6. Is it permissible to read the Eid prayer more than one time in the mosque due to lack of space or some special circumstances?

Question-and-answer session, 13 June 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it permissible to read the Eid prayer more than one time in the mosque due to lack of space or some special circumstances?

Very often the Eid prayer is said more than once due to lack of space in the place of prayer or for some other reasons. As I think, in both cases the matter is of exceptions and not of a regular basis that prayers could be said more than once. Huzoor's guidance is humbly requested in both these cases. I had written that.

You had written that, but I have already answered this, haven't I?

One Huzoor has answered.

Your question followed my answer. It didn't precede it.

No, what I asked the permission to read the what I had written as a question, but now one part was answered already. Now the second part regarding Eid prayer is still...

Eid prayer, this is wrong. No two Eids can be said. Eid prayer is not like the five daily compulsory prayers. It is a completely different institution, and it can be said only once. And if you miss it, you don't have to say it on your own. I mean, this is not something compulsory to the extent that when you miss the Eid, you should stay still say your own Eid individually. There is no such thing. So, when you missed, you have missed, finished.

No, Huzoor, I got with me a cutting from the Daily Jang where it says that in the same place it was said several times...

No, but we are not concerned. I'm not answerable to the behavior of of everybody else. I'm telling you the the correct way of doing things according to Islam, according to the teachings of the Holy Qur’an and the traditions of the holy founder of Islam, (saw). So you want me to defend the case of such people as have deviated from the path of tradition and instructions of the Holy Qur’an? Why should I? Ask them! So the first part I have answered; the second part, I should ask those people about whom you read in the newspaper, right?

Yes Huzoor.

Because, but you...

I I personally thought, now I am I'm clear with Huzoor's Huzoor's guidance, that I thought that in when there is a little space in a place, they can...

No, there is no question of space, shortage of space, because Eid prayers are said outside the mosques, in the in the open.

Yes.

Because it is understood that ordinary mosques which are built for specific needs of a small area could not be sufficient to meet the requirements of a much larger area where normally so many mosques are situated. So, obviously, no Eid could be said in in a mosque because Eid covers a much larger area of people, and so it is said in the open spaces where there is no shortage of of room.

10 of 10 left today