8. When visiting a cemetery, are we premitted to pray the prayer "peace be upon you, oh people of the grave" for non-Muslims as well?
Question-and-answer session, 22 June 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: When visiting a cemetery, are we permitted to pray the prayer "peace be upon you, oh people of the grave" for non-Muslims as well?
Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. Wa alaikumus salam. Regarding what you said about graves, that flowers and such should be placed, I would also like to ask whether in the cemeteries of the English people, too, we should recite this prayer, “Assalamu alaikum ya ahlal qubur” [Peace be upon you, O people of the graves], or should Ahmadis recite it only in Muslim cemeteries?
As for the prayer “Assalamu alaikum ya ahlal qubur”, at the time it was taught, in the time of the Holy Prophet (saw), Muslims used to go to cemeteries and recite this prayer. And it is also established that in many cemeteries where Muslims were buried, polytheists and others had been buried before them as well. Therefore, no distinction in the direction of the prayer was taught at that time. However, the principle was laid down that you should not pray for polytheists once they have died, even if they are your own parents. So, under this principled instruction, it was automatically understood that the prayer would be for those who are generally considered deserving of it. And prejudice was not made to walk such narrow paths that you shake your hand off to one side so that it does not reach them, and shake your hand off to the other side so that it does not reach them, and take aim and hold out your hand saying, ‘The salaam is for these, not for those.’
So why do you now adopt a method that was not adopted at that time, even though polytheists were also buried there? And to say that these are Christian cemeteries here is simply incorrect. These nations have made no such distinction; they are very broad-minded in this matter. In the cemetery I mentioned, Muslims are buried, Hajis are buried, atheists are buried, Hindus are buried, Christians are buried; all kinds of people are buried there. And they have no fear that a nearby corpse will have a bad influence on another corpse, so dig it up and throw it out. So when these other nations are showing such broad-mindedness, Muslims ought to show even greater broad-mindedness.
So your salaam will not reach the wrong place; do not worry.
So it means one should recite it in the cemetery?
You still haven’t understood? The caution continues.