7. What are the guidelines to follow if one is fasting and wishes to travel?

Question-and-answer session, 13 June 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What are the guidelines to follow if one is fasting and wishes to travel?

During Ramadan, uh this could be a—I see the time is short. Uh when one is fasting, uh one wants to travel, but he wants to keep the fast if possible. What criteria, in terms of distance, breaks the fast?

You know, this issue of keeping fast during a journey has been decided by Hazrat Masih Maud (as), and he has also spoken on the subject in general, other parts we have raised, I mean, have also been covered. The general picture as created by various of his sayings and verdicts, I should say, is this: that Islam does not promote keeping of fasts during journeys, because the words used by the Holy Qur’an indicate that Allah has permitted you not to keep fast during a journey.

So when, according to Hazrat Masih Maud (as), when you permit someone out of love and consideration for him, if he does not make use of that permission, it is, you know, disrespectful in a way. If you permit your child to enjoy something and he say, "No, no, no, I'm going to study, I don't want that permission to be employed, to be used," you will not be as happy as when he thanks you so much and, you know, with a with a good grace he accepts your permission and enjoys whatever is in store for him. That you like much better.

So, in the light of this psychological situation, Hazrat Masih Maud (as) inferred that Allah could have could have made it obligatory, could have expressed it in words which might have meant that if you cannot keep fast during a journey because of the hardship, you are permitted, but still we want, we prefer you to keep fasts. Instead of going into that, what holy the Holy Qur’an tells us is this: that while you are on a journey you should not keep fast; you should defer the matter till such other times as you have come back to your place and settled down.

So, this is not promoted. And in Ahmadiyya attitude, despite the fact that we can keep fast physically, and we desire to keep fast, in respect of this special injunction in the Holy Qur’an, we do not keep fast during journeys.

But what is a journey? Now I come to the second point. A journey for Namaz has a different definition, and a journey for fasting has a different definition.

For the Namaz, in one day, five, one in 24 hours, five prayers are covered. And between sunset and sunrise, three, and between sunrise and sunset, two other prayers are covered. So if you exceed in traveling the time of one prayer and run into another, at least one prayer can be conceived as between the journey, engulfed by your journey. But in the fasting this cannot happen. You can go a long way between the two extremes, two ends of the fast, that is between sunrise and sunset, and still your journey will be a part of the fasting, not that the part that fasting would become a part of your journey. You understand the point?

So, in view of this and in view of many traditions speaking on this issue—I would not refer to all these because then the subject would become rather lengthy. In a nutshell, I give, create the picture as we see things in Ahmadiyyat: for the ordinary journey where prayers are permitted to be shortened, the criterion used by Ahmadis is that if you leave on a journey your own place, even if you have traveled just one mile outside the boundaries of the city, you can start halving your prayers, reducing the prayers according to the custom and tradition. And when you are approaching your own town, even if it is a furlong from your town, if you have not not yet entered the town, you can still apply the rules of the journey to your prayers.

How long the journey should be? According to the older system, the journeys would were measured differently by various Muslim scholars who have paid attention to this subject. According to some schools of jurisprudence, a journey means if you travel, according to the old mode of travel, nine miles from your town, that begins to be a journey. Some others said, no, 12 miles is the minimum. Some said 17 or even 21 or 22. Why this difference? If Islam is one and the injunctions are clear, why should the scholars differ with each other in the length of journey from the point of view of jurisprudence? The simple fact is that the mode of travel differed. In some cases, a person on foot normally traveled nine miles and would prefer to stop after the nine miles.

That is, in view of the weak people. The strong people could go much further. But some people would would consider it enough for a day to travel nine miles from a town, and that would call they would call it a day. So those who spoke of nine miles, they had those foot travelers in mind, pedestrians. And some traveled on horseback. They would go maybe as far as 17 miles or 20 miles and would like to stop there and enjoy the rest of the day, pitching the tent or seeing places. And why just to stop after 20 miles or 17 miles on a horseback was also determined by the availability of water and the normal customary provisions for travelers. They were situated in some places 20 miles apart, and some places 17 miles apart, and some places 12 miles apart.

So if you are riding a horse or a camelback, then the determination will not be made as how you travel, but the final determination would be made of how far you can travel, provided that you have provisions for your stoppage and night rest and things—water and fodder for the for your, you know, mount and so on.

So each scholar had his own personal experience or the experience of that people of a certain vicinity in mind. If the posts, as they are called—the the places where provisions for staying the night and other requirements of passenger of of passengers are made—if they are situated in some area nine miles apart, the scholars who were discussing that subject would say nine miles is that the the distance of journey. If they were 20 miles apart, they would say 20 miles is the distance of journey.

According to our observation in India, in the during the Mughal Empire days, to the best of my knowledge, they were never farther apart than 20 miles. The periods between the two places of rest, or watering places as they as they are called in English, was generally either 20 miles or less than 20 miles—17, 16 miles. So the difference is according to the variation of their personal experiences.

Now, that shows that fundamentally, when we interpret the Holy Qur’an, we must interpret the Holy Qur’an according to the situations prevailing, not according to the situations which prevailed once in history.

We must interpret these verses in in view of what situation is prevailing, not only in that time generally, but in your place where you are living. So the journey here becomes a very open question now in the modern times. It is it becomes very difficult to define a journey in view of the fast mode of travel: trains, cars, aeroplanes, and so on and so forth.

So, how can, I'll come to, how can one define these journeys and how one one can solve this issue was made easy by us, for us, by the general practice of Hazrat Masih Maud (as) and his caliphs after him, and particularly by the second caliph, Hazrat Musleh Maud (ra), who, discussing this subject, gave us a general piece of advice. He said, it is difficult for me to measure the in mileage the journey after which you should consider that you can use the permissions for reduced number of rak'ats in prayers and so on, but I advise you to judge the matter yourself. When a man is on a journey, he knows that he is on a journey; and one he is making a short trip and returning—you know, a short pleasure trip and returning then after a few hours or during the daytime sometime—he knows that it is just a pleasure trip, it is not a journey.

So he gave us this golden line to follow: that if you know that you are on a journey—I am going to Lahore from Rabwah or even to to Batala from Qadian and so on—distance is not what is important. What is important is my personal attitude and my mental experience. If I am I have prepared myself for a journey, then even after I have left the boundaries of my town by a few yards, I am permitted to say the prayers in reduced rak'ats and skip the fasts because I am on a journey. But if I am on a pleasure trip, and that pleasure trip is up to Islamabad, which is 40 miles from here, it would not be called a journey, and I know that better than anybody else.

So except for this definition and this mode of approach, I don't conceive any other definition or mode of approach which would solve problems rather than create more problems for us.

The about the fasting, I'll add further information, further observations.

The practice among Ahmadis is this: that because generally the period of stay for a guest is considered to be three days, according to Islamic traditions, so for the fasting, this period becomes the guideline for us. If we are staying in some one place more than three days, we begin to fast. And we consider the journey part over and the settlement part beginning. If it is a longish period, of course, you would you are permitted to keep fasts. But if you are visiting a place and mean to stay there for a shorter period than three days, then you do not keep fast, because you are on a journey.

This is not a a rule which is binding on you; this is an inference, so it doesn't become binding on anybody. But what does become binding is this: that while you are actually traveling during a journey, then you should not keep fast. So the rest is left to you.

What we have observed during Qadian days—because he referred also to Qadian days, because in those days majority of the people living there belonged to the companions of Hazrat Masih Maud (as), who had been taught Islam by Hazrat Masih Maud (as) directly, and then later on had the benefit of the company of his earlier generations and companions and and caliphs and so on. So those are the times who are like uswa to us for the modern times. So during those times we observed this generally practiced: that if somebody stayed more than three days, he would start keeping fast and he would not consider himself on a journey.

But as far as the prayer timing is concerned, this is established according to the old jurisprudence school based on many traditions that three days are not the period to determine your journey; they are either 15 days or in some cases even more than 15 days. If you are staying in one place during your journey—you are breaking your journey and stay there for 14 days, for instance—you will say your prayers according to the reduced number of rak'at permissible to you. And all that period of 14 days would be considered a part of the journey. If you extend your that period of stay, after, say, 13 days, suddenly you decide to stay there,

you know, it when it's not a plan of the previous part, a part of the previous plan, you decide suddenly that, all right, I extend my journey to ten more days, still you would be on journey, and the same rules of journey prayers would apply to your prayers. If you, before the end of 10 days, for instance, you decide to extend it further to 13 days more, still you would be on journey. The uncertainty part here is the integral part of a journey's atmosphere. So as long as you are not certain, that is to say in your plans, in your attitude, to stay in one place for more than 14 days, you continue to remain unsettled in mind, and that uncertainty of approach or situation would permit you to say your prayers as if you are on a journey.

It is known that Hazrat Masih Maud (as), while appearing in Gurdaspur, stayed there for many months continuously, not knowing when that period of journey would end, continued to apply the rules of journey prayers to his prayers. Now when he did it, you must bear in mind that he was not one of those who would avoid prayers, who would seek excuses to shorten the prayer. He was one who would spend most of his time while on journey still in prayers. Still this was his attitude of deep respect to Allah and His Prophet, that if they permitted you, you would you must be respectful that permission and use it with gratitude, not pose as if you can do better, and so you you have you don't regard these permissions, you don't need these permissions.

So this is all that I had to say to you regarding this issue. If any part of your query is left untouched, you better come and now... Now is it complete? Yeah. Okay, alhamdulillah. You know, I knew you wanted to find out less than I have told you, but I wanted to give you more than you you inquired, because such opportunities come seldom your way, so I intentionally prolonged the answer beyond the region to your inquiry, region of your inquiry.

10 of 10 left today