6. (Continuation) How does the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat differ from the Baha’is, and how is their claim to be refuted that the Shariah of the Holy Qur’an has been superseded by new requirements?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1986
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Continuation) How does the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat differ from the Baha’is, and how is their claim to be refuted that the Shariah of the Holy Qur’an has been superseded by new requirements?
Now I read to you: Baha’ullah Sahib wrote: I, who am God, am in prison for your sake and am bearing the hardships of prison; see what a great favour of mine this is. And not just once, he made this claim repeatedly. In the whole Holy Qur’an or in the Ahadith there is no indication that God the Exalted seizes in this world one who claims divinity; He seizes one who claims prophethood. What is the reason? The claim to divinity is so obviously false that no one can be deceived, except people who are already corrupt. With the claim to prophethood it is difficult, because there he says that God spoke to him; you have no means of determining whether He spoke or not. The One who did it knows. If He does not seize him, how would you know? You would take hold [accept him] though he lied, and if you accepted, you would remain in doubt whether he claimed God spoke though God said nothing. Therefore, when someone claims divinity, Allah the Exalted leaves him alone; all these ‘gods’ die their own death. And in all the well-known religions whose founders are said to have claimed divinity, they did not actually do so; those who really did have no weight left, they passed away by themselves. [Garbled:] … their case is different because their claim was one of prophethood, and God did not seize them [?]. Anyway, that is a separate subject. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is the true Islam; with Baha’ism we have not even the remotest connection. On the contrary, we have disputes with Baha’ism; we hold great debates with them. For they say: a new Shariah, or in the sense that most of the Shariah of the Holy Qur’an is no longer binding, because the times have changed; therefore there are new, modern requirements. In accordance with these new requirements Baha’ullah says: I am now changing the Shariah, because these are new times and I am bringing it according to the requirements. He reduced the prayers, abolished some, changed the names of the months and their timings, removed some obligations; instead of permission for four marriages he made it two; he lifted the veil (Purdah), and much else. Baha’ullah has disfigured the whole appearance of the Islamic Shariah and claimed that modern requirements demand it. By Allah’s grace the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is putting up the defence against the Baha’is too, on behalf of the entire Muslim Ummah; therefore we have to engage with them as well. I give you an example: there where they are widespread and carry on their propaganda, they say they have spread greatly; we see no blessing in it, because the total [number] of Baha’is there is no more than 25 or 30. [Garbled.] A conversation took place with a Baha’i gentleman, together with a missionary in Burma; I tell you so that when Baha’is come to you, you talk with them this way. They say the Islamic Shariah was better because the Shariah of Moses and the Shariah of Jesus had fallen behind, and before that the one of Abraham; they could not meet the requirements of the time. Man is progressing: where did man stand 1400 years ago, and where has today’s man reached through progress? So how ignorant is the belief that the Shariah stands still and God does not change it and does not consider the new requirements. Therefore, on the very basis on which the Holy Qur’an abrogated the earlier Shariahs, the abrogation of the Shariah of the Holy Qur’an is a rational, a necessary demand. This is the argument they give, and many poor, simple Muslims, because they do not know the philosophy of religion, fall into difficulty. I heard him out, and I explain the method to you too. I said: in the argument you have given you made an error; I will expose it, then we talk further. The Holy Qur’an does not merely claim that it is better compared with the earlier religions and therefore has the right; the Holy Qur’an claims [to be perfect]. [Gap 65:28-65:58.] … I give an example and put a teaching before you; change it and show me. The teaching of Hazrat Moses (as) was: nose for nose, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, and exactly equal retaliation. This teaching was … and he did not permit forgiveness. The teaching of Hazrat Moses was a relative (comparative) perfection, not absolute perfection. I want to tell you that Islam had absolute perfection, not relative. When you understand this, you can overcome the Baha’is at any cost; they find no escape. If we call the teaching of Hazrat Moses and Hazrat Jesus (as) imperfect or deficient, the objection arises that God gives deficient teaching; God is perfect, how can He give deficient teaching? If His teaching was deficient, then His divinity would be finished, then one would have given up religion. Therefore we should say: that teaching was perfect in relation to its time, not absolutely. Because at the time of Hazrat Moses, the people to whom he came were oppressed, downtrodden, subjugated, and made so abject that they would not even take their right. When the ruling people slapped them, they would say: we forgive you from the heart. What kind of forgiveness is that? The poor fellow cannot take revenge anyway! Their morals were so corrupted that they declared every weakness to be high morality. Had they been given permission to forgive at that time, they would have kept on ‘forgiving’; that would have ruined them. To build up their character, to set them on their own feet again, Allah the Exalted said: for this time, until We see fit, you are not permitted to forgive. If a tooth is knocked out, a tooth must be knocked out; if a nose is cut off, a nose must be cut off. A perfect teaching with regard to its time, but not with regard to all times. So after a long time the reaction came and they became hard-hearted. The Holy Qur’an says: after some time their hearts became like stone, hard like rocks. They became so cruel that they treated Hazrat Jesus (as), an innocent, loving person whose teaching was full of gentleness, cruelly. Then God gave a teaching going the other way: Hazrat Jesus said: whoever strikes you on one cheek, turn to him the other as well; whoever takes your cloak, give him your shirt too. A magnificent teaching! But had the Jews at the time of Hazrat Moses (as) been given this teaching, they would have [been ruined further]; and to those already hardened he said: for one slap, offer the other cheek. Therefore in that time, in that context, it was a perfect teaching, but not absolutely. I said to the Baha’i gentleman: now I come to Islam. Six hundred years, about six hundred and ten years later, Islam appears. God teaches the Holy Prophet (saw): if someone does wrong, a person has the right to retaliate in equal measure, but only as much as the wrong done, not an inch more, otherwise he himself becomes a wrongdoer. That is the first teaching. Second: to forgive, but on condition that forgiveness leads to reform and does not encourage crime. Not absolute forgiveness. He says: ‘fa-man ‘afa wa aslaha’ – these are the words: whoever forgives, provided reform results from it, God loves him [his reward is with God]. I said: now change this teaching today. 1400 years have passed; change a single jot of it and show that it fell behind in some age and that the perfect teaching is now this. For earlier [times] it was absolutely perfect [suitable]. This is the real point: perfection is when no better teaching is possible – neither forgiveness left unrestricted nor retaliation left unrestricted. Man has reached the age of reason; he should decide whether he forgives. If forgiveness encourages crime, God does not permit me even to forgive; if forgiveness leads to reform, someone’s heart changes and he becomes pure, then God demands of me that I give up my right. In short: this is the perfect perfection, and the belief of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is that the religion [of Islam] has become perfect in such a way that it [applies] for every age.