3. The point is this: Hazrat Mirza Sahib’s (as) claim is that he has come as a subordinate (servant) prophet. One should understand this claim and just see whether there is anything objectionable in it, and whether there is anything that would be insulting to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). If it is said that his spiritual kingdom lasts until the Day of Judgement, his Book lasts until the Day of Judgement, his Sunnah lasts until the Day of Judgement, and no person, whether prophet or saint, can abrogate even a jot of the Holy Qur’an, the Sunnah and the true Ahadith, then what is objectionable if he is given the title of prophethood?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: The point is this: Hazrat Mirza Sahib’s (as) claim is that he has come as a subordinate (servant) prophet. One should understand this claim and just see whether there is anything objectionable in it, and whether there is anything that would be insulting to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). If it is said that his spiritual kingdom lasts until the Day of Judgement, his Book lasts until the Day of Judgement, his Sunnah lasts until the Day of Judgement, and no person, whether prophet or saint, can abrogate even a jot of the Holy Qur’an, the Sunnah and the true Ahadith, then what is objectionable if he is given the title of prophethood?

I want to say at this point that, as far as love for the Holy Prophet (saw) is concerned, this is in no way contrary to love. I understand it thus: the king whose servants are themselves kings is all the greater. That is why the Holy Prophet (saw) said about the godly scholars of his Ummah: “The scholars of my Ummah are like the prophets of the Children of Israel,” i.e. they hold a rank equal to the prophets of the Children of Israel. So the foundation is laid. His second claim is that he is the Imam Mahdi. No question of anything objectionable arises in that. But there is one matter concerning the Imam Mahdi: if you understand this issue, our disagreement about prophethood disappears as though it never existed. I want to explain it openly, if there is time. This issue is very important: what we say, what our thinking is, why we consider you Muslims despite these things, and say that we are in accordance with the Holy Qur’an. Let our case be heard. Regarding the Imam Mahdi, it is the belief of most Muslim sects that he will come. Some Ahl-e-Qur’an say he will not; they also deny the coming of the Messiah. So I leave that sect aside. All the remaining sects agree that Hazrat Imam Mahdi will come. They also agree that the Imam Mahdi will make the claim of being Imam Mahdi by God’s command, not on his own; Allah will make him Imam. There is no doubt about it: whenever Hazrat Imam Mahdi comes, Allah the Exalted Himself will appoint him Imam. And thirdly they agree that whoever denies the Imam Mahdi will in effect break his relationship with Allah the Exalted, because denying one whom God has sent as Imam is a major sin. In these three fundamental points there is not even a particle of difference between us and the other sects. The only difference is what name has been given to this reality. A person about whom we believe that God has sent him, whether by election or by raising him Himself; a person about whom we believe that denying him will be disbelief and will mean breaking the relationship with Allah – if he has not come today he will come tomorrow, and when he comes this will be his claim. Separate this claim from prophethood and show: if its name is not prophethood, then what is the difference between prophethood and this claim? That is why I have always requested the scholars – you can ask too, ask the greatest scholar, ask him honestly: leave Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as) aside, whether you accept him or not; tell us what is going to happen tomorrow. Tomorrow he will claim to be the Imam Mahdi; if not today, then when he comes. Are these foundations part of his claim or not? He will declare: “By God, Allah the Exalted has raised me Himself, as Imam of the Ummah, in the servitude of Muhammad Mustafa (saw), as Imam Mahdi of the whole world; accept the Imam Mahdi.” Will he do so or not? All scholars are compelled to admit: yes, he will make this claim. After that you can ask: do you, or do the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah, give us the right to deny him after this claim? There is not a single scholar who can permit you that. Ask him, he will say: you will become real disbelievers, you will have no connection with religion left, if you deny the Imam made by God. The third question is: what is the Islamic name of such a claimant? What name does the Holy Qur’an give such a person? As far as I know – study the Holy Qur’an and ask –: among human beings, the one in whom belief is necessary is the prophet. In no non-prophet among humans is belief necessary according to the Holy Qur’an. In the foundations of your faith: first, we believe in Allah, in the angels, in the Books – these three are not human beings; then we believe in the Hereafter – that is not a human being either; we believe in the decree of good and evil – that is not a human being either; and we believe in the prophets. These are the foundations of faith. Prove from the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah belief in a non-prophet; there is not a single exception. That is why in the whole Ummah of Muhammad, not for a single day was it made a doctrine that belief in a Mujaddid is necessary. Mujaddids came before too, with every century, but because they were not the Imam Mahdi, they were not given the title Imam Mahdi; therefore belief in them is not a condition in the creed of any sect. But belief in the Imam Mahdi is part of the basic doctrines of all sects; it is obligatory. Second: God Himself will appoint him – what is called divine commission. The one whom God Himself appoints, the Holy Qur’an calls Imam; the Holy Qur’an uses the word Imam for the prophets. You may well say that the Imam Mahdi will be from within the Ummah, but the two foundations of the creed compel you to acknowledge his status as a subordinate prophet from within the Ummah. Now tell me: does one become a sinner by giving the name, while holding the belief itself amounts to prophethood? What is this? One should act with righteousness and first examine one’s own faith. Consider: if you think Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as) is false, then tomorrow, the day after, or later, the prophecy of the Holy Prophet (saw) must be fulfilled in any case, and the Ummah will necessarily one day have to deal with the Imam Mahdi and face him. He will claim that belief in him is necessary and that God has appointed him. The scholars who have taught you this lesson will tell you again tomorrow that he is a liar because he is a prophet, and that the claim of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat makes you disbelievers – it will not leave you alone. That is why the foremost Mujaddids among the earlier saints, having been informed by God, warned in advance: when the Imam Mahdi appears, do not think people will readily follow him; in opposing the Imam Mahdi the imams and scholars will be at the forefront. Hazrat Mujaddid Alf-e-Thani, one of the foremost Mujaddids, said this in advance; God informed him on this matter, and he wrote in his Letters (Maktubat): when the Imam Mahdi appears, the body of the scholars of that time will be in opposition to him. So this factor too will be fulfilled at the same time. How will you decide then? However you decide then, decide likewise today. Today it is no different difficulty; the factors that will trouble you then trouble you today as well – all three of these factors.

10 of 10 left today