11. Why was the prophet Zakaria surprised when his prayer for a son was accepted?
Question-and-answer session, 25 April 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why was the prophet Zakaria surprised when his prayer for a son was accepted?
Is that in Surah Al-e-Imran, where Allah Ta'ala gives the details about the birth of Hazrat Yahya, the prayer is mentioned of Hazrat Zakaria after seeing Mary, and he prays to Allah that he may be given a zurriyyat—the word zurriyyat is used there—and when Allah Ta'ala gives him the glad tidings, in the next verse it is mentioned that he was surprised, how could he have a son when his wife is barren and he is so old, which seems contradictory if we mean the zurriyyat, which is translated as offspring? The word zurriyyat is used there in that, that prayer? Right. Let me re-... just a moment.
I can read it and make sure that...
Nahin nahin, nahin hai.
Surah Maryam. In the first few verses of Surah Maryam, this is mentioned, and Al-e-Imran also it's mentioned. Idh nada Rabbahu... and Al-e-Imran also it's mentioned: Idh nada Rabbahu nida’an khafiyya. Aapko yaad hai na? No, no, not that one, the other one. Idh nada Rabbahu nida’an khafiyya. Wa qala Rabbi inni wahanal-‘azmu minni wa-shta‘alar-ra’su shaiba... Aha, after that, what is it? Qala inni khiftul-mawaliya min wara'i wa kanatimra'ati ‘aqira... ‘Aqira, yes. Fahab li mil-ladunka waliyya. Waliyya! Zurriyyat is not used; the word waliyya is used. That's in Surah Maryam, but in Surah Al-e-Imran... There the word zurriyyat is used. Achha. So he's referring to that verse. Right. Please read the exact text.
Hunalika da‘a Zakariyya Rabbahu, qala Rabbi hab li mil-ladunka zurriyyatan tayyibah.
Yes, that's right. Zurriyyatan tayyibah. These are the words. Correct.
Innaka sami‘ud-du‘a. Fanadat-hul-mala’ikatu wa huwa qa’imun yusalli fil-mihrabi anna Allaha yubashiruka bi-Yahya musaddiqan bi-kalimatin minallahi wa sayyidan wa hasuran wa nabiyyam-minas-salihin. Qala Rabbi anna yakunu li ghulamun wa qad balaghaniyal-kibaru wamra'ati ‘aqir. Qala kadhalikallahu yaf‘alu ma yasha’.
So, this seems sort of confusing, that after he is praying for a son—zurriyyat translated here as offspring—and when he is given the glad tidings, he is showing his surprise again, that how can I have a son, when his prayer is answered.
Now, this is... you know, the word surprise can be understood variously. Sometimes when you are told something which is very pleasant to you, and you also believe that it would be so, yet you say, "All right, is that going to happen to me? Would that be?" This is natural. Achha, as you say it in Urdu, or "Well, will it be?" That sort of expression, or other expressions equivalent to this achha, are used in every language.
So that does not mean that you do not believe in the statement. It only means that you are very happily surprised, and it's an expression of gratitude instead, and thankfulness and enjoyment. So, it... here it is used in that context. It does not mean either here or in the place where Hazrat Ibrahim's wife, Sara, showed this surprise and said that, well, I am, you know, I am an old woman, how could it be? That doesn't mean that they disbelieved the word of God at all. Not disbelieving, but showing that he would know that he is old.
No, that surprise... that surprise, as I have mentioned, is psychological. Human psychology is at work normally. In every such situation, whether he be a pious man or an impious man, these are the psychological expressions of man in such occasions. So, it only should be meant to... I mean, you should understand them to mean that he was very happily surprised. That is exactly what the Holy Qur’an wants to state.
Zurriyyatan then does mean—it doesn't mean an heir, it just means an offspring, a son?
Zurriyyah may mean many things, and this also is the meaning. Zurriyyah is generally offspring or generation as well.
You know, a single offspring can also be referred to under the word zurriyyah, and a full generation can also be expressed with the word zurriyyah, if that is what you want to understand.
Yeah, I understood it that way because then he saw Hazrat Maryam being blessed so much that whenever he would go to visit her, he would find her all these different things. So he naturally got the desire that he should have some of his progeny or from his followers, maybe somebody who would...
No, but the things which you have missed to notice, the common factors about both, that neither do we find the children of Hazrat Yahya nor of Hazrat Isa (as). You see, it's very interesting. As I understand this, that was the end of the line of Hazrat Ishaq, and this was practically exhibited to them that you have come to an end, and from now on the line would be changed to the children of Ismail; no longer the favours of Allah would remain with you. Now, to soften this shock, this method was adopted by God.
The end line, before it came to an end, their parents were, you know, were shown these signs of zurriyyah, so that they were satisfied. But before they knew that they would be martyred, or they would end up without any generation behind, they had themselves died in satisfaction. As far as they were concerned, they had the zurriyyah behind them.
But Allah's will was also carried out. And it is in a way tragic, but in another way, it is compassion of Allah which is exhibited. It had to be like that. It was a fate which had to be accomplished, because much higher things were at stake. A definite message was to be given to that generation that: “That’s all, enough. We have tried you, and ultimately you have failed, and We are shifting the blessing from you to the other promised son.” So this is why, physically also, they were shown these signs.