5. (During the call to prayer, implied) Must one remain silent during the Adhan?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (During the call to prayer, implied) Must one remain silent during the Adhan?
There is no such instruction about the Adhan that one must fall silent at it; it is not a command. That relates to recitation: the Holy Qur’an says that when it is recited, listen to it and be silent. For the Adhan there is no such thing. That is why it is permitted among us; in our gatherings the conversation sometimes continues. One should fall silent when idle talk is going on. In religion one should go only as far as God has commanded; if we do more, we impose constraints on ourselves. When one is sitting alone, no religious conversation is taking place, or idle talk is going on, then it is better [to be silent]. But if a religious discussion is going on, then [one may continue].