3. [Beginning missing] What the Holy Qur’an mentions shows that one sect (of the Christians) remained on the original faith for a very long time … I meant that their zeal for preaching continues to this day, while Muslims stopped preaching after a few years, so that today their preaching has no influence on any nation, because they had found an easy way of making Muslims by force – why trouble themselves when they could bring Islam into hearts with the sword?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: [Beginning missing] What the Holy Qur’an mentions shows that one sect (of the Christians) remained on the original faith for a very long time … I meant that their zeal for preaching continues to this day, while Muslims stopped preaching after a few years, so that today their preaching has no influence on any nation, because they had found an easy way of making Muslims by force – why trouble themselves when they could bring Islam into hearts with the sword?

Even when Islam came, such a sect was found around Medina and in Arabia, purely monotheistic, accepting Hazrat Jesus (as) as a prophet; the vast majority of them was absorbed into Islam. Besides, it is not correct that they [Muslims] stopped. The impression in your mind is due to the noise of the mullahs. The fact is that Islam spread through preaching; nobody became Muslim through their sword. Even European critics have written books; recently I received a book on the spread of Islam in which a European orientalist, with maps, states that it is completely wrong to say it spread by the force of governments. In the times of those governments it was Muslim Sufis, dervishes, preachers and traders who spread Islam on their own. For several hundred years, even under Muslim rule, the number of non-Muslims in some Muslim countries remained the same, unaffected, and no one said anything to them. In the time of Mamun and Harun there were even debates at their court, where they stated their position and refused to become Muslim under pressure. So it is wrong that Muslims gave up preaching. A particular class of ulama gave fatwas to have others and Muslims killed; their fatwas of coercion operated throughout Islamic history against Muslims. The preaching class was not the mullahs but Sufis, saintly people or traders, whose preaching continued uninterrupted. How did Indonesia come about, China? Neither a mullah nor a sword reached there. Malaysia – all came about through the preaching of ordinary Muslims. [On mention of Arnold:] I have not seen that, but you are telling me; I will look, it seems a good book. Arnold also wrote on the same position with strong examples. The book I mention has very detailed data and charts for every century: Islamic rule had reached here, but Islam was confined only here, without influence. It also examines Spain, how Islam spread there, and says it spread through the people.

10 of 10 left today