10. Why are two goats sacrified for the birth of a boy while only one goat is sacrificed for the birth of a girl?
Question-and-answer session, 22 June 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why are two goats sacrificed for the birth of a boy while only one goat is sacrificed for the birth of a girl?
When a child is born and its Aqiqah is performed, then generally for boys...
This is a question of midwifery, then?
Pardon?
I said, this is a question of midwifery, then?
No, the child has been born; it can be done afterwards as well.
All right, all right. Yes.
It is about the Aqiqah: for boys two goats are sacrificed and for a girl one. Yet all the other commandments and acts of worship are the same for both men and women?
They are equal. Yes, one reason for it is also that boys receive two shares of the property and a girl receives one.
No, but she receives from the husband’s side...
Why not?
No, Huzur.
From the inheritance — in the division of inheritance the boy gets two and the girl gets one, or the boy gets one and the girl gets half, think of it whichever way you like.
But it balances out, because she also receives from the husband’s side, and the brother...
Well then, that is fine; so there should also be balance in responsibilities, shouldn’t there? Two goats should be given for a boy and one goat for a girl?
No, but it is the parents who perform the Aqiqah, isn’t it?
The inheritance that is divided is also the parents’.
It has not become clear.
This is only a symbol. The fact is that shaving the head and offering a goat, as I had explained, is a symbol of sacrifice. And at the same time it also draws a picture of responsibilities. Why, after all, should the head be shaved? Why should a sacrifice be offered? Have you not noticed that at the time of Hajj we do both of these things? Yes, yes. Even adults shave their heads and offer a sacrifice. And everywhere in the world, not only in Islam, both these concepts are present in connection with dedication. Some peoples who had not even a remote connection with Islam — these are religions that came long before — yes, among them, whether they be monks or others, they shave their heads. And they either offer human sacrifice or animal sacrifice, burnt offerings or others. So this is in fact a message to the parents that you are to dedicate your children to God, and these are the symbols of dedication. Because in the field of Jihad the greater responsibility falls upon the man, and greater sacrifice is taken from him; that is indeed the reality. You cannot change this fact. Yes. Therefore this element is greater in its symbol as well. But in shaving the head, it does not mean that you rub it harder. That will be just the same; the razor will move equally. But in the sacrifice of the goat this aspect becomes prominent, a distinction is made: as far as sacrifice is concerned, comparatively more will be expected of you regarding male children, that you will advance them in sacrifice. Thus, now in the scheme of Waqf-e-Zindagi [life devotion], women, because of their constraints, cannot devote their lives in the way men do, can they?
Many women wish to, Huzur; that is also a point.
And they cannot, so their sacrifice remains half, doesn’t it?
Yes.
So that symbol ought to have been only half as well.
Thank you, Huzur. Jazakallah.