1. Is it true that Muhammad (saw) was able to make the sun rise after it had already set with a wave of his finger?
Question-and-answer session, 27 June 1986
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Is it true that Muhammad was able to make the sun rise after it had already set with a wave of his finger?
As-salamu alaykum, Huzoor. Day before yesterday I was talking to a Shiite Muslim and he quoted a Hadith, according to him, it is from Bukhari, that once the Holy Prophet (saw) was asleep and his head was on the lap of Hazrat Ali, according to him, and while he was asleep the sun set. And when he woke up, it was already Asr prayer time had gone. So he asked him, "Why didn't you wake me up?" So he said, "Because you were deep asleep, so I didn't want to disturb you." Now according to him, he said the Holy Prophet (saw) moved his finger like that. And he was so adamant on this that he said, "Well, this is something which..."
Tell him to show you the reference.
Yes. I was just thinking that...
It's all hocus-pocus. There is nothing, no truth in it whatsoever.
Seemed to me a very learned person, but such a hocus-pocus which I felt was, they very strictly believe in it. Although... So I was just wondering how to sort these people out who have...
You can't. Anybody who believes in anything, how can you sort him out? You can tell him that Aan-Hazrat (saw) is declared to be Uswah Hasanah in the Holy Qur’an, an ideal model for you to follow. So you can pose him the question, "If you do follow him, you follow him in this respect as well, please, and move your finger. And if you can't bring the entire sun back, only bring the very small rim of the sun back, because, of course, you can't fully follow him, entirely follow him, but at least to this degree you can follow him."
Tell him in whatever we believe about him, we can prove that we can follow him. There is nothing barred from us. We can't say the prayer of that quality, of course, but somewhat we can have the pleasure of following him to a certain degree. In everything which he did, we can follow him to a certain degree except for where Allah has categorically told us that this is for him and not for you: min doonil mo'mineen. These are a few places where Allah has mentioned it. But in this case, it doesn't apply. So, if he believes in him truly to have done that, then he should be able to repeat it to a little extent, because no superhuman model could be created for man. This is the simple logic of this. Superhuman models should be for superhuman beings. Human model is for human beings. So, this incident does not relate to a human model at all.