4. Hazrat, a friend of mine in Libya, Kamran Bakht from Jhelum, gave me two questions before I came. He cites Sura Al-Baqarah, verses four and five: those who believe in what was revealed to the Holy Prophet (saw) and what was revealed before him, and believe in the Hereafter – they are on guidance from their Lord and they are the successful. He asks: what is the verdict of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat about a person who does not believe in Mirza Sahib but believes in this verse? He has heard that the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat does not even offer the funeral prayer of such a person, on the grounds that he did not accept Mirza Sahib as a prophet. Is this not something new added to the religion after the founding of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 August 1986

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Hazrat, a friend of mine in Libya, Kamran Bakht from Jhelum, gave me two questions before I came. He cites Sura Al-Baqarah, verses four and five: those who believe in what was revealed to the Holy Prophet (saw) and what was revealed before him, and believe in the Hereafter – they are on guidance from their Lord and they are the successful. He asks: what is the verdict of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat about a person who does not believe in Mirza Sahib but believes in this verse? He has heard that the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat does not even offer the funeral prayer of such a person, on the grounds that he did not accept Mirza Sahib as a prophet. Is this not something new added to the religion after the founding of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat?

[Question: what did you answer? – Reply: he had written a day before.] The answer to the first question is that 'wa ma unzila ilaika' contains everything we hold. If someone believes in the Holy Prophet (saw) according to this verse, in everything revealed to him, then the only issue is: if the Holy Prophet (saw) prophesied the coming of someone and a person does not believe in him, how can his belief in 'wa ma unzila ilaika' be true? That is why the only position of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is that he [the Promised Messiah (as)] is the fulfilment of the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (saw). Then the claim to be within 'wa ma unzila ilaika' while rejecting some statements of the Holy Prophet (saw) would be false. That is why the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat says no new prophet can come who is outside the command of the Holy Prophet (saw), because he would fall outside 'wa ma unzila ilaika'. Understood? For the perfection of the Shariah, and to show that no one can come outside the command of the Holy Prophet (saw), faith was set up to 'bima unzila ilaika'. But if within this 'unzila' there are matters such as 'believe in so-and-so', and the Holy Prophet (saw) said that when the Imam Mahdi appears, go and pledge allegiance to him even if you must crawl on your knees over ice – what will they say then? They claim to fulfil 'bima unzila ilaika', yet say: this statement of the Holy Prophet (saw) we will not accept. He said the Messiah will descend – they say we will not accept it; the Mahdi will come – we will not accept it; yet they invoke 'bima unzila ilaika'. If they do not accept the reformers, what then remains? Understood?

10 of 10 left today