.
“O ye who believe, when you borrow one from another for a fixed period, then write it down and let a scribe write it in your presence faithfully. And no scribe should refuse to write, because Allah has taught him, so let him write, and let him who incurs the liability dictate, and he should fear Allah, his Lord, and not diminish...”
Yes, that will suffice, yes. Now what is the question?
Huzoor, Huzoor's guidance is requested in the light of the above Surah in respect of the following situations and other similar instances.
This is a common practice: that friends and colleagues borrow small sums from one another, payable later, and no written documents are exchanged.
Number two: people travelling together, relatives and friends, pay petty expenses to be shared later, contribute as and when required, and no writing is done at the time of payment. The whole transactions are done verbally.
Third, I have quoted three instances, Huzoor.
Yes, please go ahead, yes.
This is common among the ladies that they join together, each contributing a fixed sum for a period, and the total sum collected each period is received by each by their turn agreed in the beginning of the system. To my knowledge, no receipts are issued while receiving or giving. This is the common practice.
So what, do you want to change it?
No, Huzoor, I... this is...
I mean, when you go out for for a picnic or something and somebody buys you an ice cream, you know, or fish and chips, would you go immediately into writing, you know, then? Yet, the person who sells that to you does it. So it is, this verse mainly applies to business affairs, and you shouldn't extend it to these regions of ordinary social behaviour, day-to-day life.
This verse doesn't apply to these day-to-day ordinary commonplace experiences. But it applies to business transactions, and there everybody must do it. If he does not, then the consequence would not be Allah's wrath, because this verse does not belong to that category where Allah wants you to do something, if you do not do, then you will incur punishment of Allah.
This verse belongs to a category where it's an advice for keeping our economic order healthy, and if we ignore this advice, then by the natural economic laws or social moral laws we would, we will be automatically punished. So when these transactions have a serious nature and you don't commit them to writing, then generally it happens that differences appear, and sometimes they reach, take the shape of lawsuits and quarrels, and sometimes even end up into murders. So this, these are the punishments of natural laws of Allah.
So when you don't do it in ordinary life, number one, don't consider that you're violating the laws of God and it's a sin, because this verse should not be meant to be a religious obligation to the extent that Allah would not be pleased or Allah would punish you if you don't do it. It's a strong economic advice and a strong social advice as well. If you ignore this advice, you'll be punished by the economic and social laws of God.
This is why most of the quarrels which are reported to us, even between an Ahmadi and an Ahmadi, revolve around these neglects. Contracts are made verbally and they are not put to writing, they are not signed. And imagine the beauty of the Holy Qur’an that 1400 years ago, when writing was a rare art with the people, particularly with the people of Arabia—the common lot was ignorance, total ignorance of the art of writing; they were illiterate people—and to make it binding upon them, at that time, to commit these things to writing, is a very rare thing. No religious book could ever have thought of it. But the Holy Qur’an has done it.
So this is the beauty of the teaching, and it also emphasizes the fact that when the age arrives when everybody would be able to read and write, if you still ignore this, then you'll be punished in the sense I have described. And because even in Ahmadiyya community people are not paying proper attention to such orders, they suffer as a consequence. They say, "We, I said, I said that," somebody says, "I said that," and the other one says, "No, you said that in that meaning and not in this meaning," and so on and so forth. Unnecessary quarrel is prolonged and the whole atmosphere of the society is tarnished and destroyed.
So this, this verse should be followed to the maximum in all serious transactions, not in ordinary transactions like you have quoted.