1. Did Muhammad (saw) compose the Holy Qur’an himself after meeting with Christians and reading their scriptures?

Question-and-answer session, 22 June 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Did Muhammad (saw) compose the Holy Qur’an himself after meeting with Christians and reading their scriptures?

Most of the Western authors who have written books about Islam have raised the objection that the accounts of earlier Prophets given in the Holy Qur’an were, God forbid, taken by the Holy Prophet (saw) from the Bible. They write that although the Holy Prophet (saw) did not know how to read or write, he used to exchange views with Christian monks, and from this he learnt the biblical version of the accounts of all the Prophets. Since the students here read these books, they raise questions of this kind: was the Holy Prophet (saw) acquainted with the accounts of the earlier Prophets before the revelation of the Holy Qur’an or not?

This question has two or three aspects. Please sit down, please be seated.
The first is the claim that the Holy Prophet (saw) used to meet Christian scholars. This is entirely false, and it is self-evidently disproved by other objections the Christian orientalists themselves have raised. For they say, and this is another objection, that in the Meccan period he did not address Christianity, because he was not acquainted with Christianity, nor did he speak to the Jews, because he was not acquainted with the Jews either; he only kept speaking to the idolaters. And when he went to Medina, where both peoples of the Book were present, he then addressed the People of the Book and began speaking about their matters. So where did the accounts of the Prophets in the Meccan Surahs come from? Where had he learnt them? And if he was already acquainted with them there, why did he not begin speaking about them there? So these two objections of theirs contradict each other.
Secondly, in the present age, when education is so widespread, the Bible is present in every home and is entirely compiled, if you ask any educated person who has read the Bible once, or even four times, to relate the accounts of the Prophets, he will have forgotten everything; he simply cannot recount them. Ask those of you sitting here, several of whom must have read the Bible. Think about it: leaving the Bible aside, take the Holy Qur’an, which you read again and again every Ramadan. If I ask anyone to tell me the accounts of the Prophets in it, to relate the accounts of all the Prophets right now, you will find that no one remembers the full details. So with whom did the Holy Prophet (saw) secretly meet? And to remember the accounts in such detail is in any case contrary to fact and contrary to reason. And when they are asked, they cannot say who he was, who it was that told him. The Holy Qur’an too has mentioned this allegation. This objection existed in that age as well and has continued until now; it is nothing new.
The third and most important point is that every account the Bible relates contains such absurdities that it cannot possibly be accepted as the Word of God. For example, Hazrat Jacob (as) wrestling with God; or the account of Hazrat Adam (as), how Eve deceived him, how he fell into sin, how the serpent made promises to them and the serpent turned out to be truthful and they turned out to be liars; and the creation of Eve from Adam’s rib. If the Christians had explained these accounts to him, they should have told the Holy Prophet (saw) these things.

The Holy Qur’an has left out every absurd thing. Not a single objectionable thing has entered it, which shows that this is not something taught by Christians at all. The Christians are caught up in these stories today, and the same stories and the same tales were found in the Bible in that age too. Look at the story of the creation of Adam; then Prophets being deceived by their sons and by their wives, the blessing being snatched from one and given to another. It is not just one story; there are so many absurdities. There is not a single account of a Prophet in the Bible that does not contain false and worn-out tales and things contrary to reason and contrary to nature, and the Holy Qur’an has cut out every one of them. This shows that the teachers were not the people who had read these books; the Teacher was someone else.
Another important point is that things about the Prophets of which there is not even a hint in the Bible are also present in the Holy Qur’an. And they are things that no human being of that age knew. Never mind those Jews or Christians; no human being knew them at all, and even in later centuries no one knew them for a long time. For example, in the time of Hazrat Moses (as), the Bible mentions Pharaoh’s pursuit and his drowning. But what Pharaoh said to God as he was drowning, and what answer he was given, is not mentioned even by way of allusion in any book of the Bible. The Holy Qur’an not only preserved this account but stated that, as he was drowning, Pharaoh said to God, ‘O God, today I believe in the Lord of Moses and Aaron; grant me deliverance.’ At this God said to him, ‘Al-ana’: ‘Now you think of deliverance, when the time has passed? Now the time of seizure has come.’ But since he was asking for deliverance out of fear for his body, not out of fear for his soul (for had he sought deliverance out of fear for his soul, he would have sought it when his soul was being warned of destruction), Allah the Exalted spoke to him in a wonderful way, which brings an astonishing eloquence and a special beauty to the passage.

He said: “So this day We will save thee in thy body alone that thou mayest be a Sign to those who come after thee.”
Very well, We grant you deliverance of the kind you seek. You seek deliverance of the body, so We shall preserve your body. And We shall preserve it for this purpose, that it may become a sign of warning for people until the Day of Judgement.
Now, in which Bible is this event recorded? And which human being of that age could have invented this event? For there was no mention at all of Pharaoh’s body. The entire civilisation of Egypt, together with its magnificent buildings in which they lay buried, which are called the pyramids, together with the pyramids of Egypt and all its pomp and glory, lay buried beneath layers of sand. And that was in Egypt; in that region of Arabia those people were completely unknown. And hundreds of years later, no, more than a thousand years later, it was the Christians themselves who discovered these ancient remains and recovered from them the body of that Pharaoh about whom the promise had been made that your body would be preserved as a warning for the generations to come.
Now these Christians ought to be asked which Bible taught this to him, or which human being told him about it. Moreover, this was an event that could not possibly have been proven true in that age. That event was proven true thirteen hundred years later, and through the hostile nations themselves and their own researchers. This shows clearly that the One who taught this Word was some other Being Who was the Knower of the unseen. Otherwise, it is simply not within the power of man.
So, completely rejecting the unnatural events narrated in the Bible, completely rejecting the absurd events of the Bible, adopting from the accounts of the Prophets only those which are beyond the reach of objection, rejecting the worn-out, shameless stories about the Prophets, and then bringing forth things of which there is no mention in the Bible, which man cannot invent, and which are proven true in later ages, all these facts show that the Holy Qur’an was not a book taught by anyone; it was not a book taught by any human being.

10 of 10 left today