8. What is the reasoning behind sometimes combining prayer to accommodate events or gatherings?

Question-and-answer session, 14 June 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What is the reasoning behind sometimes combining prayer to accommodate events or gatherings?

Now, like yesterday, already we have reached a time when we will have to say the prayers together. Instead of saying Maghrib separately and Isha separately, we are advancing now towards a time where we will have to say the two prayers together. Now, because of this special summer day-night relationship, I think it would not be inadvisable if we fixed a certain period during which we will always say, during Majlis-e-Irfan only, Maghrib and Isha together.

For that, there are other considerations as well. You know, after we have finished this session here, people have to return to long distances to their homes. Sometimes they come from East London and sometimes from, you know, farther-off places. So they would reach home by the time—if immediately after Majlis-e-Irfan they leave, and if they don't eat here, then they may reach home by 12 o'clock or so. If they wait for the Isha prayer to be said here, then they would reach home even later and it become—it would become very inconvenient. Mostly they leave before Isha prayer. So, they miss the Isha prayer in congregation, number one thing, and when they reach home, they are not in a fit mood to concentrate on prayer as a fresh man—a man with fresh energy would be able to do.

So, keeping these disadvantages of this special time, that is, special period of summer, I don't think it would be wrong to say Isha and Maghrib prayers together for a while. When the times change and the relationship be—the ratio of day and night becomes more respectable, then we'll revert to the old normal ways.

Is that, you think, the general consensus of opinion here? Any disagreement on this?

No, no, you don't have to find excuses there. I mean, that was Hazrat Masih Maud (as)'s time and he has mentioned it very categorically that this is particularly applying to Aan-Hazrat Masih Maud (as). But this is a genuine reason. I mean, there is—why to find excuses? This is a genuine reason. And for any session which is held for the sake of discussing religion, this is valid reason, because Aan-Hazrat (saw) has known to say—to have said two prayers together for no other reason but for the reason that he was sitting there discussing important things of Islam and religion.

So he merged the two prayers together. So it is not at all against the fundamental teaching of the Holy Qur’an or the traditions of Aan-Hazrat (saw). The convenience and the actual advantages of the people are to be seen.

When I came here for the last two years, I generally preferred to say the prayers separately in their time and insisted on it, to leave this message to you that you have adopted an easy-going habit vis-à-vis Namaz and you should change this attitude.

When I came here, I noticed that people would generally, normally say Jam‘, would do Jam‘, would do Zuhr, say Zuhr as Jam‘ with prayer. They would say Zuhr and prayer toge—Asr, Asr, I'm sorry, Zuhr and Asr together—and they would say, we have made it Jam‘. And as a routine, they would say Maghrib together with Isha, and call it Jam‘, and consider it to be just a legal practice, normal, routine practice of Islam, that was wrong.

So even when I thought I was permitted to do that, I would forgo that permission for the sake of educating you, for the sake of telling you that you prefer saying Namaz at its proper time, and do not fall prey to your ego, your inner self creating excuses for yourself.

Having done that, at times I feel that I have carried it too far where genuine requirements and necessities demanding Jam‘ prayer have also been neglected now. And this is one of the situations where you are sitting late discussing religion and things of God, and where people would have to go to extra trouble to say their Isha prayer after returning home, and they can't say it in congregation anyway. So that disadvantage is greater than saying the Isha prayer to—Isha prayer together with Maghrib in congregation.

So I have explained all this background. So for a while, until my next decision, considering the time relationship, as I said, between day and night, we'll say, during, only during these sessions, Maghrib together with Isha.

10 of 10 left today