3. In Zafrulla Khan's translation of the Holy Qur’an, what is meant by the phrase "She [Maryam] accompanied him [Jesus] to her people, while he was riding…" (19:28)?

Question-and-answer session, 2 May 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: In Zafrulla Khan's translation of the Holy Qur’an, what is meant by the phrase "She [Maryam] accompanied him [Jesus] to her people, while he was riding…" (19:28)?

I'd like to refer to the chapter of Maryam in the Holy Qur’an, and two things I have questions about. One is that—I think better read it out so it will be the exact thing. The translation of that is: she, that is Maryam, accompanied him to her people while he was riding.

While he was riding? Yeah, that's the translation.

That must be wrong. It says, "Fa-atat bihi qawmaha tahmiluhu." "While he was riding" is the wrong translation.

Carrying him in his in her lap—that's what I thought too, but the translation does say so.

Or both of them were traveling in a carriage, that can also be translated. But not riding.

Yes, but in this Chaudhry Zafrulla Khan's translation, which I have a photostat here with me, it says "while he was riding."

It is not right, it is not correct. It is an incorrect translation, unfortunately.

What does it actually mean, tahmiluhu?

Tahmiluhu, carrying him along. It may mean both: number one, in her body, in her lap, like children are carried; or if he is older of age, then if some lady is taking her son along in a carriage, even then the expression tahmiluha can be applicable, tahmiluhu can be applicable. So that sort of picture is created. But in no way can it be translated as riding along or something, no, no.

Would we have a correction in the Holy Qur’an in the next edition maybe? Either translation...

No, but the author is no longer alive, the author of this translation, I mean.

The next point is after that... this verse... it says Jesus...

I would you had pointed out earlier, then it would be... Because we never had these interesting discourses in the evening, so I... No, these things in the rendering of the Holy Qur’an always, you know, small things escape notice.

Actually, when Chaudhry Sahib had prepared his translation, he requested Hazrat Khalifatul Masih As-Salis (rh) to appoint a board of Ahmadi scholars to go through all the translation along with him, so that if there are some mistakes committed, some, you know, omissions here and there, they could be attended to from the Ahmadiyya scholarly point of view. That was his intention.

So, Hazrat Sahib appointed a daddy, I mean, a body of people who would help him, and among them, I was also one. So, it was composed of Sheikh Bashir Ahmad Sahib, late Sheikh Bashir Ahmad Sahib, late Malik Ghulam Farid Sahib, and one or two others, and I was also one of them. So he invited us to stay in Lahore for a month or so, and we were his guests—not that we were staying with him, but we went in the morning and returned at night, and all day long we were at it, and we ate at his table, and so on. It was a very interesting month we spent together, and we tried to improve upon things here and there, but mostly we found the rendering excellent.

Yes, of course, but still, because Chaudhry Sahib was not a scholar in Arabic, or he was not taught in depth the Islamic teachings as some others were, like Sheikh Bashir Ahmad Sahib, he was not also a scholar in Arabic, but he was deeply associated right from his childhood.

Malik Sahib, of course, was entirely associated with the Holy Qur’an. I think Malik Ghulam Farid Sahib was also one of them, and or if I remember rightly, maybe Muhammad Ahmad Sadid? So anyway, we—it was a very useful session altogether—not session, but I mean a useful exercise altogether—and I, I'm surprised how this missed our attention.

Actually, there are quite a few such things, maybe. Later on, you know, in fact, what happened was that we were not able, all of us, to attend all the sessions. So there are certain omissions here and there which might have been caught by others, but who were... they were not present at that time.

10 of 10 left today