2. (No separate question audible; Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh) invites further questions and then speaks on examining the claim of Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as), especially the claim to prophethood.)

Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (No separate question audible; Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh) invites further questions and then speaks on examining the claim of Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as), especially the claim to prophethood.)

You have asked the remaining questions in detail; if you wish to ask anything more, you may. Research of course continues. But I request you to research with righteousness (Taqwa). For I have complete conviction, and every Ahmadi has conviction, that he who claimed, I am the Messiah and Imam Mahdi, ... – the signs of liars are not those that are visible in his followers. When a liar lies, he lies for some purpose, and his purpose cannot be pure. Never has a liar produced worshippers who pray, never has a liar produced servants of the Holy Qur’an, never has a liar produced people who sacrifice wealth and property in the name of God. All this forms a collective picture. Therefore, if this teaching is not correct in your view, at most you can say it is mistaken; you cannot level the charge of lying, because the signs of a liar are different: his manner of speech, his way of life, the kind of people he produces are different. Hazrat Masih (as) said a very beautiful sentence: a tree is known by its fruit. If a man is a liar, what need has he to produce people who sacrifice in the name of Allah, offer prayers, serve religion, bear abuse and suffering, even become martyrs and give their lives, yet stay firm on their purpose? That is why all God-fearing people judge thus: if we do not understand their beliefs, they may be mistaken, but they are not liars. Some people err; some errors are trials, but their basis is not sin; a person understands a matter in a certain way without ill intent. Now all these Christians who believe three to be one and one to be three – you cannot call them liars, because for three hundred years, first together and then continuously, they made sacrifices for their religion. You can say they are mistaken. There is a big difference between the two. And that is why those Christian authors who were relatively nobler and more God-fearing did not use the word liar about the Holy Prophet (saw). All these authors write that he had complete faith in his message. A biographer ..., wherever he gets the chance he stabs and drives the dagger in, but when it comes to the truthfulness of the Holy Prophet (saw), he necessarily affirms it. Lane-Poole is one, Carlyle is one, who expressed this with great emphasis, although he did not become a Muslim; he says this man was not a liar. Likewise the saints, the ... Muslim thinkers and leading scholars at the beginning of this century did not use such words about Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as). Even to Maulana Azad the Ahrar came and said: give a fatwa. He said: I cannot call him a liar; I do not accept him, I disagree with his beliefs, but that I should believe he is lying – that I cannot say. Very great saints, Sufis and scholars of that time expressed themselves this way. When you read our polemical literature you will be amazed: only the names of a few scholars appear who were prepared to call him a liar; the rest said: we do not know, but we have differences in beliefs. So the first correction to make is in this attitude: how can you knowingly call people liars whose entire community has been making sacrifices for a hundred years, doing good and transforming lives? Therefore examine whether in the beliefs they are mistaken or you are mistaken. Whichever side the Holy Qur’an is with, one should go with that; then the matter is settled. But set the arguments against each other. One big point: the ulama today say he claimed prophethood, and after that there is no doubt left. They say: if he claimed prophethood, what issue remains? Why any further interest? This is the biggest objection raised, which usually, like a stake, kills any further interest; after that, they say, there is no need to ask what the truth is. They cite the view of Hazrat Imam Abu Hanifa: whoever says, I am a prophet, do not talk with him further, he is a liar. Now reflect on this issue, to what extent it is correct. If this were the rule, why did the Holy Prophet (saw) give an opportunity to the envoy of the false prophet? If anyone can be a definite liar in a claim to prophethood, there can be no more definite liar than the false prophet who appears in the time of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and makes the claim in that time. And he says: I want to send a delegation for negotiations, and the Holy Prophet (saw) receives them. So the question is whether dialogue was closed. And the Holy Qur’an says that before you there were nations who had formed the belief that God would never again send any prophet. It gives the example of Hazrat Yusuf (as): as long as Hazrat Yusuf lived they opposed him; when he died – the word “halaka” is used – they began to say that now God would never send a prophet. Now tell me: among those holding this belief, how many prophets claimed after Hazrat Yusuf, how many claimants of prophethood appeared, in the long period from Hazrat Yusuf to the Holy Prophet (saw), and all made the claim? Were they justified in saying, but we have this belief? So reflect. And the Holy Qur’an gave this matter such importance – beware of falling into this trap – that in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) it recorded the delegation of the Jinn that came, in Surah Al-Jinn, preserving their dialogue. The Holy Qur’an says that when they returned they said among themselves: how foolish we were, how ignorant, that we used to say such things. And among these things, the Holy Qur’an says, they also used to say, before Muhammad (saw), that God would not send any prophet. Despite this belief they came, spoke with the one who claimed prophethood, understood, and said that belief was wrong. Why did the Holy Qur’an need to preserve these two things? And besides this there is a fundamental point of tremendous grandeur, after which, I believe, no problem remains in this matter. The Holy Qur’an says that in the time of Hazrat Moses (as) there was a man among Pharaoh's people who secretly believed in Moses. He was so respected – the Holy Qur’an did not disclose his name, he remained hidden; here too God kept him hidden, this too is God's covering. It is astonishing that the Holy Qur’an, which is there to explain everything, kept his name hidden, as if saying: even now we do not tell who he was. But he was such that he had access to the court and was listened to. For it says that when they were plotting to kill Moses, the leading men, Pharaoh's ministers and others together, he came to them and said: listen to me, do not interfere in these matters. He has claimed that God sent him. The meaning – I will read you the verse – is: how can we find out whether Allah spoke to him or not? God does not place an inspector in between through whom He speaks, nor is there an exchange; if there is an exchange, it is that of angels, not of humans. Then he said: see, if he is a liar, as you consider him a liar, even then it is not your task to punish him. “Fa ‘alaihi kadhibuhu” – the burden of the liar's lie falls on himself. How can the burden of lying fall on you? Whoever lies has cause to fear, not you. If he is a liar, God's decree will destroy him. “Fa ‘alaihi kadhibuhu” – what concern is it of yours? This is a fundamental truth to be remembered. If this were a wrong statement, why would the Holy Qur’an, in its account of prophets, mention a non-prophet, indeed a believer who was hiding his faith, and preserve his words forever? He said: “In yaku kadhiban fa ‘alaihi kadhibuhu” – if he is a liar, he should fear his God; if he does not, let him go to hell, as we say in Urdu; the consequence falls on him. You have no right to interfere like this. “Wa in yaku sadiqan” – but consider: if he turns out truthful, “yusibkum ba‘du alladhi ya‘idukum”, then surely some of the calamities he warns you of will befall you. What a dangerous bargain it is to issue a fatwa about a claimant saying, we say with certainty God has not spoken to him and he is a liar. How do you know Allah did not speak? Allah knows. And does Allah have no honour, no concern that a liar has come? And would He lay the responsibility of killing him on those poor people who cannot possibly know whether God spoke or not? That cannot be; it is against reason. So if Mirza Sahib made this claim, first understand the nature of his claim, and reflect within yourself whether this claim is against the glory of Muhammad Mustafa (saw) or not. That is the right way; otherwise, if you get caught up in disputes about Arabic, most of you do not understand it, do not know Arabic, and even if you do, the disputes are endless. We too give arguments from the Holy Qur’an, arguments from Arabic grammar; we too have great, leading scholars. Two such are even sitting among us, Mustafa Sahib for instance, I could call him. How then will one get anywhere? If one says most Arabs are opposed – in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) most Arabs were opposed to him too. That is no argument. So the principle is to adopt such methods as anyone, complete or incomplete in knowledge, can adopt. And in my view the greatest touchstone for distinguishing truth from falsehood is this: every belief that is against the glory of Muhammad Mustafa (saw) is to be rejected; it cannot be true. For God the Exalted has preserved the glory of the Holy Prophet (saw) until the Day of Judgement and taken responsibility for its protection. Every belief that increases the glory of Muhammad Mustafa (saw), or does not harm it, that befits it, is not to be rejected. Once this is understood, no further dispute is needed. This principle is so decisive and clear that in my view every disputed issue, be it between Shias and Sunnis, between Wahhabis and Barelvis, or between Ahmadis and non-Ahmadis, if tested on this touchstone, yields the correct answer. And second: test it on the touchstone of your own nature; see what answer your nature gives. The claim Hazrat Mirza Sahib made is this: I am a perfect servant of Muhammad Mustafa (saw); I have not come to change even a dot of the Holy Qur’an, nor to change the Sunna, nor to change the command of Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Until the Day of Judgement these are enduring values; no one can change them. I have come to call the nation back to the servitude of the Holy Prophet (saw), to restore those practices that were followed in his time, from which the Umma later moved away, to resolve those issues that were clear in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) but later fell victim to disagreement. That is the claim. If you reflect for a moment, detached from your previous background: if someone claims that God has clothed him with the mantle of prophethood as a servant of Muhammad Mustafa (saw), as his follower, what harm does the glory of Mustafa suffer from that? This is a touchstone to which I invite you. Consider one more thing: before him there were prophets to whose servants God granted the mantle of prophethood, even though no new law came. If Moses – God forbid – were to claim: on the Day of Judgement my servants will stand, and among my servants will be the greatest prophets, David will be there, Solomon will be there ... among the servants Hazrat Isa (as) and Solomon (as) and others, all of them will be there; and when Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) stands, behind him there will be no prophet as his deputy – if this were said, by what argument could we reject this claim of superiority? What wisdom is there in it? Why should God not grant prophethood to a servant of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) for a great reform? That is the point.

10 of 10 left today