10. What do you say to those who reject a religion because it is an Asian or Eastern religion?

Question-and-answer session, 20 June 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What do you say to those who reject a religion because it is an Asian or Eastern religion?

My question is on the observation and dealing on the tabligh side to the English community. With great respect to the English people who are already Ahmadi, you see, we feel... it's great respect to the people who have already accepted Ahmadiyyat, as you know. My feelings and what I've come across is that the people do understand and they accept the Ahmadiyyat and the Masih Maud (as) message. But how can we actually make them to accept the Asian religion? They always say, "No, this is a good religion, but this is an Asian religion." What is our answer to that?

Christianity is an Asian religion. How could they accept that? What is Christianity?

Yeah, but they have merged into the European, Huzoor, that's what they say. Is it possible for Islam that they will come to some terms?

As far as the religion is concerned, Christianity is an Oriental religion. That's true. That's true, isn't it?

That is true, sir.

Yes. So what you perhaps you what you what you are confused about is the fact, or they, the questioner maybe, the people whom you met, what they are confused about is this: that they are they are pitching their culture against religion. That is right. This is wrong. This polarization is is is wrong and not proper. Cultures should be pitched against cultures. They should be compared with cultures, and religion against religion.

So, if they want to become Muslims, they should become Muslims comparing Islam with Christianity. That's they, Huzoor, they accept it. All right.

So there is no there is no direction in religion. There is no East and Western religion, particularly in Islam. It is universal. So to declare Islam to be an Eastern religion is much more wrong than to declare Christianity as an Eastern religion, because in Christianity there is no mention, no positive declaration, I mean, that Christianity does not belong to any direction. But in the Holy Qur’an this declaration has been positively made. It has been categorically declared to the rest of the world, to the whole world, that the nur of Islam, the light of Islam, neither belongs to the East nor to the West: *Lā sharqiyyatan wa-lā gharbiyyah*.

*Ummatan wasaṭan*. Again, the people of Islam are described as *ummatan wasaṭan*, those who are situated in the middle. So a religion which claims to be neither belonging to the East nor to the West, and which takes pride in being middle-roader, you know, most well-poised between extremes, how can that be rejected on the plea that it is Eastern?

There is nothing Eastern about Islam. Islam claims to be a universal religion, and no religion can afford to take sides with East or West or North or South if it claims to be a universal religion.

So ask them, ask those friends to pinpoint those features of Islam which they think are Eastern, and then you can defend the cause of Islam.

This is, Huzoor, what they say, you see. Whatever they've been taught, you see, preached by most of the mullahs who go to their houses or to they go in their shalwar, they grow in the Eastern religion and they force them. They say, what I have given them, Huzoor, a copy of the Masih Maud (as)'s teaching of Islam, you see, Philosophy of Islam, and they appreciate that book very much.

They say, this is really a balanced type of the point of view, which we don't know who has sent it, but as we have told them, he was a quite illiterate person actually, he never knew English, he never knew others.

This is the young stalwart I was referring to.

Isko uthaayeiñ na zara, phir aapko pata chalega. Haan jee. Masha'Allah. And they they do accept that point of view which Promised Messiah (as) actually explained, and this is beautiful. But how can we go to these Muslims when these people are what they are preaching How they do what? How can they accept the Islam when they are preaching something else and practicing something else? That is the Who? These Other Muslims? Other Muslims, sir. So ask this question to other Muslims, not to me! Now, that's Put this question to those... You know, you are changing your position. No, Huzoor, he did ask me. I've asked During the course of this question, you have changed your stance from one to the other, That is the correct way. Now it appears to me that you already know the answer to your own question. Sure. I do, thank you very much, sir. What you wanted to convey to me was simply this, that the practice of some other orthodox Muslims is hindering our preaching efforts. That is all what you wanted to say. That's what Why didn't you do it straightforwardly?

10 of 10 left today