4. (Badly garbled) The questioner apparently objects that others such as Imam Khomeini also call themselves Imam or made such claims, and that by this logic one would have to accept every claimant.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Badly garbled) The questioner apparently objects that others such as Imam Khomeini also call themselves Imam or made such claims, and that by this logic one would have to accept every claimant.

I am saying this: if you believe that the Imam Mahdi will come, you cannot call anyone a liar on the ground that he has claimed to be the Imam Mahdi. Perhaps I could not fully express my meaning. I say: in principle you cannot reject a claimant to being Imam Mahdi by saying that, since the elements of prophethood are included in his claim, we therefore deny him. Because when the true Imam comes – if this one is not true – these two elements will necessarily be included in his claim. That is what I am saying. Therefore it is proper and reasonable to test every such claimant in the same way you will test his claim. This is the invitation I am giving. By this standard, your remaining point is right or wrong: if Imam Khomeini were to claim, “I am the Imam Mahdi, God has raised me, and denying me will be disbelief because God has raised me” – if he makes this claim, the claim in itself does not make him a disbeliever or a liar. What would make him a liar is that God did not say so and yet he makes the claim. That I accept. But the claim in itself is not a false claim, i.e. it is not against the foundations of Islam, because you yourself admit that, if this one is not true, such an Imam will certainly come and make exactly this claim. I am not yet saying that he is the true one, because there is a difference between your belief and mine, and unless I come onto your platform, how can I make you understand? Without developing a common factor, one cannot make anyone understand in a disagreement. That is not logic. If I said to you, “I consider him the true Imam, so accept him as Imam,” that would be a very foolish method. I am explaining to you: look, if the grounds on which you oppose him are valid, then it is certain that tomorrow, when the true Imam comes, you will have to oppose him too, because the same grounds will arise. That is what I am explaining. And as far as Imam Khomeini Sahib is concerned, he never made such a claim. What is being said there is contrary to fact; he certainly made no such claim. I am explaining this: Imam Khomeini did not make this claim. If you understand their belief: in practice all Shia imams call themselves the deputy (Na’ib) of the Imam. Their belief is that the infallible Imam has come and is alive; they do not see him today, they say he will return, and in the presence of an Imam whom God has already appointed, there cannot be another Imam. So they say ‘Imam’, but they mean that he is acting as his deputy, his stand-in. And to this day he has never claimed that God appointed him; you cannot show a single sentence. As for Baha’u’llah: Baha’u’llah and the Bab are two different persons. The Bab made a claim and said that God had appointed him to prepare the way for the coming Messiah – the one whose coming is foretold; that is why he called himself Bab (gate): passing through him, the coming one would appear. And because he had made a clear claim of revelation, he was killed within a fixed period, and God dealt with him as He deals with liars. [Hindi passage garbled: it is said that someone claimed to be the Mahdi, that Baha’u’llah claimed to be God and wrote books from prison.] I want to explain: if in my statement even a jot, even a single point has remained in which there is a misunderstanding, you have the right to ask. Indeed, by asking you do a favour; it may be that someone else’s misunderstanding, like yours, is removed as well. Baha’ullah Sahib wrote from prison – it exists in his books and letters –: Behold, …

10 of 10 left today