7. Is it permissible for the government to seize someone's land and redistribute it to the poor?

Question-and-answer session, 22 June 1986

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it permissible for the government to seize someone's land and redistribute it to the poor? In many of the underdeveloped countries there is a tendency to introduce land reforms whereby land over and above a certain limit is confiscated by the state with a view to redistribute among the poor. I would like to request Huzoor to explain the Islamic point of view in this connection.

Well, Islam does give a measure of power to states to manipulate the wealth in a manner as some people are not totally deprived of the collective benefits of the state. So it cannot be ruled out. But it is not based on the communistic philosophy of dialectic materialism. Other principles govern this.

But now, what is happening in these states to whom, which you are referring, is not this. It is not the welfare of the poor which is motivating this. It is to gain cheap popularity by certain political parties that they vie with each other to play havoc with the concept of of of personal private property and the right of holding private private property. So they are not honest about it, because they such movements are generally supported by the bourgeois, industrialist, and the great tradesmen. So instead of hitting at the industry and trade, they go only to hit the farmer who is defenseless as compared to them, and they go on reducing the number of acreage holding per person, per capita.

And this should, this is generally not done with any wisdom, because the ulterior motive is that of gaining cheap political power, cheap political popularity. The result is that such political parties do not pay attention to what would result from this: Would the economy gain or suffer? Are the conditions ripe for such a measure or not? That is the one main problem which is left out of their consideration.

The result is that sometimes such measures result in smaller and, comparatively, less production than previously. And sometimes it so happens that economically a country is not on a stage where further division of land would be advisable. For instance, when the state is not capable of running, maintaining, and improving large-scale farming, collective farming, with collective machinery, and when as an alternative in the private sector the farmers have a sizable acreage of land which can be developed more in the modern terms, they are capable of holding, owning their own tractors and farm machinery and employ the most modern terms, most modern inventions in this regard, the production per acre in that case would be much higher than the production of an ordinary farmer who who has a smaller holding, who is incapable, economically incapable...

...of owning a tractor, or owning farm machinery, or employing such other inventions of the modern times as are conducive to larger production. Now, this is exactly as the state as prevailing in Pakistan and in some other backward countries. If the gov-, if a political party, for the sake of cheap popularity, further divides the land holding and just arbitrarily takes the land of, chunks of land from some larger holders and distributes it to the ordinary farmers as their own, number one, the problem would be created of this improved farm-, improved style of farming. Those landowners who were capable of running farms on modern scientific bases would be destroyed, and these smallholders will be totally incapable of running the farms on modern bases. Overall production of the country would fall to a great measure, and in ultimate terms, the poor of the country would be left poorer off. Because without production, you can't improve your state of, your your way of life, your your, you know, it's impossible that the overall production is is decreasing in the country and the lot of a common man is improving, this is not possible. So it would be a big loss to the nation as such.

Such measures have been proved to be futile and extremely dangerous and even fatal when carried out in the modern times by some more powerful states than Pakistan and India, for instance. In China, the so-called Green Revolution almost destroyed the entire achievements of the revolution of Mao Tse-tung. That Green Revolution has become a horror word in China because some drastic measures were adopted by the government to improve the farming on the basis of dialectic materialism, and they failed because the economic situation was not ripe... also so low that those in power will also take sides with their relatives and friends while distribution of benefits are are concerned, and those who go into collective farming would try their best to cheat the other partners.

So when the moral standard and education standard is so low, how can you go for the collective farming, which is the only answer left? If you reduce the number of of holdings, then the only answer to improve the farming situation would be to go for collective farming, so that collectively in a larger number of farmers participate in a big farm, though their own personal holdings would yet would remain to be the small holding, but the farm collectively would become big, so they will be capable of employing the modern techniques.

You know, that is the idea. But there are other hindrances in the way of putting this idea into practice in these countries. So it is against wisdom, not only religion. What religion says is that do what is good. I mean, the governments are required to do what is good for the people. If a measure which is carried out in the name of the people is not good for the people, then to that extent it would be irreligious.

But in principle, it cannot be said that the government is not permitted to interfere in the land holdings for for any reason. In fact, if a, if somebody holds large tracts of land which he cannot put to proper use, which he cannot control, with the result that that large holding is causing collective loss of the people in terms of production, according to the to to the Islamic principles, the government not only can interfere in this matter, but it is the duty of the government to interfere and take take away that much land which he cannot control.

And this I am speaking on the authority of An-Hazrat (saw) himself. He said that you are permitted only to hold that much land which you can properly control, and you will not be permitted to hold large land holdings wastefully, just because to you want to satisfy your avarice.

So there are clear-cut principles and the general principles which would provide us guideline in this regard. But the present measures which you are referring to are not healthy measures, in my opinion.

10 of 10 left today