12. Is it acceptable for a government to compel women to work in the country's armed forces?
Question-and-answer session, 2 May 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Is it acceptable for a government to compel women to work in the country's armed forces?
Is this right, the women and the girls, to work in the army with men by force? By force? By force of government? I mean, if it's legally made incumbent upon every boy and girl to work together in the army, is that right? This is what you mean?
Yes, by force, from government.
I know. Yes. But it all depends on what sort of work is taken and what precautions are also taken to safeguard the chastity of the ladies, if it is done. And also, we don't know the nature of the jobs. Under certain national compulsions it is possible, but with certain modifications and qualifications, of course, not generally.
But, Huzoor, there is no purdah in the army.
No, you have not heard me, or I have not been able to explain what I mean. Was there purdah in Jang-e-Uhud and Jang-e-Ahzab and some other battles of Islam? Was there purdah observed—Khandaq ho ya...—by Muslim ladies? Tell me.
Yes, Muslim ladies. I am speaking about a Muslim constitution.
I am also speaking of Muslim ladies of earlier times now. I am referring to certain battles in which Ahn-Hazrat (saw) participated himself. Also, his holy wives participated. And there was no purdah observed—the sort of purdah which you have in mind, I mean. Otherwise, the spirit was observed.
So, it all depends on the situation. If there is a compelling situation, which is a national question of do or die, then this part of the teachings of Islam can be looked upon with some accommodation and with some laxity, of course.
*Su'ar* is haram, for instance, totally. Pig is haram, isn't it? Yet you are permitted to eat under certain conditions for saving life. So, when the national life is at stake, purdah is just a small consideration as compared to that. And in the earlier times as well, Islam has looked at this with the same attitude. Why should not again the same attitude be adopted?
But still, I don't condone every action of every government, whoever compels ladies to do certain things. I'm not condoning that. What I am telling you is that, for different occasions, each order of a government would be considered on merit. Some may be right according to Islamic teachings, some may be wrong according to Islamic teachings. But you can't treat them all with one yardstick.
From situation to situation, the answer may be different. From order to order, the nature of the order as it is, the answer may be different. So, in principle, I have told you that under certain compelling, demanding situations, it is possible to waive off the strictness of purdah as we observe in normal, ordinary life. Thank you.