2. How would one respond to allegation that the Holy Qur’an is a copy of other religious books?
Question-and-answer session, 2 May 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: How would one respond to allegation that the Holy Qur’an is a copy of other religious books?
In some books, some people accuse the Holy Qur’an to be a copy or copied from Bible or Old Testament. Could Huzoor tell us...
No, tell me which particular objection you have in mind or allegation you have in mind. So, I mean, this is a general question; it can't be answered.
This is too large a question. I mean, it concerns so many verses, so many accounts of the Holy Qur’an, so it's a general allegation which we refute when the allegation is raised in particular, then we can refute it.
Yes, I was reading a book about which is written by an English author, and he was very fair in it that he was comparing the messages in the Holy Qur’an and knowledge about different things in this world and the Bible, and he mentioned that the allegation that Qur’an has been copied from different places from Bible does not stand very sound in view of quite a number of things he pointed out that were never mentioned in the Bible or were very vague but were made clear.
I agree, but the point is, how can you expect an answer to this question which requires references, which requires scholarly treatment in depth? First of all, all the allegations have to be collected and raised one after the other, not in just general terms.
Huzoor, I was asking, is there any book which deals with…
You are telling me the existence of that book.
Well, that was by chance that man mentioned, but he said, by the way he mentioned.
In literature, various references are found in different books in answer to some particular allegations.
Yes, but is there any book which...
No, I don't know of any one single book which deals with this subject as such. I don't know of any such book.
I see. Okay. Jazakallah.
You know, Hazrat Khalifatul Masih Awwal (ra) wrote a book in defense of Islam against the Christian allegations. What's the name? Faslu... Nuruddin? Fasl... No, but the full name is Nuruddin something. Does anybody remember the name? The other day I told Hadi Ali to write home to send my book, that particular book which was there in my room somewhere, to send me over to here. That's a very good book. Once somebody sent a book to Hazrat Khalifatul Masih Awwal under the title Yanabiul Islam, in which the same subject was discussed and a lot of allegations were hurled against Islam, and the author tried to trace each account of the Holy Qur’an back to some biblical version.
So the name was Yanabiul Islam, the original sources of Islam. And Hazrat Khalifatul Masih Awwal (ra) just wrote one short verse of the Holy Qur’an on the title of this book and finished with the subject. And that was Fīhā kutubun qayyimah. In the Holy Qur’an are those books which have... now let me translate kutubun qayyimah: those books which have lasting values, which have been revealed earlier. They are called kutubun qayyimah. Qayyimah means something which stays, which has the staying power, which has the lasting value. So the Holy Qur’an itself claims that in this book you will find all the previous books which have staying power in the world, which have any lasting value for the mankind. So that was the answer.
It is no discovery on the part of somebody that the Holy Qur’an speaks of earlier teachings or borrows from earlier teachings. The Holy Qur’an claims that it borrows from the earlier teachings only in a defined way, in a qualified manner. And that qualified manner is that all the hocus-pocus is rejected, but the truths are taken up only, and the Holy Qur’an is selective in that choice.
So if you understand that principle, then it becomes so easy to rebut all such attacks on Islam, because the principle is simply this: Fīhā kutubun qayyimah. All that the Holy Qur’an has taken is that which is true, which has a lasting value, which has no, you know, nonsense about it, which is not false; and all that is false and hollow, etc., or man-made, that has been rejected by the Holy Qur’an.
And many a version of the Bible is amended by the Holy Qur’an. It is not taken in toto. Amended to a degree that it completely transforms the quality of that biblical statement. From just a banal, ordinary statement, it rises to a high level, very high level.
So that is what I mean. This is how you should treat such allegations: not in general answers, but take up each allegation one after the other, compare it with the corresponding statement of the Holy Qur’an, and then when you make a comparison, you will begin to understand what I mean. It is not taken in toto at all, anywhere. All the statements of the Holy Qur’an which are a repeat of Bible are not an exact repeat. They omit certain things, they add certain things, and they present it as a whole truth.